Arrow punches/chain punches

[Xue Sheng96]

sounds like you make trouble and got outed as a fake martial artist

Ahh. More unfounded accusations to try and redirect and get a rise out of me.. didn’t work

And nope, just not buying what you’re selling. Been training martial arts since 1972, meant a few folks that post on MT. But I was in their vicinity, or they were in mine. Not likely I will be paying the money for a 6 hour flight and paying for accommodation so another safe bet on your part. So thanks for the invite, but hard pass on that.

 

[BorntoRaiseHell]

Ahh. More unfounded accusations to try and redirect and get a rise out of me.. didn’t work

And nope, just not buying what you’re selling. Been training martial arts since 1972, meant a few folks that post on MT. But I was in their vicinity, or they were in mine. Not likely I will be paying the money for a 6 hour flight and paying for accommodation so another safe bet on your part. So thanks for the invite, but hard pass on that.

Well it was my offer to speak to you but I guess you have your reasons for not backing up your talk on here.

 

[Xue Sheng96]

Well it was my offer to speak to you but I guess you have your reasons for not backing up your talk on here.

You are funny, that offer is laughable, I pay thousands of dollars, take time off from work, to fly 6 hours, book a hotel, to get you to answer a simple question you could have easily answered here. And if for some reason I did lose my mind and fall for this it is more than likely you wouldn’t be there. Tell you what I will be in Xi’an in May, feel free to stop by and answer the questions, you know the, ‘did you actually watch the video’, ‘what school do you train at’, ‘have you ever really trained JKD’ . Should be worth it, I mean you’re the one making the claims, I’m not, so the proof is on you, just hop on over to Xi’an in a few months and we can discuss over tea…. I have nothing to back up, I’m not the one making claims of training and I’m not the one who is not answering questions, you are….see you in Xi’an in the spring, but if you miss me there I will also be in Beijing, possibly Shanghai and Seoul for a layover. Should not be a problem finding me with no address in any of those massive cities….

 

[isshinryuronin]

You are funny, that offer is laughable, I pay thousands of dollars, take time off from work, to fly 6 hours, book a hotel, to get you to answer a simple question you could have easily answered here. And if for some reason I did lose my mind and fall for this it is more than likely you wouldn’t be there. Tell you what I will be in Xi’an in May, feel free to stop by and answer the questions, you know the, ‘did you actually watch the video’, ‘what school do you train at’, ‘have you ever really trained JKD’ . Should be worth it, I mean you’re the one making the claims, I’m not, so the proof is on you, just hop on over to Xi’an in a few months and we can discuss over tea…. I have nothing to back up, I’m not the one making claims of training and I’m not the one who is not answering questions, you are….see you in Xi’an in the spring, but if you miss me there I will also be in Beijing, possibly Shanghai and Seoul for a layover. Should not be a problem finding me with no address in any of those massive cities….

The poster's name can tell you a lot. Sounds like he's in his teens.

 

[Xue Sheng96]

The poster's name can tell you a lot. Sounds like he's in his teens.

I seriously doubt he is as old as his MT info page says he is

 

[Kung Fu Wang103]

how effective do you think these are in a real fight? i like that in JKD we use western Boxing which i find more effective
Bruce knew what worked !

thoughts ?

Who will win when you use jab and cross chain punch and your opponent uses left and right hook. The double hooks can knock off jab/cross. But the jab/cross cannot knock off double hooks.

 

[drop bear103]

WC does not move like a Boxer.. maybe you´ve never done western boxing
Bobbing, weaving & the footwork is totally different to WC

Yeah. But that bobing weaving and footwork lets people apply wing chun principles better.

Lomenchemco is possibly still the best guy to follow if you wanted to make wing chun work.

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

how effective do you think these are in a real fight? i like that in JKD we use western Boxing which i find more effective
Bruce knew what worked !

thoughts ?

Let’s talk about Mr Lees fight record in regards to “what works”.

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

Agreed, I however I have seen some Wing Chun practitioners place to much emphasis on the chain punch…. Thanks to, IMO, any of the Ip Man related movies

Nah I’ve seen that garbage 20 years ago. Way before those crap movies.

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

If you look at Bruce in older film footage..i would say he moves more like a western fighter than a chinese WC man
Hong Kong roof top fighting in the 50s & 60s between 2 chinese guys is not like fighting a western man trained in Boxing
Bruce quickly knew this & adapted

Bruce did roof top fighting in the 50s and 60s?

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

let´s meet and discuss it

I’m in Northern California, Mckinleyville to be exact. You can find me anytime you like. I don’t practice Wing Chun or JKD though so probably not in your interest.

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

Well it was my offer to speak to you but I guess you have your reasons for not backing up your talk on here.

Challenges are not allowed per MT rules. Just fyi

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

The poster's name can tell you a lot. Sounds like he's in his teens.

Not with that beat tattoo he isn’t.

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

I seriously doubt he is as old as his MT info page says he is

That old beat tattoo tells you he is.

 

[HighKick1]

That old beat tattoo tells you he is.

I would say there is a 50/50 chance that is not even hit tattoo. Stock photo.

 

[Monkey Turned Wolf103]

I would say there is a 50/50 chance that is not even hit tattoo. Stock photo.

It looks like one, but a reverse image search did not find anything

 

[Xue Sheng96]

That old beat tattoo tells you he is.

if that is even his, you can find them on the internet

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

if that is even his, you can find them on the internet

It’s a common flash. Vintage Americana style tattoo still popular amongst the vintage crowd. I have an appreciation considering its roots. Not my personal taste, but an important style of tattooing history. I love tattoo of all kinds, it’s the people that wear them that can be tiresome and troubling…

 

[Wing Woo Gar37]

if that is even his, you can find them on the internet

Honestly, if he was going to post a picture of a tattoo that wasn’t his, don’t you think it would be a better example? I think I gotta believe it’s his.

 

[Xue Sheng96]

Honestly, if he was going to post a picture of a tattoo that wasn’t his, don’t you think it would be a better example? I think I gotta believe it’s his.

After about 10 years in security and 30 years working for the Gov, I'm way to cynical to believe much