Worst/Weirdest Martial Arts for self defence?
- Thread starter smiller2144
- Start date
what can I say if not "I see sloppy Aikido and worse Shotokan.
I sure wish they made Shotokan guys like that back in my day. Would have saved me a whole bunch of broken ribs.
As for weirdest Martial Art - I have never actually seen anyone doing Monkey Kung Fu. I've only seen it in magazines years ago, so I have no idea what the hell I'm talking about (nothing new there) but if I were to lose a fight to a practioner of that art my friends would make my life miserable.
As for weirdest Martial Art - I have never actually seen anyone doing Monkey Kung Fu. I've only seen it in magazines years ago, so I have no idea what the hell I'm talking about (nothing new there) but if I were to lose a fight to a practioner of that art my friends would make my life miserable.
Cirdan
Senior Master
THAT is the most awesome thing I've ever seen in Martial Arts. How could I not have been aware of this before. Thanks for posting that, Cirdan, I needed some sunshine this morning!
I think somebody suffered too many blows to the head.
Gosh we are all going to grovel when it's proved to be true aren't we on ...May 12, 4025 A.D., we won't be mocking then..oh wait...
Cirdan
Senior Master
And of course Viking Berzerker Arts, the best art at EVERYTHING. (this is true of course, Hail Odin rarrhh!!)
BERZERKER Viking Fighting Arts Grandmaster Sven S. Svensson
BERZERKER Viking Fighting Arts Grandmaster Sven S. Svensson
I would have to say TKD in its current state. There was a time when TKD had a lot of respect as a fighting art. But not so much anymore. It's an entertaining Olympic sport but I wouldn't count on it in a serious street fight. Too many 10 year old black belts to take it seriously.
You're painting TKD with a brush that is far too wide. We have zero baby black belts in our program. And we're far from the only school teaching TKD without any interest whatsoever in the Olympic sport.
I teach TKD and rely on it in physical confrontations in the ER all the time. And I do so with TKD "in its current state".
Last edited:
Gnarlie
Master of Arts
Not a balanced appraisal.
There are plenty of aspects of Taekwondo that are viable for self defence application.
Maybe you're looking in the wrong places.
Incidentally, we do have poom grades in our group i.e. Provisional first dans under the age of 16. Their poom grade, and the expectations at testing are different to those of an adult dan grade, and they are trained separately. I don't see this as a bad thing. At the moment, they know the forms and basic punch kick block techniques. Over the next fifteen to twenty years, they will become highly competent as the leaders of our art. It's a form of succession planning.
The adults in our group certainly have the tools to defend themselves.
Maybe you should get out more.
Any art that has a program called 'Rape the rapist" is something to watch out for.
My observations are based on my "getting out" over the past 41 years in Martial Arts.
Yes it could be said I'm painting TKD with a broad brush. But I'm painting with my understanding of what I witnessed and experienced over many years. I'm sure everyone on this board could be accused of the same thing regarding various arts.
If you read the title of the thread, it's obvious that every response is going to be an opinion. And that's my opinion. Right or wrong. Regardless of hurt feelings.
If you read the title of the thread, it's obvious that every response is going to be an opinion. And that's my opinion. Right or wrong. Regardless of hurt feelings.
Gnarlie
Master of Arts
Wrong, in this case.
Similar threads
