Martial arts effects on mental health

[Muay Thai Student]

Hi! I’m doing a study on the effects of combat sports/martial arts on mental health. If you could fill out this really quick survey it’d really help me out. Thanks!

Effects of Combat Sports on Mental Health Survey

Web survey powered by SurveyMonkey.com. Create your own online survey now with SurveyMonkey's expert certified FREE templates.

www.surveymonkey.co.uk

 

[Dirty Dog]

I looked at it, but did not fill it out. Pure 100% subjective studies are not science. Not even remotely. And this is a poor example even of the sort of pseudo-science typical of the genre.

 

[Xue Sheng]

Mental Benefits of Martial Arts​

Positive Psychology in Martial Arts​

Can You Raise Resilience With a Roundhouse Kick?​

 

[skribs]

I looked at it, but did not fill it out. Pure 100% subjective studies are not science. Not even remotely. And this is a poor example even of the sort of pseudo-science typical of the genre.

Qualitative studies exist. This is psych 101.

 

[mograph]

I looked at it, but did not fill it out. Pure 100% subjective studies are not science. Not even remotely. And this is a poor example even of the sort of pseudo-science typical of the genre.

Making a broad distinction between "subjective" and "objective" studies isn't scientific. To be scientific, one must look deeper.

This type of study is called a "self-report" study, and their validity can be improved by the use of other measures in the study, as well as careful phrasing of the questions to attempt to avoid bias.

Self-report study - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Validity (statistics) - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

... and a good self-report study acknowledges limitations of the study, and suggests ways of improving validity in the future.

I'd add that this looks like a survey, rather than a study conducted by an academic institution, since it doesn't include the usual informed consent form.

I wouldn't get into a twist over it.

 

[Buka]

Hi! I’m doing a study on the effects of combat sports/martial arts on mental health. If you could fill out this really quick survey it’d really help me out. Thanks!

Effects of Combat Sports on Mental Health Survey

Web survey powered by SurveyMonkey.com. Create your own online survey now with SurveyMonkey's expert certified FREE templates.

www.surveymonkey.co.uk

I filled out your survey. But I'd like to explain some of my answers. When asked if fight competition helped me in the ways asked, I answered NO. Because it wasn't the competition that did anything, it was the every day training in the dojo that DID do everything.

Big difference. I hoped this helped.