New anti Sine Wave pattern deliveries on Youtube

From your post 421 "I hope you listen very carefully to how he completely disrepects the KKW and thus violates his own principles of respect."

So, now are you claiming it was not "His" own principle?

Are you arguing that courtesy nd respect are the same?

 

I once asked a hippopotamus what it was like to fly.

 

Did you get an earful?

 

One cannot exist without the other.

 

His changing views of the KKW is evidence of inconsistent belief as to what constitutes TaeKwonDo as opposed to Karate impersonation.

It is exactly the type of unreliability I was referring to when he tells you that SW has punching hip twist and to Yeo chin huat that SW parted with hip twist.... Some days the KKW is a poor mans Karate, other days they are part of the TKD family.... Some days SW has hip twist punches, other days it does not.

 

So, you are comparing what General Choi consistently taught with what someone else says he thinks General Choi taught - got it.

You base your opinion on snippets of videos and excerpts from texts and somehow extrapolate various excerpted opinions on KKW to what he taught. My opinion is based upon over 150 classroom hours with him, a dozen pages or so of typed notes from that along with comparison to what he had in his texts, and found him 98% consistent and my conclusion that the other 2% or so can be mainly attributed to my misunderstanding what he said, his misunderstanding a question or my inaccuracy in note taking. I will leave it to others as to whose opinion is based on better data

 

EARL WEISS SAID: ↑
Are you arguing that courtesy nd respect are the same?

Well therein we have a disagreement on how terms are defined / applied and without such agreement an intelligent discussion cannot be had.

At a certain basic level most humans are entitled to a certain level of respect simply for being part of humanity. This is not what is typically referred to when someone says you need to respect someone, Admittedly "Showing Respect" and displaying "Courtesy" can be considered similar. However, in most common usage someone is respected because of what they have accomplished and a feeling of admiration for their qualities or accomplishments. . Age, Rank, knowledge, experience. etc. Aside from age these qualities are unknow in a stranger so you would not "Respect" them. Courtesy is often defined as politeness or good manners. You can display courtesy to a stranger, or even to someone you do not respect.

So, you can most definitely have courtesy without respect. Having respect without courtesy - while possible would not say much about someone's education.

 

Even my dog knows to give up on a bone when there's nothing more to be got out of it.


As we used to say in the RAF..................... NFI mate.

 

Yeah but why would you? The hole point behind courteous is that you respect him or her. So in practice, there is no difference.

 

I can't say that I've experienced it from you. But I don't mind a little sting to conversations. Just sayin..

 

You can mock someone who says smart things too. Just because you CAN do something, doesn't mean it actually makes any sense..

 

No, I base it on my own training dating back to 2014 under Yeo Chin Huat

You challenged me to produce names having a different experience of what sine wave does and does not contain.. Then when I did so and encouraged you to email said person, you decided against it.

 

I don't "believe" in that. Disrespecting someone is fundamental. It's not just some snarky remark.

 

You have a basic level of respect for people that you are courteous to. Anonymous forums are a perfect example of how true that is. When nobody needs to face the consequences, they disrespect the sh*it out of each other.

Then in real life people keep their mouths shut simply because it's easier that way. But I wouldn't say that they are polite.. just neutral.