Recommendations for cane materials?

Blackstaff

White Belt
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
Hello everyone,

I'm posting here since I thought people who might practice with sticks or staffs might have some good recommendations. I am disabled from birth and must use a cane to walk. I have a few, but I window shop a lot as a hobby and I like the look for a lot of carbon fiber models. The problem is, I have heard it can fracture or crack easily.

I need a cane for support, but I would like to add some robust ones that also look nice. I don't need the cane for any kind of heavy abuse, because if it broke I could not move, but it would be nice to know that it would be a strong one that could withstand a lot, just for the peace of mind. I've had generic canes break before, but luckily in my home where I could reach another. I guess I am asking here because many of you may know existing models you could recommend. I wish the carbon fiber ones were sturdier (and maybe they are and I just don't know) but if something happens and it breaks, I'd be in trouble.

I do some solo training just for fun, so it would be nice if I found something that could withstand some strikes, but since I am mobility-challenged, obviously I can't use this in a fight, etc. I know some people who train with sticks have multiples in different materials, and obviously holding them in your hands is different from using them as support, but I would like to hear your thoughts.

I picked up a few solid wood and nylon ones, I suppose I should just be happy with those. Just seeing if there's anything out there I am missing. Thank you everyone.
 

Flying Crane

Sr. Grandmaster
Joined
Sep 21, 2005
Messages
13,775
Reaction score
3,263
Location
San Francisco
Hickory is a very strong and durable wood. It is used in making axe and maul handles, so that says something. It can be finished to be attractive as well. Ive made a couple of hiking staves, long staff and spear poles with it. I havent tested any of them to destruction, but it has a good reputation.
 
OP
B

Blackstaff

White Belt
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
Hickory is a very strong and durable wood. It is used in making axe and maul handles, so that says something. It can be finished to be attractive as well. Ive made a couple of hiking staves, long staff and spear poles with it. I havent tested any of them to destruction, but it has a good reputation.

Thank you very much! Hickory does have quite the historical reputation, from what I understand.

I wish I had the resources to test multiple sticks to destruction because I'd like to do it myself. I've been looking for videos that test canes, but of course it is not really a subject many have interest in.
 

Flying Crane

Sr. Grandmaster
Joined
Sep 21, 2005
Messages
13,775
Reaction score
3,263
Location
San Francisco
Thank you very much! Hickory does have quite the historical reputation, from what I understand.

I wish I had the resources to test multiple sticks to destruction because I'd like to do it myself. I've been looking for videos that test canes, but of course it is not really a subject many have interest in.
Ive never made a cane with a curved handle, only hiking staves of about shoulder height. A couple times I had some leftover length after the staff, and I shaped it into a short stick, probably 2 feet long. It is really stout, I feel like all of these things are serious bone-crunchers if it ever came to it. That goes for the short sticks or the longer staffs and poles.

When I was younger and training capoeira, we also trained a stick and machete dance called maculele. In the dance, you clash the sticks or machetes together with a partner. I was using a hickory axe handle that I cut into two pieces, everyone else was using various sticks that they found or acquired otherwise. They made me ditch the axe handle because I was destroying everyones sticks. And that was not the point of the dance.

I say you cant go wrong with hickory, as long as you finish it and give it some weather protection. I dont have a lathe, instead I shape them on a belt sander. It takes longer, Im guessing, but Ive had excellent results, I can make them nearly perfectly round just rolling them over and over on the belt sander. Sand them lengthwise, not across the grain. I buy a plank of hickory from a lumber yard, about an inch and a half thick by however wide, by longer than I want the finished piece so there is extra room for error. I cut them into square strips an inch and a half on a side, and then work them on the sander.

Honestly, I might be persuaded to make something for you if you want to talk about it. Ive never made one with a curved handle, Im not sure how to go about that. It requires a lot of steaming and Ive never experimented with that. But Im sure I could make one with a knob on the end, tapering down on the shaft.

