To Punch or Not to Punch, That is the Question

Having done heavy bagwork bareknuckle, I realized why traditional martial arts have a lot of different strikes. If my knuckles start to get sore, I switch to a different strike, such as a palm strike or even a ridgehand.

I categorize strikes along two axes:
  • How effective it is with minimal training
  • How safe it is with minimal training
Let's look at an example of each of four options:
  • A spearhand thrust is generally more dangerous to your fingers than to the target (unless you've trained it well)
  • A punch is dangerous to your opponent, but also dangerous for your hand
    • Note: I think punches to the body are better, because you're hitting softer tissue, it's fist-on-skull that's the big problem. This is also why bareknuckle boxers of the 16th-19th centuries typically focused on body punches.
  • A backfist strike generates less power and so is safer for your hand, but does less damage
  • A palm strike is generally safe to use, and deals damage pretty effectively.
Using this concept, I've identified what I think are beginner, intermediate, and advanced techniques.
  • Beginner techniques are those that are highly effective and relatively safe, including: body punches, palm strikes, knees, elbows, hammerfist, knife-hand strikes
  • Intermediate techniques are those that are either highly effective and a little risky, or maybe not as effective but easier to use, such as backfists, head punches, and ridgehand strikes.
  • Advanced techniques are those that pose high risk and are more difficult to apply successfully, such as a spearhand or claw hand.
I realize this is a Karate thread, but if I were developing a TKD curriculum, I would layer hand strikes in this way, and focus on the high/high techniques in the lower belts, high/low and low/high techniques in the intermediate belts, and low/low techniques at the upper belts. If I were developing a HKD curriculum more focused on self-defense, I'd probably just leave it at high/high and focus the upper belts on grappling skills.
 
I just watched this yesterday. I like his analysis however I'd punch 100% if it was self defense. We don't have to worry "as much" about some of the consequences like amputation from infection. It does make you think a bit more about hitting soft targets.

As far as the backfist I think its a decent nose breaker. sure it could go bad and you hit teeth or something by accident but you also don't have to throw 100% if the intent is a nose break and not a knockout.

For whatever reason I hate straight in palmheel strikes (ie nose strike). They just mess up my wrists. A slap or openhanded strike from the side can be quite effective though. I like the ridgehand too.
 
I just watched this yesterday. I like his analysis however I'd punch 100% if it was self defense.
Yes I think that’d be most people with a bit of MA training’s reflex.
We don't have to worry "as much" about some of the consequences like amputation from infection. It does make you think a bit more about hitting soft targets.
If you have insurance (or live in the UK) 😉
As far as the backfist I think its a decent nose breaker. sure it could go bad and you hit teeth or something by accident but you also don't have to throw 100% if the intent is a nose break and not a knockout.
I alway used uraken as a painful distraction before unleashing my biting techniques.
For whatever reason I hate straight in palmheel strikes (ie nose strike). They just mess up my wrists.
Do you have limited wrist extension?
A slap or openhanded strike from the side can be quite effective though.
Yes I remember being taught a technique called haishū uchi which is a whipping strike with back of an open floppy hand to the face/eyes.
I like the ridgehand too.
Yes, haitō is very strong!
 

Latest Discussions

Back
Top