I am not a lawyer, but I suspect if you consulted one, you'd be told that you might be opening yourself up to some liability issues.
But like most martial arts instructors, isn't that the norm. with the lawyers as well? I may be wrong in saying this, but it seems to me, that many who will be making the decision as to whether or not you're right or wrong in what you did, will be totally clueless or have a limited at best, knowledge of the arts.
I think that I am not in control of when or if I will be attacked or mugged. Training in self-defense is one of the ways in which I prepare myself against that eventuality.
I agree. Hopefully with our training, came a heightened awareness of our surroundings.
I also think that the primary principle of self defense is encapsulated in the words 'self' and 'defense'. I do not think my wallet is worth my life. If I believe I can avoid giving up my life in exchange for my wallet, I will do so. If I believe I can outrun a mugger, I will do so. If I believe I can avoid being injured by handing over my car, I will do so.
If I do not believe I can avoid being further injured with the possibility of being killed, I will fight instead.
It's not about being macho to me. It's about staying alive.
I know we've had these discussions before, and at the risk of going down that same road again, I must ask...how can we be sure? I mean, I may walk into the casino and 'believe' that I'm going to get a 'feeling' when I walk past a slot machine or table, sit down, and hit it big, when reality sets in, and I now realize that I just lost $100. Its a gamble. I can sit at the table and have a 50/50 shot at winning. I may walk away from the mugging with my pants soiled..lol...or I may not walk away at all. As much as losing $100 bucks kills me, I want to walk away with my life.
As for being macho...I'm not superman, I'm not cocky and frankly, I hate to talk about my MA training with anyone thats not a MAist. I certainly do my best to avoid trouble, so when it does come, it usually comes looking for me, not the other way around.
I always try to talk my way out first and fortunately, more times than not, that alone has worked. For that, I'm thankful. But, if I'm pressed, and talking is a) not working or b) not the option, right or wrong in the eyes of others, I'm going to defend myself and anyone that I'm with. If someone thinks that I'm wrong for saying that, thats fine..to each their own.
That's perfectly reasonable.
But if you're being mugged, the statistics say you're not going to die. So making the encounter a violent one by attacking is to perhaps go down swinging when you could have walked away.
And there are people that run around throwing out stats saying that all or 90% of all fights go to the ground. Personally, I take stats with a grain of salt.
The people on the plane had no choices. They even knew from phone calls what was about to happen to them. They made a brave and wise choice.
A person being mugged has no such information. There are a nearly infinite set of variables that they have no knowledge of and no control over. Is this guy desperate enough to kill? Has he killed before? Is he just bluffing? Is he a hardened criminal, a drug addict out of his head, or what? Is he even armed? If he has a gun, is it real, is it loaded? Etc, etc.
Every situation is going to be different. In some, the smart response might well be to attack with everything you have. In others, the smart response might be to tell him to get stuffed and walk away. But you don't know.
I don't think there can be one set answer. We have brains, we're trained as martial artists to analyze the situation. "Hulk Smash!" isn't usually the smartest answer in every situation.
So, using the plane analogy, am I safe to assume that you're saying the following: If death is imminent, if there is no other option for the victim, be it on a plane, or a mugging situation, if it looks like I'm going to die, then I should fight for all I'm worth. But if I 'feel' that I may not die, that if I just give the badguy my cash, that I'll survive, then I should do nothing more than hand it over and hope that I can remember enough of what happened, to give a report to the police.