I had noticed that about the different species, on the websites, the characteristics as described seemed pretty consistent.
One thing I did notice was that the hickory species are not resistant to insect attacks, or weather, so definitely need to finish the work with some kind of sealant and protect it. I had made a hiking staff, and it occurred to me that someone could be on a multi-day hiking/camping trek and could be in wet weather for several days at a time. Would hate to see the staff begin to deteriorate if everything stays wet for a while.
I finished a leftover piece with teak oil, and with a combo of teak oil and linseed oil then stuck the end of it in a bucket of water and left it for 24 hours to test it. It came out pretty well, didn’t seem to harm it after I got it dried off again. I figured that was a pretty good test.