Dojo Etiquette: Those You Love, Those You Question

Gyakuto172 181

Grandmaster
Supporting Member
Many of us are involved in archaic martial arts, some with even little relevance in the twenty first century. These include certain rules of etiquette: how were expected to behave in the dojo. Are there any you enjoy/see the rationality or others you think should be jettisoned?
 
Many of us are involved in archaic martial arts, some with even little relevance in the twenty first century. These include certain rules of etiquette: how were expected to behave in the dojo. Are there any you enjoy/see the rationality or others you think should be jettisoned?
Most all the rules/etiquette have something to do with the following:

Respect
Self-discipline
Self-control

Aren't these the qualities found in a warrior as you have related in your daily quotation thread?

And importantly in this age, contribute to the safety of the students.
 
I've been a part of two very contrasting dojos re: etiquette. One being suuuuper strict and huge on proper etiquette, respect, osu response to everything etc, and one still having basic etiquette, but muuuuch more relaxed in every way.

I appreciate and enjoy both ☺️
 
I appreciate the etiquette and try to follow it as best as I can.

The part that really gets to me is when the etiquette leaves the mat and the dojo. Especially the rank bit. Once class is over, the rank you have means nothing. When we leave the dojo, I am just Bill and you are just Bob (or whatever your name is...) Sensei, Master, Guru, Renshi, Shihan, Super Soke.... all ends at the edge of the mat. People insisting on being addressed by rank and title at the supermarket are really just telling you how small they feel they are... that they needs this little bit of recognition to make themselves feel validated.

Heck, even on the mat... we should be more people and less rank. If someone can help you get better and is willing to help you out.... take the help.... even if you out rank that person. I was at one class where one of the black belts was working on a technique that he was having trouble with. The Sensei asked him to work on that technique with one of the color belts. The color belt saw what the black belt needed to fix and suggested a way to fix it. The black belt scolded the color belt for trying to correct someone who out ranked him, he would not demean himself to take correction from someone that he out ranked. Sensei then soon brought the entire class together, had us all work on that same technique... then had the color belt come up and demonstrate his "fix" to improve all of our techniques. After class, the black belt was embarrassed and insulted and never came back. Our class was a lot better after that.
 
I've been a part of two very contrasting dojos re: etiquette. One being suuuuper strict and huge on proper etiquette, respect, osu response to everything etc, and one still having basic etiquette, but muuuuch more relaxed in every way.

I appreciate and enjoy both ☺️
Other than the act of bowing, most Japanese dojo etiquette seems to be simple good manners, for example not walking directly across and in front of another person or giving thanks any instruction given.

One thing I have notice in US dojo (video clips, you understand)! is the teacher having to say, “Bow to me/bow to each other” rather than bowing and having it reflexively returned. Is this normal?
 
I appreciate the etiquette and try to follow it as best as I can.

The part that really gets to me is when the etiquette leaves the mat and the dojo. Especially the rank bit. Once class is over, the rank you have means nothing. When we leave the dojo, I am just Bill and you are just Bob (or whatever your name is...) Sensei, Master, Guru, Renshi, Shihan, Super Soke.... all ends at the edge of the mat.
I agree with that, too.
People insisting on being addressed by rank and title at the supermarket are really just telling you how small they feel they are... that they needs this little bit of recognition to make themselves feel validated.
In the supermarket 😆
Heck, even on the mat... we should be more people and less rank. If someone can help you get better and is willing to help you out.... take the help.... even if you out rank that person.
Yes, this is often a difficult situation due to grade-related ego. Perhaps it can be presented more ego-sparingly. When an issue is spotted in a senior, one could say, …”when I’m doing this is it correct or should I be doing it differently?” Most people will get the hint.
I was at one class where one of the black belts was working on a technique that he was having trouble with. The Sensei asked him to work on that technique with one of the color belts. The color belt saw what the black belt needed to fix and suggested a way to fix it. The black belt scolded the color belt for trying to correct someone who out ranked him, he would not demean himself to take correction from someone that he out ranked.
Grade-related ego… (GRE)
Sensei then soon brought the entire class together, had us all work on that same technique... then had the color belt come up and demonstrate his "fix" to improve all of our techniques. After class, the black belt was embarrassed and insulted and never came back. Our class was a lot better after that.
What? 😳Stupid blackbelt (SBB)🙄
 
Other than the act of bowing, most Japanese dojo etiquette seems to be simple good manners, for example not walking directly across and in front of another person or giving thanks any instruction given.

One thing I have notice in US dojo (video clips, you understand)! is the teacher having to say, “Bow to me/bow to each other” rather than bowing and having it reflexively returned. Is this normal?
Not in my experience. I've seen that done in tournaments. But it didn't seem particularly necessary. By and large, I'm confident opponents would have bowed to each other (or saluted, or touched gloves, or whatever) one way or another.
 
There’s the apocryphal story of a Kendoka being disqualified for fist pumping after scoring a point. I’m sure I saw that in a video of a college/school taikai.
 
There’s the apocryphal story of a Kendoka being disqualified for fist pumping after scoring a point. I’m sure I saw that in a video of a college/school taikai.IMO, a simple fist pun
IMO, a simple fist pump is acceptable, but two or three while dancing around (or a backflip as in MMA) is beyond proper decor. TMA, even in competition, is more than just sport and practitioners should hold themselves to that higher standard of humility and self-discipline.
 
We had sparring this morning and one of our coaches basically had a guy on the ropes with no way out.

