Anyone using AI Engines like ChatGPT for MA questions?

You want to analyze something? Sure, use Copilot or chatGPT, but you better damn well back it up with your own physical evidence if you plan to sell it to others.
I completely agree. Which is why I always say that Ai is just going to be like computers. Ai won't run on it's own. It will have a person with expertise plugged into it. It's the same thing that happened with computers. Computers didn't take over, they just ended up having humans plugged into them.

I always tell people the expertise of the person who is using ai for a specific task is critical. How would that person know if Ai is wrong unless that person had the expertise and knowledge to know when something is off, or needs a second look. Those who are just going to follow Ai without subject knowledge are just going to fail.

I use Ai to assist me with IT responsibilities at work. When it gives me answers. I can tell if that answer is within the context of the issue that I have or if it seems like Ai is talking about something else. If a person can't do that at a minimum, then Ai will be more of a burden. Ai interprets. The human has to be able to know what Ai is looking at and if things seem off.

Experts say that people think less with Ai. For me it's the opposite. I'm currently training people now how to get the most out of CoPilot when analyzing Government Policies and they think way more now than they did before. Ai explains things so they can understand it, and it's that understanding that triggers additional thought.

There are those who don't think. For those type of people, Ai isn't the issue. For those type of people Tribalism and Group think is their problem. They follow the group because they don't want to think.
 
The martial arts cannot be effectively learned or taught by reading from a screen. Period.
I agree with this. This was never my claim. I'm the one who is always saying that people can't understand martial arts unless they train application in sparring. 90% of the time I'm in the same boat with Kung Fu wang when it comes to application and learning martial arts.


Like I said previously, you clearly have found something 'shiny and new' that you are passionate about it which is fine and good, but man oh man are you over the top on trying to convince yourself and others that it is the whole enchilada.
I never said it was the enchilada. That was an assumption that you made. It wasn't the information that I was providing. Remember. I'm the one who wrote that Ai (copilot ) couldn't tell the difference between Right And Left.

Why would I say that if I thought it was the whole enchilada. Ai couldn't even align the circles on the body correctly. All I did was showed what it's able to do and the problems it was having.

I'll put it like this. I barely go 3 hours without putting something into Ai and the reason I use it so much because I want to know where Ai is strong and where it is weak.
 
I agree with this. This was never my claim. I'm the one who is always saying that people can't understand martial arts unless they train application in sparring. 90% of the time I'm in the same boat with Kung Fu wang when it comes to application and learning martial arts.



I never said it was the enchilada. That was an assumption that you made. It wasn't the information that I was providing. Remember. I'm the one who wrote that Ai (copilot ) couldn't tell the difference between Right And Left.

Why would I say that if I thought it was the whole enchilada. Ai couldn't even align the circles on the body correctly. All I did was showed what it's able to do and the problems it was having.

I'll put it like this. I barely go 3 hours without putting something into Ai and the reason I use it so much because I want to know where Ai is strong and where it is weak.
Because You are the one who has blown this thread up with AI content. Is that really so hard to understand?
And Yes, you have been talking out both sides of your mouth for the majority of the content.
 
Because You are the one who has blown this thread up with AI content. Is that really so hard to understand?
The title of the thread.
"

Anyone using AI Engines like ChatGPT for MA questions?"​


Feel free to share how you use Ai for Martial Arts questions. First time I've ever had someone upset because I posted a lot about a subject matter.


And Yes, you have been talking out both sides of your mouth for the majority of the content.
If you are going to accuse me of something, then show the proof.
 
NO. But you probably guessed that already. :D
yeah that message came in loud and clear. I'll have to convert some of you. lol.

But in all seriousness. I think it's important to have an open mind. Some the stuff will be junk while other things will take a more practical path.

I would love to have something like this to Analyze my training on heavy bags and sparring. Especially if it can determine what the punch would have been if the punch wasn't pulled.




The future of Martial Arts training will take the same path as it has always taken. The younger generation will seek to make improvements on existing methods. There will be successes and failures.
 
yeah that message came in loud and clear. I'll have to convert some of you. lol.

But in all seriousness. I think it's important to have an open mind. Some the stuff will be junk while other things will take a more practical path.

I would love to have something like this to Analyze my training on heavy bags and sparring. Especially if it can determine what the punch would have been if the punch wasn't pulled.




