Recent posts got me thinking about the unusual circumstances I opened my original Dojang under. How did you do it? Did you start under a formal Instructor/Assistant Instructor format? What is your lineage? Did you have any special training or background that helped, or hurt? Are you in your own building, lease space, at the gym, or the garage? Do you teach a singular style or multiple styles? Are you affiliate with a system? What are you happy with or what would you change if you could? Are you a Corporation, a LLC, or neither?
There are a lot of different ways to open dojos. Most of my friends and acquaintances were/are dojo owners so I'll briefly share what they did. I've already told my history on previous threads, so I'll just write what they did.
- A friend of mine, and many other colleagues, taught at a YMCA before opening his school. That's a very good place to start. He opened with 40-50 students. Community centers are also a good place to start, as well as running after-school programs at schools.
- I have had friends run schools for their instructors before opening up their own dojo.
- A dojo down the street from me self-promoted from green belt and opened up a dojo. He became a very good martial artist and a successful dojo owner. If you are into sport karate, then you would probably recognize his name.
- Many instructors run dojos at night after working their full-time jobs in the morning. Most of those that I knew worked construction.
- Most full-time dojos that I know lease individual suites, but some own the building. Owning the building is nice because you have a commodity.
- A lot of people I know began teaching in parks, their backyard or garages, or at the beach.
- I have found that background doesn't matter as much to the general public. That really only matters to martial artists. The main importance is how well you treat your clients. If you are running a full-time school, keeping your clients happy is of utmost importance. A little bit of knowledge regarding human behavior can really help when teaching or running business.
- I have also noticed that if a martial arts dojo advertises too many arts, it can be confusing. The general public doesn't know the particulars of the martial arts. That's why you see a lot of "Karate" signs out there when the dojo really teaches (insert whatever art here that isn't technically karate). Or you'll see BJJ. or Grappling, or MMA advertised when the dojo teaches a TMA. Those are buzzwords that the general public knows right now.
There are positives and negatives to the situations that you asked about. A long-time friend of mine owns a franchise-dojo. He pays a percentage to the corporation, but can also advertise his dojo as a "leader in the field." For most on this forum, we may see that as unimportant, but for the consumer who doesn't know the industry that can be a powerful advertising tool. Because my friend has stayed with the same system for so long, I would argue that he hasn't grown as a martial artist. Essentially he is getting really good at one aspect of the martial arts without making gains in other aspects. Renting or owning a space is great for business, but also increases overhead. Teaching out of your garage is cheap rent, but opens the instructor up to personal liability (no matter how many waivers you have students sign).
I hope I added something beneficial here for you. If you have any other specific questions about running a dojo full-time, feel free to ask.