MJS,
I would take the other side of this issue and say that the gun is the better weapon (Let's just stick with sidearms/pistols for this discussion) for many reasons.
Firstly, pistols are very easy to conceal and, I think quicker to aquire because of the holster. Fishing through your pocket for a blade will take just as long if not longer from my experience. For SD, concealing the weapon is the last thing I want to do, I WANT the bad guy to know that I am armed are willing to use that weapon, regardless of type, because it might get him to leave me alone. Concealing any weapon until you use it is an ambush and hard to defend in court.
Guns are quicker?? How many people aside from LEO do you see walking around with a gun on their side?? I dont know where you live, but where I'm from, that is something that I've never seen. If the gun was concealed under a jacket, and a knife was clipped to my belt, are you honestly telling me that you could get your gun out before the knife was deployed?? As for the concealing, I was referring to a criminal using the knife. Also, as for concealing the weapons...keep in mind, that not every situation is going to warrant you pulling a gun or knife, so that is even more reason to use extra caution before pulling it out. Also, a gun has to be aimed. How many people practice against a moving target, in low light, under the stress of combat??? My guess would be not that many. You dont need to aim a knife like you would a gun.
Knives don't require 'aiming' but they do require accuracy and focus. Plus the resultant damage/effect of a knife is not the ballistic damage, hydrostatic shot and audible stunner that a pistol shot can produce with much less effort relative to a knife.
Knives require being accurate??? LOL!LOL! Come on man. A knife can be effective on any part of the body. You can give a knife to a 3y/o and they can be dangerous if they dont want to give it back to you.
Also, pistols can be fired from as many varied stances or positions as any well delivered knife attacks.
Yup, and in order for it to even be effective, it has to be pointing at its target, whereas a knife, no matter how its held, can cut you.
Check out Masaad Ayoob's relationship with West Coast KALI people to make a whole SD approach. As far as what other people who shot do, I really don't care because that only gives guys who do participate in pressure shooting the edge. There are many good practical competetive and SD programs out there that you can take home and use just like you can learn forms and drills for knife work.
I'm sure there are many programs that are available for the public to take. The question is, how many actually take them???? Your average "Joe" will most likely take a basic gun class at the local range, and that'll be the end of it, aside from the occassional target practice. Its all a matter of how much you want your training to grow.
My biggest reason for the gun as superior, though, is shear public perception. If you are a stand up guy, with a registered firearm, licensed user, regular practice/SD/Practical pistol league shooter, familiar with the USE OF FORCE/DEADLY FORCE laws in your area and maybe even have an NRA safety course certificate or two in your portfolio, you will look more credible in the average jury members/LEO/Attorneys perception than the 'knife freak' with over $500 invested in military and 'fighting' knives, along with hours of 'chop sockie' training.
Just had a cop/suspect shooting in a city in the state that I live in. The first thing out of the guys family was, "Why did they have to kill him? Why didnt they just mace him?" I get the impression that anyone who owns a gun, has a permit, etc. thinks that they can just pull it out any time they want. Not the case. As I said above, the situation has to warrant the gun being pulled out. Even cops are required to use as much force as whats being used against them.
Sure is a gun going to look better than a knife? Probably. But the fact of the matter is, is that they are BOTH deadly weapons.
Can't ignore the other 'fight' of the court room. Remember, justified use of force is a defensible stance, not a judgement call for the cops on the scene. If you are covered in blood standing over a guy with a crusty knife in your hand, you will be questioned and possibly arrested UNTIL you can prove justified force. Same goes with a gun in the equation, though.
Let me ask you this. If your life or the life of a loved one depended on it, would you pick up a knife and use it?? I sure know that I would. If someone breaks into my house at 2am, I'm going to pick up anything I can, be it a knife, gun, stick, chair, etc. and I'm going to use it! Period!!! I didnt invite this guy into my house, so he deserves what he gets. I guess it'll have to get sorted out in the court.
Mike