The Last Person.....

Status
Not open for further replies.
JeffJ said:
Thanks, I just might take you up on that in order to see different interpretations of them. My wife knows them up to 4th black(can't remember whay that call that in Korean), I just have them up to Chung Mu.
Which I still insist the meaning of that form is the sound a Korean cow makes!

Yep you are probably right in that a Korean cow would probably maek that noise. :rofl:

I do not practice the ITF Tuls that much anymore but I do know them all.
 
JeffJ said:
Ohh, ok, just didn't know that's what that was called. You are talking about the raising up durring the stepping and dropping down into the strike I'm guessing.

Yep that is the sine wave!
 
Hey Brian, I'm almost up to 800 posts on this thread now. I don't know whether that should make me happy, or really, really depressed!
 
JeffJ said:
Hey Brian, I'm almost up to 800 posts on this thread now. I don't know whether that should make me happy, or really, really depressed!

You know it is kind've a double edge sword. Your happy but yet slightly embarassed. I rationalize it that this is the best chat thread on the internet.
 
Brian R. VanCise said:
Old as in pre sine wave!

Ah - y'know, it's really easy to misread where an emphasis on a bulletin board. I thought you meant "old" as in "previously used and now replaced". Thanks for the clarification.
 
Brian R. VanCise said:
Yep that is the sine wave!
When I first started learning the forms, I was trying to do them like my Shorin Ryu and Kyokushin forms, all level. Which was really hard with the way TKD moves in it's stances. That made it a lot easier.
 
Brian R. VanCise said:
You know it is kind've a double edge sword. Your happy but yet slightly embarassed. I rationalize it that this is the best chat thread on the internet.
Gotta agree with you there!
 
Kacey said:
Ah - y'know, it's really easy to misread where an emphasis on a bulletin board. I thought you meant "old" as in "previously used and now replaced". Thanks for the clarification.

Glad to clarify!
 
JeffJ said:
When I first started learning the forms, I was trying to do them like my Shorin Ryu and Kyokushin forms, all level. Which was really hard with the way TKD moves in it's stances. That made it a lot easier.

What is funny Jeff is that TKD the way General Choi origional practiced them used a very level movement similar to what you used to do. Then he went the way of the sine wave.
 
JeffJ said:
Ohh, ok, just didn't know that's what that was called. You are talking about the raising up durring the stepping and dropping down into the strike I'm guessing.

Sine wave, properly done (which it's often not) should not be nearly as pronounced as most people make it. Gen. Choi went over it in detail at several seminars (one of which I was present at), and he kept telling people to go up and down as they moved - and the seniors did, and the juniors didn't, so he kept yelling... the seniors kept increasing the amount they went up and down, and the juniors kept nodding their heads because they thought they were doing what he said - from there, things just snowballed, and sine wave was over-exaggerated for some time; it still is in many places. But yes, it is the natural up and down motion that occurs when you walk. Try walking without moving your head up and down and see what happens - do it facing a large mirror if you can. It doesn't work very well. The natural motion is what you want; it should be exaggerated slightly in some movements - specifically those that have a downward or upward trajectory (in which case the sine wave stops at the end of the movement) but not nearly as much as many people do it.
 
Talking about the TKD forms got me thinking. For someone who says they hate forms, I sure go out of my way to learn them. Hell, I learned a couple of new ones just 'cause what they taught would help me with my jujitsu.

I've never tested in TKD, but I know the forms up to what I think is 2nd Gup (might be wrong on that). I think there are at least a couple I'd have a lot of trouble with now, seeing as I have a whelks chance in a supernova of performing cressent kicks with my left leg ever again.
 
JeffJ said:
Talking about the TKD forms got me thinking. For someone who says they hate forms, I sure go out of my way to learn them. Hell, I learned a couple of new ones just 'cause what they taught would help me with my jujitsu.

I've never tested in TKD, but I know the forms up to what I think is 2nd Gup (might be wrong on that). I think there are at least a couple I'd have a lot of trouble with now, seeing as I have a whelks chance in a supernova of performing cressent kicks with my left leg ever again.

It is fun to learn a form every now and then but it is just as much fun to forget it. :rofl:
 
Kacey said:
Sine wave, properly done (which it's often not) should not be nearly as pronounced as most people make it. Gen. Choi went over it in detail at several seminars (one of which I was present at), and he kept telling people to go up and down as they moved - and the seniors did, and the juniors didn't, so he kept yelling... the seniors kept increasing the amount they went up and down, and the juniors kept nodding their heads because they thought they were doing what he said - from there, things just snowballed, and sine wave was over-exaggerated for some time; it still is in many places. But yes, it is the natural up and down motion that occurs when you walk. Try walking without moving your head up and down and see what happens - do it facing a large mirror if you can. It doesn't work very well. The natural motion is what you want; it should be exaggerated slightly in some movements - specifically those that have a downward or upward trajectory (in which case the sine wave stops at the end of the movement) but not nearly as much as many people do it.
That's how I was taught. To do it but not to over exaggerate it.
 
Brian R. VanCise said:
It is fun to learn a form every now and then but it is just as much fun to forget it. :rofl:
There are only two forms I practice regularly any more.

Tensho and Ni Hanchi (sp.?)

I get a lot out of those.

Actually just did Tensho for the first time in ages yesterday. I forgot how painful sanchin-dachi could be!
 
Kacey said:
Sine wave, properly done (which it's often not) should not be nearly as pronounced as most people make it. Gen. Choi went over it in detail at several seminars (one of which I was present at), and he kept telling people to go up and down as they moved - and the seniors did, and the juniors didn't, so he kept yelling... the seniors kept increasing the amount they went up and down, and the juniors kept nodding their heads because they thought they were doing what he said - from there, things just snowballed, and sine wave was over-exaggerated for some time; it still is in many places. But yes, it is the natural up and down motion that occurs when you walk. Try walking without moving your head up and down and see what happens - do it facing a large mirror if you can. It doesn't work very well. The natural motion is what you want; it should be exaggerated slightly in some movements - specifically those that have a downward or upward trajectory (in which case the sine wave stops at the end of the movement) but not nearly as much as many people do it.

Yep, you are right on. Unfortunately to many people are doing it in an major over pronounced way. Some of them are way to high up (in rank) to change and when I was at General Choi seminar's I never saw him do it to over pronounced but more along the lines of just right. (right that is for the sine wave) Sometimes though when he demonstrated something he would do it more pronounced and that is where I believe many of his students saw this and moved to a really over pronounced sine wave.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top