And by that line of logic, everything negative we do can be related to stress. If I go out and rob someone it is due to stress of not having money. If I go out and rape someone is this due to stress not having any sex at home? I will concede that stress can trigger impulsive behavior but to allow it as an excuse on deliberate attacks or crime of opportunity opens up a floodgate for criminals to have something to blame their actions on.
Their are morals and values not being executed here. Even though the parents claim that this is not like him at all to do such a thing, he was intelligent enough to know what he was doing while he was doing it.
And now you are Exaggerating.
By Your Logic, this would mean that we should just ignore the existance of a Psychological Effect which can lead to;
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronic_stress#Symptoms
So as to keep this Reply nice and short.
I never said he wouldnt know what he was doing.
But might one not say that an Attempted Suicide is a lack of the Base Human Instinct of Self Preservation, as well as a Lack of Morals for the People it would effect?
Ever seen someone put their Hand into a Solid Wall out of Anger?
Throw something accross a Room?
Shout at someone?
Smack their Head into something?
Panic Attacks?
They must all lack Morals and Values then, those Insane People.
Optionally, I could refer back to
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aggression#Culture.
Humans are Naturally Hostile.
We LEARN Self Control.
But Ultimately, theres still Violence. And Crime.
It doesnt make the Perpetrators lacking some Human Value.
Now, despite what you seem to have concluded, Stress isnt a Magical Card People can Draw when they have Issues.
It can be Medically Diagnosed, and is familiar to any Psychiatrist, and probably many Doctors, since it can cause Physical Pain.
Intelligence can hardly be a Factor either - Some of the Greatest Minds of both our Time and the Past had Tempers.
And they didnt exactly take Anger Management Classes.
And perhaps it was Anger.
Anger being a largely Chemical Process present Predominantly in Males, due to the Hypothalamus in the Male Brain.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothalamus#Endocrine_hormones
It can be an Addiction, and a Serious Condition.
The same part of the Brain can cause someone to become addicted to Masturbation, or Sex.
Think what you will, but I am stating that these are Possibilities.
And if we were to prevent any Defendant from being able to claim such things, wed first need to Eradicate PTSD, and send any Soldier, or Victim, or any other such Mark whos Committed an Offense as a Result, to Prison. Where his State of Mind will Amplify, instead of be Improved.
I am stating this as a Viable Possibility. Not as an Excuse.
Even if someone is Influenced by Anger, or Stress, they are still Liable for their Actions. That was never in Question.