Martial arts creates Violence? Say Yes or No

CB Jones

Senior Master
Joined
Feb 20, 2017
Messages
3,938
Reaction score
2,013
Location
Saline
Asking if martial arts create violence is like asking if bacon creates breakfast.

Bacon is simply an ingredient that a chef uses. Just like martial arts is an ingredient that a person can choose to use
 
Last edited:

Steve

Mostly Harmless
Joined
Jul 9, 2008
Messages
21,918
Reaction score
7,474
Location
Covington, WA
Violence is inherent to martial arts. The root of the word "violence" is the same as for "viola" and "violin", which is from Middle English root "violenca" and the Old English 'Vitula" from which we also get the modern term "vitriol."

Not many know that this shared root for "violence" and stringed, musical instruments are where the term "Martial Art" comes from, meaning "harmful music." It's not an accident that the sound of the bow being drawn across the strings on a musical instrument sound like the screams of someone in pain.

Or it's possible I just made all that up. Who knows?
 

oftheherd1

Senior Master
Joined
May 12, 2011
Messages
4,685
Reaction score
817
Violence is inherent to martial arts. The root of the word "violence" is the same as for "viola" and "violin", which is from Middle English root "violenca" and the Old English 'Vitula" from which we also get the modern term "vitriol."

Not many know that this shared root for "violence" and stringed, musical instruments are where the term "Martial Art" comes from, meaning "harmful music." It's not an accident that the sound of the bow being drawn across the strings on a musical instrument sound like the screams of someone in pain.

Or it's possible I just made all that up. Who knows?

Well that's how it normally sounded when I played the violin. I guess that relates to why I like martial arts?
 

Anarax

Master Black Belt
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
1,022
Reaction score
377
Location
New Mexico
Martial Arts on it's own doesn't make people violent. Concerning MA and it's connection to violence, that's more on the character or lack there of for the individual and the Instructor. MA can help with controlling irrational violent tendencies and it does in a lot of cases. However; I've seen horrible schools that encourage violent and all out barbaric behavior in training/sparring. IMO these schools usually only retain students that already had behavioral issues, thus I don't think the MA itself is to blame. I also think that these types are environments are a reflection of the Instructor rather than MA itself.

There are MA Instructors that don't fully take into account the ramifications of teaching MA to those who are already dangerous. I've seen some instructors excuse grotesque behavior, but I've seen others throw students out of their schools.

I think it's more a matter of both the instructor's and student's character rather than MA.
 

_Simon_

Senior Master
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
4,397
Reaction score
2,905
Location
Australia
Sort of. In the same way a vaccine contains the virus it's created to inoculate against.

There have been some awesome analogies already, but this one takes the cake, love it!

No.

Our animalistic natures create violence. Martial arts just teaches us to do it better, but at the same time gives us an outlet to let out our aggression and gives us the discipline to control ourselves.

Martial Arts, like any other weapon, cannot be blamed for the violence in the human nature.

Yeah great point. It's like the old question of guns creating violence. No, the gun is actually neutral, it's the person wielding it that creates the situation/consequence.

It's the animalistic nature which spurs forth violence. Violence in this context being wanting to truly, truly hurt or kill someone.

It's actually a great question, because that's what it looks like when viewing or participating in martial arts classes, there are violent techniques being taught. But the intention behind it is where this all lies. Don't quote me on this, but I don't really think many take up martial arts to be violent as such... As in to purposely use it to go out and hurt people with it. Could be wrong! Obviously training gyms vary, and clearly some places are designed to train people for full contact and ring/cage-fighting competition etc. But seems different from the violence the OP is talking about.

All depends on the context of what you mean by 'violence' hey!
 

pdg

Senior Master
Joined
Feb 19, 2018
Messages
3,568
Reaction score
1,034
There have been some awesome analogies already, but this one takes the cake, love it!



Yeah great point. It's like the old question of guns creating violence. No, the gun is actually neutral, it's the person wielding it that creates the situation/consequence.

It's the animalistic nature which spurs forth violence. Violence in this context being wanting to truly, truly hurt or kill someone.

It's actually a great question, because that's what it looks like when viewing or participating in martial arts classes, there are violent techniques being taught. But the intention behind it is where this all lies. Don't quote me on this, but I don't really think many take up martial arts to be violent as such... As in to purposely use it to go out and hurt people with it. Could be wrong! Obviously training gyms vary, and clearly some places are designed to train people for full contact and ring/cage-fighting competition etc. But seems different from the violence the OP is talking about.

All depends on the context of what you mean by 'violence' hey!

Yes, MA can be viewed as a tool that can be used for violence (like a knife, or a gun, or a pillow), but the tool doesn't initiate the violence.

What can though is the relationship with the tool, or the way that relationship is conditioned.

If you are a cobra kai student, that type of training can make you violent - but that's not the art itself at fault, it's the relationship conditioning...
 

Monkey Turned Wolf

MT Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jan 4, 2012
Messages
12,212
Reaction score
6,308
Location
New York
No. I wouldn't even say martial art causes people to be more violent. It's helped me and at least a few other people I know and on this board (cough cough @Ironbear24 cough cough :D) become less violent
 

Danny T

Senior Master
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
4,258
Reaction score
2,293
Location
New Iberia, Louisiana USA
I don't think martial arts creates violence though it may use violence.
Many practitioners at the higher levels can actually prevent violence by knowing and understanding what to do in a potential violent situation. I believe myself to be a violent person though I may be very willing to use violence if the situation deems it appropriate for my or my loved ones personal protection.
 

_Simon_

Senior Master
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
4,397
Reaction score
2,905
Location
Australia
Yes, MA can be viewed as a tool that can be used for violence (like a knife, or a gun, or a pillow), but the tool doesn't initiate the violence.

What can though is the relationship with the tool, or the way that relationship is conditioned.

If you are a cobra kai student, that type of training can make you violent - but that's not the art itself at fault, it's the relationship conditioning...
YES! Exactly, if we all just take a look at Cobra Kai, question resolved ;D
 
OP
pulsescarborough

pulsescarborough

White Belt
Joined
Mar 19, 2018
Messages
13
Reaction score
1
Location
Scarborough, Ontario M1S 3L6
Violence is inherent to martial arts. The root of the word "violence" is the same as for "viola" and "violin", which is from Middle English root "violenca" and the Old English 'Vitula" from which we also get the modern term "vitriol."

Not many know that this shared root for "violence" and stringed, musical instruments are where the term "Martial Art" comes from, meaning "harmful music." It's not an accident that the sound of the bow being drawn across the strings on a musical instrument sound like the screams of someone in pain.

Or it's possible I just made all that up. Who knows?


I barely like things, but the way you explained it changed my opinion on martial arts
 

Latest Discussions

Top