Flying Crane
Sr. Grandmaster
I've been thinking about this a bit lately, and thought I'd open it up for discussion.
When we have experiences, these experiences will have an effect on how we view other things. It gives us a frame of reference for comparison and a basis on which to understand what else we might be looking at or doing. This holds true in the martial arts. After we have spent time training in one martial art, that experience will influence how we view any other martial art that we look at. If we begin training in a second or third martial art, prior martial experience will influence that later training, even if we try and compartmentalize it and keep the different arts "pure" and separate from each other. I think this is natural and normal. Whatever we have done in the past, influences whatever we will do in the future.
However, I think there is a trap that some people can fall into, and that is judging one art by the standards and practices of another.
It seems to me that many different arts have a lot of things in common. They share a good number of techniques and methods, including how they generate power and what their footwork is like. These commonalities make it easier to understand what we are seeing, and to an extent make a judgement on the quality of what is being done.
But some arts are actually quite different from each other. Their methods are very different, including physical technique, power generation, footwork and movement. They are really different enough that it doesn't make sense to judge the one art by the standards of the other. Yet I sometimes see people doing this.
I think it demonstrates a closed mind to do this. Seems like for some, they feel that their method had captured the "best" way to approach martial training and technique, and if a system doesn't share these methods, then they believe it is inferior or sub-optimal.
I don't understand it when people can't even recognize that they simply lack the experience to pass judgement one way or the other. In my opinion, it's like putting blinders on, and refusing to look around and recognize that while some things are simply different, they are also tremendously effective.
Just my thoughts, feel free to comment.
When we have experiences, these experiences will have an effect on how we view other things. It gives us a frame of reference for comparison and a basis on which to understand what else we might be looking at or doing. This holds true in the martial arts. After we have spent time training in one martial art, that experience will influence how we view any other martial art that we look at. If we begin training in a second or third martial art, prior martial experience will influence that later training, even if we try and compartmentalize it and keep the different arts "pure" and separate from each other. I think this is natural and normal. Whatever we have done in the past, influences whatever we will do in the future.
However, I think there is a trap that some people can fall into, and that is judging one art by the standards and practices of another.
It seems to me that many different arts have a lot of things in common. They share a good number of techniques and methods, including how they generate power and what their footwork is like. These commonalities make it easier to understand what we are seeing, and to an extent make a judgement on the quality of what is being done.
But some arts are actually quite different from each other. Their methods are very different, including physical technique, power generation, footwork and movement. They are really different enough that it doesn't make sense to judge the one art by the standards of the other. Yet I sometimes see people doing this.
I think it demonstrates a closed mind to do this. Seems like for some, they feel that their method had captured the "best" way to approach martial training and technique, and if a system doesn't share these methods, then they believe it is inferior or sub-optimal.
I don't understand it when people can't even recognize that they simply lack the experience to pass judgement one way or the other. In my opinion, it's like putting blinders on, and refusing to look around and recognize that while some things are simply different, they are also tremendously effective.
Just my thoughts, feel free to comment.