The Best Martial Art

Touch Of Death

Sr. Grandmaster
MTS Alumni
Joined
May 6, 2003
Messages
11,610
Reaction score
845
Location
Spokane Valley WA
no such thing as a superior art.

there are superior teachers, superior students, and superior combinations of a particular art with an individual's traits.

but there is no such thing as a superior art.
Sure there is. Each school does what it does well and probably better than the other guy whom concentrates on the aspect they are good at.
Sean
 

charyuop

Black Belt
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
659
Reaction score
14
Location
Ponca City, Oklahoma
So you would argue that Aikido is well suited for Brawling?

I don't think you will find many brawlers that will agree with that. Different arts are suited for different things. Aikido has its strengths, brawling is not one of them.
First of all, I would like to see a civilized fight coz all the fights I have ever seen there is alot of anger and rage in them. But even considering that...

The difference between North ans South style kung fu is basically the use of the legs. I read somewhere once an explaination for this difference. In north China people were more horse riders, thus they use more leg work, while in the south people were more fishermen thus they used less the legs because they needed to be well grounded on thir boats. Does that mean if someone who uses mainly legs fights on a boat will lose by default??
No, it is up to the practitioner's inteligence to see the condition of the surroundings and adapt to it.
Mind I am not trying to defend Aikido because I practice it, I would say this for every Martial Art which survived years and years showing it has a value. Saying that certain Martial Arts are suited for certain situations and others for other situations means considering that Martial Art dead. A Martial Art to be considered alive must have a good adaptation and evolution. Many Arts do not practice alot against many attackers how for example Aikido and BaGua do. Does that mean if you do another Martial Art you are dead Vs 2 or 3 people?

Of course I might be wrong. So if you tell me that certain Martial Arts are only for certain events and you can give me some example I will be willing to change my mind.
 

still learning

Senior Master
Joined
Nov 8, 2004
Messages
3,749
Reaction score
43
Hello, The BEST martial arts are the ones, that teach you to be humble and kind. (Help keep your EGO and pride in the right place).
Learn to avoid an negative situtions, awareness, and not to be in a dangerous place. (sometimes no choice)

The best teacheres teach you real skills for defending one self, but the learner must be able to apply themselves.

The best art (may be inside of you?)........Aloha
 

HG1

Blue Belt
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
234
Reaction score
6
Location
USA
The best Martial Art is the one where you fit, it fills your needs, and inspires you to continue training week-after-week; year-after-year. It can have the best skill sets out there, but if you have to drag yourself through the door every training time, it stinks for you personally. I know this isn't really the answer you were looking for, but it is the best I can answer.
You got it right - good answer.
 

Last Fearner

2nd Black Belt
Joined
Jan 21, 2006
Messages
712
Reaction score
17
So...my question is: Is there an art out there thats the best?

The answer is YES.

Now I will explain, but first let me clarify what has already been stated here.

"Best" is a relative term depending on desired outcome; "goals," and one's ability to achieve those goals in the most desirable fashion.

Yes.

Which one depends on your goals and natural abilities.

Although I don't agree it is "natural" abilities, but skills that you learn which either enhance your natural abilities, or compensate for a lack thereof.

This is why no art can really be the best unless you specify best for what, then something can be the best, and others can be poor for that goal.

Mr Green, you really have to stop giving the best answers, or you make it difficult for me to sound smart! :)

Ok - - If your goal is to become a better person, or learn spiritual enlightenment, or win tournaments, or beat up every person you don't like, then your method of training might vary from other people. If your goal is to survive in life, and not get killed, beat up, or otherwise victimized, then your goal is specific enough that I can answer this question.

The "best Art" for the goal of survival in the real world is presented below in a list starting with the best at the number one position and moving down in desirability to the bottom of the list.

1. The "art" of avoidance: If you are not there, they can not hurt you. Avoid situations that are inherently dangerous or risky, and avoid people who tend to be violent, attract violence, or are strangers you don't trust. This means you are going to have to be alert, and aware of your surroundings. The next part of this "art" is what to do if you did not successfully avoid the situation or person. Then, you must avoid contact. Distance, evade, and maneuver so that your attacker can not strike you, touch you, or grab you (or assault you with a weapon). Run away, talk your way out of it, or move quicker than they do (reading telegraphed movements helps here). The "art of avoidance" is the best and most ideal response to any given situation, but since it is not always possible, we move on to number two.

2. The "art" of deception: Here is where you fake the person out. Make them think you are very deadly, or sick :barf: , or crazy, or drunk, or pregnant (for the ladies :) ). Make them believe you are slow, then become fast. Make them believe you are tired and ready to drop, then come alive! Make them think you are within their range, or that you are going to stand still, move back, go left, right, closer, jump, or duck, then do something totally different. For striking them, make them think you are going to punch, then kick, or vice-versa. Make them think you are going low, then go high instead. If contact occurs, make them think you are going to push, but then you pull, etc, etc. "Deception" is also known as "sneakiness."

3. The "art" of T.A.P.: "TAP" is Timing, Accuracy, and Power. If you are able to avoid getting hit, grabbed or taken down, or if you find yourself in a bad predicament, then the final thing is that you must be able to execute your technique with ideal Timing (when to move and when not to), Accuracy (don't miss), and Power (if it don't hurt, immobilize, project your opponent away, damage or destroy, it won't work).

We also have to remember the skill of "common sense." You have to know when it is time to get the heck out of Dodge! Know when the fight is over, whey you are out-numbered, in danger of weapons, and when it is time to split - - distance yourself - - avoid further conflict, which leads us back to number one - the "art of avoidance."

In reality, none of what I listed above is an "art" by Martial Art definition. they are skills which should be incorporated into all Martial Art training. In addition to whichever specific "tools" or techniques you choose to apply in step 3, this is what Martial Art self defense is.

In fact, the answer to the question, "What is the best Art?"

Answer - - "The Martial Art"

Whatever you want to call it. Apply steps one through three first, then be highly skilled at the specific techniques you apply and you will have the "best" art!

Oh....One More Thing....

Aikido type stuff is great for "civilized" encounters... meaning you just need to inflict a little pain and control without anyone really getting hurt to hopefully diffuse things.
Aikido has its strengths, brawling is not one of them.

Oooops! You missed it on that one! :)

Like any system of self defense, it will depend greatly on the skill level of the person applying the art. A novice person in Taekwondo, Judo, Karate, BJJ, or anything else might give a poor showing of what their art really is capable of. In the hands of a Master, Aikido is very effective for any situation! Think of the masterful application of Aikido as the forces of the wind and the water in nature (hurricanes, tornados, typhoons, mud slides, avalanches, flash floods, and even hail storms). There is not any human being, animal, natural object, or man made structure that can withstand these forces. Aikido, when properly applied, can redirect you, spin you around, lift you up, and slam you into anything, anywhere. It can hit you with strong forces, or suck you in and spit you out. You can strike at the wind or water and hit nothing as it parts and surrounds you, then it will turn to a solid sheet and smack you down or take your feet out from under you.

Never underestimate Aikido because of the basic performances by beginner students and low ranking Black Belts.

CM D.J. Eisenhart
 

Adept

Master Black Belt
Joined
Nov 6, 2004
Messages
1,225
Reaction score
12
Location
Melbourne, Australia
I would say the best martial art is the one that does not limit itself in terms of techniques or applications, and trains in a realistic and 'live' manner.

Any art or teacher who says "That is not part of XYZ" is a poor one, IMHO.
 
Top