In another thread on training in multiple styles, the question came up of whether or not one can learn effective skills in a short amount of time. So, if someone were to train in TKD for 5 months, would they learn enough to be effective? What about Kenpo? What about Krav Maga?
Now, if we look at an art like Krav Maga, we will see something that is billed as an effective art, with skills that can be learned in a short amount of time, and remembered with little practice. Why? Because many of the techniques are similar in nature. For example: A 2 hand choke. The initial defense for this choke, regardless of it being from the front, rear or side, is the same. One doesn't have to think, in the heat of the moment, "Ok...I'm being choked. Where is the attack? Ok, I know its from the front. Ok...which defense am I going to do?" Again, the initial defense is the same regardless. The idea as far as I can see, is keeping things simple, yet effective.
Now, for the record, my experience with Krav is limited compared to some others, so what I said above is not just my words, but the words that I've also heard from others.
I've also heard similar remarks about Paul Vunak and his R.A.T. system that he has. Simple effective moves designed to teach you how to be effective in a short amount of time.
So, enough ranting for now.
To get on with the question: Is it possible to learn effective skills in a given art in a short amount of time?
Now, if we look at an art like Krav Maga, we will see something that is billed as an effective art, with skills that can be learned in a short amount of time, and remembered with little practice. Why? Because many of the techniques are similar in nature. For example: A 2 hand choke. The initial defense for this choke, regardless of it being from the front, rear or side, is the same. One doesn't have to think, in the heat of the moment, "Ok...I'm being choked. Where is the attack? Ok, I know its from the front. Ok...which defense am I going to do?" Again, the initial defense is the same regardless. The idea as far as I can see, is keeping things simple, yet effective.

Now, for the record, my experience with Krav is limited compared to some others, so what I said above is not just my words, but the words that I've also heard from others.
I've also heard similar remarks about Paul Vunak and his R.A.T. system that he has. Simple effective moves designed to teach you how to be effective in a short amount of time.
So, enough ranting for now.
