I simply can't agree. A "weapon" is a tool. A tool for Self Defense. If your LEO friends don't want you to be able to defend yourself, that's a different issue.
-Palm to face-
You either completly missed my point, or are intentionally ignoring it. I asked a couple of my LEO buddies, and they agreed that it nots a good idea to carry around a self defense object (of any nature) because after you get done using it, you have more explaining to do to with the cops. Example:
Cop: "And then what happened?"
Me: "Well, then I pulled out my Browning 9x19mm Hi-power handgun/6' butterfly knife/kobuton key chain"
Cop: "OK, why did you have said weapon with you?"
Me: "For protection"
Cop: "hu...."
Instead of:
Cop: "And then what happened?"
Me: "Well, I pulled a pen out of my pocket, and used to a block a swing, and thats when he dropped the knife I think"
Notice the differences? Also, I friend of my mine who is going into law said there have been a few cases where people carrying knifes have been charged with threatening people. Local law requires that if you're carrying a concealed weapon some part of it must be shown (ie, a clip on a pocket knife). So, I'd like to avoid some of that if possible. And I'm pretty good with a pocket stick as it is anyways, so I'm not too concerned.
If you feel that your personal environment is "safe" enough that you don't desire a Self Defense Tool, that's your decision, of course. Same sort of thing for training with them. Lots of people train weapons for all sorts of different reasons, frequently not associated with Self Defense at all. If none of those reasons appeal to you, that's fine.
Again, you either completly missed my point, or choose to ignore it. I
do carry a self defense tool, it's called the 3-5 pens I always have on me. Like I said, LEO's in my area have advised me against carrying any sort item which has no use other then being a weapon. You could get away with a flash light, sure, but I don't want to spend a hundo on it. I also said I did carry a knife to and from my MOS school because I was on a Greyhound, and felt the threat level would be high enough that getting hassled by the cops would be ok if it meant getting safely from point A to B. I almost used that knife twice, but thats another matter.
It's cheaper (sorta), but not necessarily easier. Even if you buy a dowel, you still need to cut and sand it at a minimum. Cutting time is only a few min. and sanding adds a few min. on top of that. Now you've got maybe 15 min. into the project. Plus you have to actually spend the time to buy the dowel. Hardwood dowels of appropriate diameter sell in 3' lengths for about $2 - $5 (depending on the hardwood and location). Another $2 for a pack of sandpaper, when you add in your personal time shopping for the material and producing the product (how much is your time worth?) and you're now up to at least $15.
I've never seen a Kobuton-like object for sale for less then 25 dollars. I just saved 10 bucks. As for seeing it for sale not in a magazine, and we're looking at 35 dollars, so I just saved 20 bucks. I find that a 6" stick is pretty good for me, which means I can get 12 out of a 3' dowel. So, I could keep 2 for myself, and sell the rest to people in my class for a buck for a pair. Which drops your price from $15, a total of $10. However, I have a pack or two worth of sand paper sitting around already, further lowering the cost. Also, if you were putting in new towel racks, you'd have a dowel accessable (in the form of the old dowel). Not to mention I tend to wait until I need three or four things before I go to Wallyworld, so as for time spent getting any material I needed, it just went out the door. I think I'm making a profit at this point.....
Or, you could be increadably lazy and cheap, and just use an old marker. Which I do.
And that's without cutting finger grips or friction surfaces and treating/finishing the wood in any way.
I'm sorry what?
And I'm not sure where you're shopping for Kubotons but I've seen them for $5 regularly back when they were popular. Heck, the Cold Steel "Koga" stuff starts at about $11 Retail and only goes down from there.
When were they popular? Like I said, the cheapest I've ever seen was $25.
As for using a pen for a Kopo, there really are very few pens that work well simply because of their size and lightweight construction.
I'm talking about using a pen
in a real life situation and a dowel in training. Smacking a pen into heavy bag as part of training is a bad idea for the pen and the bag. Smacking a pen into human flesh, different matter.