Reclaiming Tai Chi

Not kick boxing but Sanda (kick + punch + throw).

In the past 50 years, The SC art has been evolved into CSC (combat SC) that include kick/punch. If combat is your goal, you just can't lock yourself in the throwing art only.

This is why I strongly suggest that Taiji should also step out of it's comfort PH zone and go much further beyond.
My concern with this approach is that, over time, the practices themselves may lose the very fundamentals that made them viable in the first place.

Throughout the 1970s, when crossing hands with others, I made it a point to use what I was actually practicing. What one trains should be reflected in what one can do.

There is an old account of Yang Banhou returning home pleased that he had thrown an opponent. His father, Yang Luchan, pointed out holes beneath the armpits of his robe, indicating that his opponent could have seriously injured him but chose not to. Winning did not necessarily mean demonstrating superior skill.

Push hands, originally a method for developing particular skills, has gradually become a de facto measure of Taiji ability within the martial arts community. Changes to competitive formats have also made these events accessible to non-Taiji practitioners.

Back in the 1970s, Brendan Lai, a Seven Star Praying Mantis shifu, suggested that competitors first perform a CMA set to demonstrate that they actually practiced a traditional martial art. His concern that CMA was losing it's flavor in favor of winning competitions.

Others have taken a different direction, incorporating outside methods to become more competitive. Sanda, for example, developed around a different competitive focus and is often trained separately from traditional CMA.

However, if preserving those fundamentals is no longer a concern, why continue to associate the practice with traditional CMA?
 
Not kick boxing but Sanda (kick + punch + throw).

In the past 50 years, The SC art has been evolved into CSC (combat SC) that include kick/punch. If combat is your goal, you just can't lock yourself in the throwing art only.

This is why I strongly suggest that Taiji should also step out of it's comfort PH zone and go much further beyond.
I understand, but TJQ is after all a special thing in that it do not seek conflict(in ( this way I agree with OP) , setting out to participate in dueling competitions is to seek for conflict.
Although TJQ should be steadfast in this, it should not shy away from eventual challenges coming its way
 
Last edited:
I think we probably conflate individuals pursuing whatever they like, which might be to be "well rounded" or things like that, with "taijiquan" as some kind of entity, which cannot be compared to judo in an organizational way (there are governing bodies for rules, etc.) But maybe that last point is appledog's point - that there isn't a governing body or rules, etc... Personally I see that one is a sport and one is an art. We don't want some governing body for, say, guitar playing, or calligraphy, or filmmaking, etc. Why would we want it for any other art?

As for sport, push hands as some kind of "sport" seems like a fool's errand. The world has more than enough grappling rulesets including "no gi" if an individual wants to go do different grappling tests. When I went to judo, it was immensely fun. You could certainly use some "push hands moves" and you could certainly try to "fang song more", and those kinds of things fit well in an art that tries to be "soft" (at least in playing around, maybe not in tournaments). You can "win" by being better at being more soft. I don't find that's "the definition of internal", but that's educational. Maybe we move our portion of the Venn diagram closer to the "internal" we want.

We can also trick ourselves into thinking we used "softness" because the contact point didn't have much tension, but we actually used massive tension in our "soft" or redirecting moves. I think that soft of self-instruction is very valuable, and that grappling context is helpful. People are being "honest" when they try to throw you, and that is maybe the best part. Also, when you are exhausted from grappling, you are sort of forced to use less muscle. A lot of people who were/are in IMA seem to gravitate to Brazilian jiu-jitsu for similar reasons.
 
Last edited:
My concern with this approach is that, over time, the practices themselves may lose the very fundamentals that made them viable in the first place.
If a Taiji guy spends 10 years in PH training, one day he has a match against a kickboxer, he then loses faith in his PH training after that, it indicates that something very important is missing in his PH training.

If you don't go out of your comfort zone and test your PH skill, how will you know that your PH training can handle the real combat problem?

If a Judo master cannot deal with a boxer's jab-cross-hook-uppercut combo, his Judo skill has a hole in it.
 
I think we probably conflate individuals pursuing whatever they like, which might be to be "well rounded" or things like that, with "taijiquan" as some kind of entity, which cannot be compared to judo in an organizational way (there are governing bodies for rules, etc.) But maybe that last point is appledog's point - that there isn't a governing body or rules, etc... Personally I see that one is a sport and one is an art. We don't want some governing body for, say, guitar playing, or calligraphy, or filmmaking, etc. Why would we want it for any other art?

Arts are traditionally classified according to their distinguishing characteristics, methods, and historical development. These classifications exist independently of any governing body.