Let me know, and we can talk through private message, to work out the details.
 
OP
B

Blackstaff

White Belt
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
Ive never made a cane with a curved handle, only hiking staves of about shoulder height. A couple times I had some leftover length after the staff, and I shaped it into a short stick, probably 2 feet long. It is really stout, I feel like all of these things are serious bone-crunchers if it ever came to it. That goes for the short sticks or the longer staffs and poles.

When I was younger and training capoeira, we also trained a stick and machete dance called maculele. In the dance, you clash the sticks or machetes together with a partner. I was using a hickory axe handle that I cut into two pieces, everyone else was using various sticks that they found or acquired otherwise. They made me ditch the axe handle because I was destroying everyones sticks. And that was not the point of the dance.

I say you cant go wrong with hickory, as long as you finish it and give it some weather protection. I dont have a lathe, instead I shape them on a belt sander. It takes longer, Im guessing, but Ive had excellent results, I can make them nearly perfectly round just rolling them over and over on the belt sander. Sand them lengthwise, not across the grain. I buy a plank of hickory from a lumber yard, about an inch and a half thick by however wide, by longer than I want the finished piece so there is extra room for error. I cut them into square strips an inch and a half on a side, and then work them on the sander.

Honestly, I might be persuaded to make something for you if you want to talk about it. Ive never made one with a curved handle, Im not sure how to go about that. It requires a lot of steaming and Ive never experimented with that. But Im sure I could make one with a knob on the end, tapering down on the shaft.

Let me know, and we can talk through private message, to work out the details.

Thanks for sharing your experiences!

I'd be happy to send you a couple of messages later when I get a bit of time to compose them.

I actually like the look of straighter canes, but I have never tried to use one for support. I wonder if it might hurt to press down on them, I am not sure. The curved or crook canes are also nice because you can put them over your arm if you need to use both hands for something. You can always try to lean it against something as well, but they can fall over.
 

Danny T

Senior Master
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
4,258
Reaction score
2,292
Location
New Iberia, Louisiana USA
I've made a few canes and have gone out of my way to bang them up.
Hickory is great. I've begun to order them from Tractor and Supply Company (TSC) for about $15.00 each.
 

Flying Crane

Sr. Grandmaster
Joined
Sep 21, 2005
Messages
13,775
Reaction score
3,263
Location
San Francisco
Thanks for sharing your experiences!

I'd be happy to send you a couple of messages later when I get a bit of time to compose them.

I actually like the look of straighter canes, but I have never tried to use one for support. I wonder if it might hurt to press down on them, I am not sure. The curved or crook canes are also nice because you can put them over your arm if you need to use both hands for something. You can always try to lean it against something as well, but they can fall over.
Well, I figure I could put a rounded knob on the top, thick enough to be comfortable in the hand. Maybe even shape it a bit to be kind of pistol-gripped.
 
OP
B

Blackstaff

White Belt
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
I've made a few canes and have gone out of my way to bang them up.
Hickory is great. I've begun to order them from Tractor and Supply Company (TSC) for about $15.00 each.

Haha,I might have exactly that cane. Definitely have one from TSC, for about that price. Did not know it was hickory!
 
OP
B

Blackstaff

White Belt
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
Well, I figure I could put a rounded knob on the top, thick enough to be comfortable in the hand. Maybe even shape it a bit to be kind of pistol-gripped.

Sounds interesting! Thank you for reaching out. I will hopefully have some time to interface with you tomorrow.
 

Gweilo

Master Black Belt
Joined
Jan 11, 2019
Messages
1,141
Reaction score
330
I purchased a cane a while back for Hapkido techniques, and it was made out of Rosewood, it was a good looking thing, orangy brown, with a darker grain, strong smooth and never cracked or split, so that's my recommendation.
 

gpseymour

MT Moderator
Staff member
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
26,793
Reaction score
8,219
Location
Hendersonville, NC
I have a few I really like. My sturdiest (haven't tested to destruction) is probably my white oak (I have a pair made probably 20 years ago by Ed Martin).

