Nope i just know history...taiji is lost art long time ago..today is random upgraded style.
Repeated movements in the first form
- Thread starter SifuBoza
- Start date
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
Moy Yat only does 2 fook sao.
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
If you do something several times, it is probably because it is important. The fook sao must be properly structured with the elbow in and at the centerline so the proper form is critical because of how important the fook sao is for controlling the centerline. Think of how easy a fook sao could turn into a fist, and how it can also prevent an opponent striking you with a joot sao and leaves you a clean target.
Only 1 tan sao in SLT? Lemme think...actually I counted 4 tan sao's in SLT:
-The 2nd move goes through a cross-armed partial double tan sao when coming up from the first movement
-After the chung kuen
-After the pak sao/chang geng
-The 1st tan sao after the pak sao/chang-geng goes to gum sao then back to tan sao
BTW Chum Kiu say 'sup...8 double tan sao, 6 upward tan sao, 12 bong sao with 6 of them going from bong sao to tan sao!
Probably important.
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
All the lineages are real, what kind of question is that? Some of his students evolved it a bit such as Wong Shun Leung who added kicks but in general, you are just learning the alphabet from different teachers who were students of the same headmaster. As you know, handwriting can vary here and there, even when taught by the same teacher.
Just go a class and you'll see that the sihing are not all identical in their application.
As Sifu says (who was trained by Ip Man's son Ip Ching): "we teach you the alphabet and you write your story". It's not combo's 1-10.
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
My 9 lives cat might be able to pull that off lol.
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
good catch.
obi_juan_salami
Green Belt
whoa there cowboy. If you read the messages previous to my question in the thread, you would see I was asking SifuBoza based on statements he made on the matter. I wasnt saying there is a 'real' yip man style.
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
Ain't a cowboy but you can definitely say "whoa tiger" lol. I saw a bit of that exchange but I'll be happy to take it back from your direction if I have misunderstood or saw it the wrong way.
OffendedOnyx
Yellow Belt
A couple major reasons.
The first reason is that there are very important and distinct applications. Think of it like a dictionary word...same (spelling/hand position), with a different (definition/application)
Rock paper scissors?
The second reason is that there are very important transitions that commonly happen due to movement logic. Someone goes rock than paper...so you go paper than scissors...assuming you want to survive of course
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
Are you on the first form currently (Siu Lim Tao)? The reason I ask is because movements are repeated in all of the 3 forms.
The most repeated in the first form is obviously the woo sao or "protecting hand", which is done 8X (6X in Moy Yat lineage)...does this need further explanation? The fook sao or "controlling hand" would be next, which is 6X (4X in the Moy Yat lineage) and all is essentially to maintain focus of the centerline. Being that the fook sao is the "controlling hand", it can be used to lock the top of your wrist on to the opponent's but if you dig deeper it actually it roots the structure of the forearm as a pointer for the centerline on a controlled and relaxed manner.
Here is a great short video by Sifu Adam Williss that explains the CONCEPT of the fook sao:
What is a Fook Sao? | eWingChun
I think it would also be remiss to emphasize the importance of fook sao-jut sao as a means of controlling, deflecting and creating openings. Though this is where we don't put ourselves into a box.
We can also talk about perhaps the most repeated movement in overall in all forms is the huen sao or "circling hand". This movement can save you from many situations and is critical to grasp correctly (both inward and outward and especially from the tan sao to fook sao position as if you disconnect you leave yourself wide open).
In any case, since you asked specifically about the first form, here is an excellent explanation of Siu Lim Tao by GM Shu Chong Tin (who was nicknamed "Siu Lim Tao" by Ip Man):
Siu Nim Tao Explained by Grandmaster Chu Shong Tin
Learning Siu Nim Tao is divided into three stages. Firstly, one must relax the muscles of the whole body. Then, he should infuse the spirit..
mindfulwingchun.online
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
I have to agree here, the huen sao is an excellent technique for both gaining leverage as well as escaping holds that will result in large openings, not to mention huen sao to lop sao. Its not just a wrist exercise though it does condition your brain and wrist on applying the technique.
Also 100 on the tan sao. It truly shows the importance of understanding every movement of SLT or you just don't know wth you doing. In any case, perhaps our Wing Chun brother forgot about the double tan sao after the jum sao as well as the tan sao, gan sao, huen sao, palm strike before the bong sao to tan sao. That's definitely more than one!