The future of Martial Arts training will take the same path as it has always taken. The younger generation will seek to make improvements on existing methods. There will be successes and failures.
This is wireframe. There are tons of wireframe programs out there to do what the top video is doing. The expense is in the feedback equipment that the person wears and the interface. There is a bluetooth version but it is/was much more expensive.
10-15 years ago when we were really big into WT, we could rent a unit and use it for our elite fighters. Was it helpful? Not much since we could only analyze one side of an upcoming match (one fighter). Even if it existed, no one was going to share that kind of information. Was is 'cool' to watch on the screen and shed light on body position? Yes, but again, body position is hard to realistically analyze in isolation (as long as we are talking sparring and Not forms/hyungs/poomsae).

Has nothing to do with AI however so that may bust your AI high bubble.

"The future of Martial Arts training will take the same path as it has always taken. The younger generation will seek to make improvements on existing methods. There will be successes and failures."

An extremely, arrogant comment. Before I respond, do you want to expand on this thought?
 
There is a bluetooth version but it is/was much more expensive.
10-15 years ago when we were really big into WT, we could rent a unit and use it for our elite fighters. Was it helpful? Not much since we could only analyze one side of an upcoming match (one fighter). Even if it existed, no one was going to share that kind of information. Was is 'cool' to watch on the screen and shed light on body position? Yes, but again, body position is hard to realistically analyze in isolation (as long as we are talking sparring and Not forms/hyungs/poomsae).
This is good to know. Do you think they are using Ai to interpret the wireframe or is it just a word re-brand to take advantage of the Ai hype? I put Ai there because they said Ai. I'm not familiar with the software that they are using. If the Wireframe is being interpreted by Ai, then it would qualify. If not, then it wouldn't. I wouldn't buy it if there's no reliable interpretation.

if the software couldn't look at random biomechanics and tell what the impact would be then it would be no interest of me.

When I first used Ai to test out it's limitations it used a "best guess? attempt to interpret a still of me hitting a heavy bag. It looked at my Bio Mechanics and the indentation of the bag to determine how hard the punch was. At the time I probably should have included a description of the bag composition and I should have shown it a soft impact and a hard impact on the bag so that it would have a minimum and maximum to work with.

It wasn't a disappointment because it told me that it needed the speed of the punch and some other stuff to accurately determine how strong the punch was. I'll have to try it again to see if there has been any changes.

The only one thing that really impressed me is that I posted myself in a neutral looking stance but there was enough evidence of moving that it was able to tell what I was going to do next based on my body position / Weight distribution. I only tested it once because of the left and right issue that it has. Not being able to tell left from right will cause problems on what's the next possible movement.


Out of curiosity. Do you know what happens when Poomsae / forms, kata is used? How does it track that movement? Whenever I see the wireframe clips, It's always basic kicks and punches. Is it just pulling from information of what a kick and punch is?

The future of Martial Arts training will take the same path as it has always taken. The younger generation will seek to make improvements on existing methods. There will be successes and failures
What I mean by is that martial arts training specifically application is not stagnant. Every new generation learns new ways to use techniques. Sometimes it's a rediscovery of function but other times, it's completely new.

This improvement is the natural flow of things when people actually use Martial Arts techniques beyond form. It explains why records are broken. New methods of training, new methods of execution all which are done to improve on a system.

Jow Ga Kung Fu is a perfect example of this. Someone from a younger generation combined 3 different martial arts systems and made a hybrid in which he felt was an improvement. It was the thing that worked best for him, and he taught his brothers, and from there it's now global.

My method of training Jow Ga Kung Fu is new compared to how most Jow Ga schools train. But in the history of Jow Ga kung fu, it's probably more of a rediscovery. But it doesn't change the fact that the way that I train myself and others was from my effort to make improvements on how Jow Ga Kung Fu was taught.

It may sound arrogant, but it's not. It's the natural course of human nature. From cars, planes, to stretches, an boxing. We can clearly see evidence on this natural willingness to improve, to be better than those who came before us and if we can't reach that level, then we inspire those who can.

You can easily find many martial arts founders who display this same thing. At the time, they were the younger generation. IP Man and Bruce Lee off the top of my head probably reflect this in a way that people can see how the Younger Generation changed things.

The day that the younger generation do not seek to improve is the day the system in question will start dying. It's only natural to seek improvements on what is being used. It's not something that can be done from the outside. It has to be done from someone within the system.
 
Back
Top