OK...First off I need to say that I have never heard anything good about the ATA. I have had several transfers into my school from ATA style schools and made each of them restart at white belt (I am WTF style). I recently had the chance to visit my Nephew who wanted to show his "Master Uncle" his TKD school.
When I went to visit they were having a class in self defense called Hagganah. It reminded me of the stuff I learned in the Corps but without the emphasis on Killing. I personally do not believe my 9 yr. old nephew needed to learn how to disarm a shotgun wielding opponent nor would he have the mental capacity to do so if needed. I went to eat and apon my return saw a class on Kettlebells and cardio Kickboxing.
The next day after breakfast I went by and saw a class practicing what they call XMA. A lot of spinning, handstands and bad stances followed up by looooooooooooooooong yells. I had seen 3 classes at this school but not one of them was in TKD.
That night I took my nephew to his "TKD class" and watched in disgust. Sure the teacher knew how to motivate them. Patches and stripes/stars in every class will do that for every kid. There was a decent amount of exercise and a lot of demonstration on how to do kicks the "right way" but very little practice of them and almost no correction.
At the end of class His "Sa Bum" invited me to a black belt class (My nephew told him I was a black belt) the following day. When I showed up it was me and 20 6-12 year old kids. They were all spinning "Numbchucks" (Nun cha ku) or twirling staffs. I watched a little and then asked politely if there would be any TKD practice going on that class. The Instructor seemed puzzled as I sat on edge of the mat not participating. He then stopped the class and asked me if I would like to teach them something.
I did the only thing I thought they could handle.....Roundhouse kick (off the line) drills. I had them practice for 20 minutes and then class was over.
Afterwards the instructor told me he thought my drills were too simple. I told him I thought the kids (Jr. Black belts) needed work on their basic's. He changed topic's and proceeded to invite me to "Roll with him". I guess he was too unsure of his kicking skills for a TKD sparring match and wanted to show me what they did in the schools MMA class. Maybe I should have told him that I had been practicing BJJ for 7 years. I am not the best Purple belt on my schools mats but I made that guy my B@$%H. In the end he shook my hand and walked away looking like he was ready to cry (I didn't even go that hard).
Fast forward 3 weeks...
I get a call from my brother telling me his son's favorite teacher quit and is now flipping burgers while attending college (A good career move). He said he wanted to pull him from the school but they can not get back the Black belt tuition.
My question to everyone is :
How in the hell can they call themselves a Tae Kwon Do Association? I have a 2nd dan ITF, 5th Dan Kukkiwon and a 5th dan Moo Do Kwan. I am not the worlds greatest practitioner/teacher but I have spent my share of time on the mat. There was very little being practiced that could be called TKD and they were trying to be a jack of all trades...but they sucked!
OK...My rant is done. Has anyone else seen a school like this one?
When I went to visit they were having a class in self defense called Hagganah. It reminded me of the stuff I learned in the Corps but without the emphasis on Killing. I personally do not believe my 9 yr. old nephew needed to learn how to disarm a shotgun wielding opponent nor would he have the mental capacity to do so if needed. I went to eat and apon my return saw a class on Kettlebells and cardio Kickboxing.
The next day after breakfast I went by and saw a class practicing what they call XMA. A lot of spinning, handstands and bad stances followed up by looooooooooooooooong yells. I had seen 3 classes at this school but not one of them was in TKD.
That night I took my nephew to his "TKD class" and watched in disgust. Sure the teacher knew how to motivate them. Patches and stripes/stars in every class will do that for every kid. There was a decent amount of exercise and a lot of demonstration on how to do kicks the "right way" but very little practice of them and almost no correction.
At the end of class His "Sa Bum" invited me to a black belt class (My nephew told him I was a black belt) the following day. When I showed up it was me and 20 6-12 year old kids. They were all spinning "Numbchucks" (Nun cha ku) or twirling staffs. I watched a little and then asked politely if there would be any TKD practice going on that class. The Instructor seemed puzzled as I sat on edge of the mat not participating. He then stopped the class and asked me if I would like to teach them something.
I did the only thing I thought they could handle.....Roundhouse kick (off the line) drills. I had them practice for 20 minutes and then class was over.
Afterwards the instructor told me he thought my drills were too simple. I told him I thought the kids (Jr. Black belts) needed work on their basic's. He changed topic's and proceeded to invite me to "Roll with him". I guess he was too unsure of his kicking skills for a TKD sparring match and wanted to show me what they did in the schools MMA class. Maybe I should have told him that I had been practicing BJJ for 7 years. I am not the best Purple belt on my schools mats but I made that guy my B@$%H. In the end he shook my hand and walked away looking like he was ready to cry (I didn't even go that hard).
Fast forward 3 weeks...
I get a call from my brother telling me his son's favorite teacher quit and is now flipping burgers while attending college (A good career move). He said he wanted to pull him from the school but they can not get back the Black belt tuition.
My question to everyone is :
How in the hell can they call themselves a Tae Kwon Do Association? I have a 2nd dan ITF, 5th Dan Kukkiwon and a 5th dan Moo Do Kwan. I am not the worlds greatest practitioner/teacher but I have spent my share of time on the mat. There was very little being practiced that could be called TKD and they were trying to be a jack of all trades...but they sucked!
OK...My rant is done. Has anyone else seen a school like this one?