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
Afrer seeing this again, silly me I forgot to add the bong sao to tan sao!
When talking about
- boxing, people will address offense skill such as jab, cross, hook, uppercut, overhand, ...
- TKD, people will address offense skill such as front kick, side kick, roundhouse kick, hook kick, ...
- Judo, people will address offense skill such as hip throw, leg lift, front cut, inner hook, ...
- WC, people will address defense skill such as Tan Shou, Fu Shou, Bong Shou, ...
Why?
- boxing, people will address offense skill such as jab, cross, hook, uppercut, overhand, ...
- TKD, people will address offense skill such as front kick, side kick, roundhouse kick, hook kick, ...
- Judo, people will address offense skill such as hip throw, leg lift, front cut, inner hook, ...
- WC, people will address defense skill such as Tan Shou, Fu Shou, Bong Shou, ...
Why?
OffendedOnyx
Yellow Belt
Because they deserve general answers because of the nature of the of the question from the recievers end.
Some people psychology and psych bearings work...because they run a meritocracy...
Other ppl could care less and just generally roll with the punches
Like the question you just asked
When a WC guy lands his fist on his opponent's face, he is not using Tan, Fu, or Bong.
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
It is because they are a part of the system and many people, especially when first starting probably will not grasp the concepts of what they are doing or the application. It is a very unique art.
Nobody typically (or at least competently) needs to ask the purpose or concept of chung kuen or lin wah kuen, biu sao, chang sao/dai chang sao, man/shat geng sao, various jeong, or the kicks in Chum Kiu or the biu jee etc. as they are rather self-evident offensive strikes, some of them brutal.
When someone first learns the bong sao for example, they are probably wondering wtf they are doing until their Sifu throw a strike at them and asks them to form a bong. Then the light goes on!
Furthermore, your perspective is flawed. Just because people ask about them, it doesn't change the fundamental core concept of Wing Chun and the one term to remember "Siu Lin Di Da", which is simultaneously deflecting and attacking. This is why we wouldn't just put up a tan sao for an incoming strike but both a tan sao and a strike or a bong sao and a strike at the same time with quick biu ma and continuing forward pressure.
I mean you didn't seriously think that one would just sit there and only put up tans and bongs all day against an aggressor right? Every form in Wing Chun has multiple offensive strikes and techniques.
Finally, in every single martial art you mentioned there are core fundamentals defensive techniques and concepts. My 4yo son is in Tae Kwon Doe and and he learned the in block, out block, high block, low block, up block when he was 2yo. He also learned breakfalls.
You mentioned Judo and offense, it is really too bad that many or perhaps most schools no longer teach Artemi-waza strikes these days. Though they definitely have defensive techniques, such as the uke (blocks) and ukemi (breakfalls).
As for boxing, my best friend is a boxing coach, and to suggest boxing has no defense is absurd, all due respect. Parry, shoulder roll, ducking, bobbing, weaving, gloves covering the side of the face to block hooks, "peekaboo", and why is it do you think commentators say "slipped a nice jab through the GUARD"? Guard definition: "to protect against damage or harm".
wckf92
Master of Arts
I'm not sure.
But IMO it's a mindset that traces back to how one was trained. When I think of those terms you mentioned, to me those are linked to offensive, not defensive.
wckf92
Master of Arts
This is a narrow-minded statement.
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
The beauty of it is that they can be both. The tan sao is meant to control the outside line, inside the opponent's arm. If you put some forward motion into it and land your elbow or just above where the big bone runs down your forearm hard into your opponent's bicep from an incoming strike, it will hurt like hell and can weaken their arm. Also, since we punch/strike with our other arm at the same time, the tan sao arm is in a prime position to throw a follow up strike.
The bong sao shouldn't be the primary option but is an excellent technique for deflecting, and for protecting when transitioning. It can also be used to apply forward pressure into your opponent with your forearm and if you are in close you can put up a bong sao right under an opponent's chin to setup a finishing strike, especially to the throat. Also can turn a bong sao into an elbow strike or a biu sao.
The biomechanics are truly fascinating.
WingChunIsNoSport
Yellow Belt
Agree. You may and likely would be using either of the techniques simultaneously with a punch.
