Hello! I came across this guy's channel on y-tube. He rants about all kinds of MAs and says they don't work.
He also says Wing Chun is useless. He says that wing chun only works against other wing chun guys.
He also claims that the wing chun stance sucks and that by standing this way you invite being hit to the head.
Can you take a few mins and listen what he says and then comment on it?
What concerns me is that he says wing chun only works against other wing chun guys. This argument
might hold water. After all how are you supposed to pressure test your wing chun? The only way to test
it would be to go to a boxing class or a jiu jitsu class and then challenge the people there.
I doubt that wing chun schools invite fighters from other martial arts to visit them and to fight against their
students to see who'd win.
How do you guys know that your stuff really works? Do you pick fights every now and then to see if you can actually defend yourself?
Just think about it. What if you feel that you're good at wing chun and you can defend yourself against everybody in your school and you can do all this stuff, like fighting blind folded, and you really feel confident and then one day you get in a real fight and then you realize that the attacker acts totally different than your wing chun training buddy and suddenly none of the techniques you practiced can even be applied and you are totally shocked and freeze on the spot? That would be a real nightmare.
He also says Wing Chun is useless. He says that wing chun only works against other wing chun guys.
He also claims that the wing chun stance sucks and that by standing this way you invite being hit to the head.
Can you take a few mins and listen what he says and then comment on it?
What concerns me is that he says wing chun only works against other wing chun guys. This argument
might hold water. After all how are you supposed to pressure test your wing chun? The only way to test
it would be to go to a boxing class or a jiu jitsu class and then challenge the people there.
I doubt that wing chun schools invite fighters from other martial arts to visit them and to fight against their
students to see who'd win.
How do you guys know that your stuff really works? Do you pick fights every now and then to see if you can actually defend yourself?
Just think about it. What if you feel that you're good at wing chun and you can defend yourself against everybody in your school and you can do all this stuff, like fighting blind folded, and you really feel confident and then one day you get in a real fight and then you realize that the attacker acts totally different than your wing chun training buddy and suddenly none of the techniques you practiced can even be applied and you are totally shocked and freeze on the spot? That would be a real nightmare.