I've been toying with making one out of purple heart wood, which the Karate folks at the dojo seem to really like for their staves. I found a supplier where I can buy a dowel rod - I just need to decide if I'm willing to learn to bend it properly (or perhaps just put a brass handle on it).
 

Flying Crane

Sr. Grandmaster
Joined
Sep 21, 2005
Messages
13,775
Reaction score
3,263
Location
San Francisco
Haha,I might have exactly that cane. Definitely have one from TSC, for about that price. Did not know it was hickory!
I looked at the website, I dont think the $15 cane is hickory. There are one or two that are labeled hickory, I think their price is closer to $50.
 

Buka

Sr. Grandmaster
MT Mentor
Joined
Jun 27, 2011
Messages
11,693
Reaction score
8,308
Location
Maui
Hi Blackstaff, welcome to Martial Talk, brother.

If these guys help you with a cane you're going to have to name it. I suggest Kwai Chang. :)
 
OP
B

Blackstaff

White Belt
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
Hi Blackstaff, welcome to Martial Talk, brother.

If these guys help you with a cane you're going to have to name it. I suggest Kwai Chang. :)

No doubt! I have a couple names for some of my other canes, it's always a good idea. I have an old sword-cane called Lawrence. ;)
 
OP
B

Blackstaff

White Belt
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
I looked at the website, I dont think the $15 cane is hickory. There are one or two that are labeled hickory, I think their price is closer to $50.

I thought it was probably a bit too inexpensive for that. It's also not very heavy, and I had a feeling most hickory canes (though I've never handled one to my knowledge) were likely a bit denser/heavier, given the strength of the wood.
 
OP
B

Blackstaff

White Belt
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
Just a general thanks to everyone so far for being so friendly and helpful in my search. I don't have the footwork necessary to succeed at martial arts myself thanks to the disability, but I like to study it as a hobby.
 
D

Deleted member 34973

Guest
Blackjack oak, if you can find a straight piece.

On another note, an old man using a cane against 3 teenagers, was the first time I had seen the Martial Arts used. He took those boys down quick with that cane and just kept walking as if nothing happened.

It was simply badassery at its finest.
 

pdg

Senior Master
Joined
Feb 19, 2018
Messages
3,568
Reaction score
1,032
I wish the carbon fiber ones were sturdier (and maybe they are and I just don't know) but if something happens and it breaks, I'd be in trouble.

I don't have any cane experience, but a little with carbon fibre...

I wouldn't have any worries at all about a (properly made) CF cane - I have a few tools with carbon or glass fibre parts that I trust far more than the wooden alternatives, given that I've had the wooden ones fail on me.

The only problem might be identifying which ones are properly made if you have no experience with the material...
 
D

Deleted member 34973

Guest
I don't have any cane experience, but a little with carbon fibre...

I wouldn't have any worries at all about a (properly made) CF cane - I have a few tools with carbon or glass fibre parts that I trust far more than the wooden alternatives, given that I've had the wooden ones fail on me.

The only problem might be identifying which ones are properly made if you have no experience with the material...
Another thing to be sure of with CF, is an allergic reaction. I worked with carbon fiber, during the molding process and I turned out to be highly allergic to some of the compounds.

Really, take that into consideration. You might not know if you are or not. CF is one of those materials that was ok'd but not tested for health problems.
 

Danny T

Senior Master
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
4,258
Reaction score
2,292
Location
New Iberia, Louisiana USA
Haha,I might have exactly that cane. Definitely have one from TSC, for about that price. Did not know it was hickory!
TSC canes are from U.S. Whip. I contacted U.S. Whip who stated their canes are mostly hickory however are listed as 'Hardwood' due to from time to time hickory not being available and oak is substituted in order to maintain supplies. So it is possible to get an oak cane rather than hickory. Oak will have more of an open grain that the tight close grain of hickory. The canes I've gotten from them are all hickory.
 
Top