The coach let him off and as soon as he did. The other guy uppercuts him hard.

The coach then precedes to beat the breaks off him for the rest of the round.

And there are a couple of ideas at play here. Obviously the uppercut was a breach of etiquette. The recept he received in response is is part of the etiquette of the gym.

And then it is a case of just hanging in there doing the best you can untill the timer runs out.,
 
IMO, a simple fist pump is acceptable,
I think I take a slightly contrary view. Even a small fist pump gesture turns the focus inward, toward the ego and personal triumph, which contradicts the humility the art is meant to build. It also undermines zanshin, the sustained awareness and composure a martial artist must maintain even after a successful strike, since a celebrating fighter has already let their guard and their mind relax. A celebratory gesture should cause a point to be disallowed entirely, precisely because it signals that the technique was not complete in spirit. Restraint, then, is not coldness but an expression of respect for the opponent, the tradition, and the discipline itself, reminding the practitioner that the true victory lies in the quality of one’s character rather than the scoreboard.
but two or three while dancing around (or a backflip as in MMA) is beyond proper decor.
I think I take a slightly contrary view. I’d pay good money to see that! 😆
TMA, even in competition, is more than just sport and practitioners should hold themselves to that higher standard of humility and self-discipline.
Hair shirts and cold bathing 😑 I agree. My bath is chilling as I write 😳🥶
 
In the FMA there are really no traditions, Filipino combat fighters did just fine in real life or death situations, with that said, I did a Eskrima seminar at a local Aikido studio. I just followed the lead from the in studio students. Fairly relaxed, bow coming on and off the mats. Bow to the GM picture beginning and end of class.
 
In the FMA there are really no traditions,
Yes, I think I realised that when watching an old 80s BBC documentary (Way of the Warrior). It was a bit shocking for a 12 year old Karate student to see how casual training sessions were!
Filipino combat fighters did just fine in real life or death situations,
I can see that when it comes to killing the enemy, fine etiquette is of little consequence although etiquette isn’t only about the recipient. It’s also a habit of character, and people who practise courtesy everywhere tend to find it comes more naturally when it does matter. There’s a kendo echo here too: the bow at the start and end is partly for the opponent, but largely for the one doing the bowing.
with that said, I did a Eskrima seminar at a local Aikido studio. I just followed the lead from the in studio students.
I think that’s an excellent practice to follow.
Fairly relaxed, bow coming on and off the mats. Bow to the GM picture beginning and end of class.
There are some religious people who don’t follow that bow to the GM photo but I think they are taking a non-critical thinking perspective. They could just as well give the photo a thumbs up and say, “Cheers mate”!
 
Yes, I think I realised that when watching an old 80s BBC documentary (Way of the Warrior). It was a bit shocking for a 12 year old Karate student to see how casual training sessions were!

I can see that when it comes to killing the enemy, fine etiquette is of little consequence although etiquette isn’t only about the recipient. It’s also a habit of character, and people who practise courtesy everywhere tend to find it comes more naturally when it does matter. There’s a kendo echo here too: the bow at the start and end is partly for the opponent, but largely for the one doing the bowing.

I think that’s an excellent practice to follow.

There are some religious people who don’t follow that bow to the GM photo but I think they are taking a non-critical thinking perspective. They could just as well give the photo a thumbs up and say, “Cheers mate”!
We bow to the GM in my school, the teacher, and the flag. It's a simple sign of respect for the art we are learning, the one who is teaching us, and our country. I have zero qualms about doing it, and like the ceremony.
 
I do wonder if the resistance to bowing to GM photos or Kamidana (Shintō shrines) goes back to the idea of ‘graven images/idols’. I do understand since an omnipotent deity might easily confuse respect with worship and a religious person might accidentally slip from respect into worship🙄
 
I wouldn't say there are NO traditions in FMA. Though there's certainly less formality than in some styles. Uniforms and belt systems, for instance, aren't universal. My first FMA style was Doce Pares, and my school had both a uniform and a belt system. Later I trained alongside a lot of Modern Arnis folks (versus learning Modern Arnis, which I can't claim to have done really). Again, there's a uniform and belt system.

That said, it's not unusual at all to see pictures of practitioners, both current and former, training in something like a t-shirt, slacks, and sandals. There's a cultural difference there, certainly. I haven't participated in a ranking system or worn a uniform since the mid-90s.

We expressed respect in many of the same ways, though, whether you're talking about titles, bowing, etc. In FMA, it's not a bow so much as a salute ("pugay"). Hand over the heart, either empty or holding whatever weapon you happen to be using. There was a more elaborate and formal salute in my school, which included kneeling to a senior and performing the "mano." The mano is an expression of respect for elders, whether in a martial arts context or no, where you take their hand and press the back of it to your forehead.

Titles vary based on the style of FMA, dialect being used, and so on. (Including the tendency for escalation in titles.) "Guro" is a general term for teacher, with "Maestro" and "Maestra" also seen frequently (demonstrating a Spanish influence). In the Modern Arnis group (which I didn't teach), I was referred to as "Kuya," denoting an "older brother" in the art. "Ate" (or Aunt) is used as an honourific for female seniors. Etc.

I changed schools after earning my black belt in DP, so my official ranking is "Lakan Isa" (or Black First, for a first degree).

Now, I never trained in the PI, so I haven't gotten the really deep dive on cultural traditions. For instance, the "anting anting," a protective ward often expressed as a tattoo. But that's a thing as well.
 

Latest Discussions

Back
Top