What we now call Taijiquan falls within a historically established classification that eventually came to include Chen style and other related traditions.

A governing body isn't necessary to establish those distinctions. They existed long before modern organizations or competitive rules.

As for sport, push hands as some kind of "sport" seems like a fool's errand. The world has more than enough grappling rulesets including "no gi" if an individual wants to go do different grappling tests. When I went to judo, it was immensely fun. You could certainly use some "push hands moves" and you could certainly try to "fang song more", and those kinds of things fit well in an art that tries to be "soft" (at least in playing around, maybe not in tournaments). You can "win" by being better at being more soft. I don't find that's "the definition of internal", but that's educational. Maybe we move our portion of the Venn diagram closer to the "internal" we want.

Seems you're conflating the engine with the method, when each can be expressed independently of the other.

That said, there are things that can be accomplished using one type of engine that may not be possible with another, even though both can achieve the same general outcome within a given context, provided the necessary skill has been developed.

We can also trick ourselves into thinking we used "softness" because the contact point didn't have much tension, but we actually used massive tension in our "soft" or redirecting moves. I think that soft of self-instruction is very valuable, and that grappling context is helpful. People are being "honest" when they try to throw you, and that is maybe the best part. Also, when you are exhausted from grappling, you are sort of forced to use less muscle. A lot of people who were/are in IMA seem to gravitate to Brazilian jiu-jitsu for similar reasons.

The Chinese distinguish between two kinds of softness: ruĒŽn (軟) and róu (꟔).

One is like a marshmallow that yields but does not return to its original shape; the other is like a spring that yields and returns.

IMO, neither really expresses the idea of emptiness (空, kōng), which can give the appearance of either.
 
Last edited:
Arts are traditionally classified according to their distinguishing characteristics, methods, and historical development. These classifications exist independently of any governing body.

What we now call Taijiquan falls within a historically established classification that eventually came to include Chen style and other related traditions.

A governing body isn't necessary to establish those distinctions. They existed long before modern organizations or competitive rules.



Seems you're conflating the engine with the method, when each can be expressed independently of the other.

That said, there are things that can be accomplished using one type of engine that may not be possible with another, even though both can achieve the same general outcome within a given context, provided the necessary skill has been developed.



The Chinese distinguish between two kinds of softness: ruĒŽn (軟) and róu (꟔).

One is like a marshmallow that yields but does not return to its original shape; the other is like a spring that yields and returns.

IMO, neither really expresses the idea of emptiness (空, kōng), which can give the appearance of either.
There is yet a third softness, the spinning sphere, or cylinder if you like, that moves past or carries with. It more clearly expresses Kong, because it does not interact responsively to introduced force. I have only experienced these things with my teacher. Let me be clear, I do NOT claim to master these skills, but I do claim to have experienced them. I even have a photo of one particular instance.
 
The Chinese distinguish between two kinds of softness: ruĒŽn (軟) and róu (꟔).

One is like a marshmallow that yields but does not return to its original shape; the other is like a spring that yields and returns.

IMO, neither really expresses the idea of emptiness (空, kōng), which can give the appearance of either.
Don't think I am really getting it. I think maybe in the very beginning, we start with a very "hard" rollback in the canonical beginner push exercise, where we can keep the contact point 10oz (not 4oz), but we are holding lots of tension to try to calibrate that. almost more like getting ready to backhand a tennis ball at a large angle. it's redirected, but it took a lot of force. then we can kind of calibrate that tension down a lot, but it's still ultimately lots and lots of tension. if i hold my arm up (right now interrupting this typing) as if to do a roll back movement, i can feel 'oops there is lots of tension at my shoulder'. i am letting it go now in my shoulder, i can feel it 'release'. but can i do that in a simple two person cooperative push hands exercise? or am i just fooling myself as soon as there is the least bit of cooperative pressure, now my shoulder is unconsciously tense again? i don't know how many "degree"s of fangsong there are if we can move toward the emptiness, but these are sort of proprioceptive markers to oneself of "oh ok still too tense", I think.
 
Don't think I am really getting it.

Maybe that might be the problem. šŸ¤”


Thinking there’s something to get, rather than realizing how much there is to let go.


secrets, correct form, hidden formulas—all attempts to pass along experiences and understandings developed through practice.


Not meant to be duplicated as experiences in themselves, but to serve as guides, helping us recognize the door we’re attempting to go
understanding has to come through one’s own practice.

Once that understanding has arrived , others can offer suggestions that may help deepen it further.
 
Last edited:

Latest Discussions

Back
Top