windwalker099177 25
Master of Arts
My concern with this approach is that, over time, the practices themselves may lose the very fundamentals that made them viable in the first place.Not kick boxing but Sanda (kick + punch + throw).
In the past 50 years, The SC art has been evolved into CSC (combat SC) that include kick/punch. If combat is your goal, you just can't lock yourself in the throwing art only.
This is why I strongly suggest that Taiji should also step out of it's comfort PH zone and go much further beyond.
Throughout the 1970s, when crossing hands with others, I made it a point to use what I was actually practicing. What one trains should be reflected in what one can do.
There is an old account of Yang Banhou returning home pleased that he had thrown an opponent. His father, Yang Luchan, pointed out holes beneath the armpits of his robe, indicating that his opponent could have seriously injured him but chose not to. Winning did not necessarily mean demonstrating superior skill.
Push hands, originally a method for developing particular skills, has gradually become a de facto measure of Taiji ability within the martial arts community. Changes to competitive formats have also made these events accessible to non-Taiji practitioners.
Back in the 1970s, Brendan Lai, a Seven Star Praying Mantis shifu, suggested that competitors first perform a CMA set to demonstrate that they actually practiced a traditional martial art. His concern that CMA was losing it's flavor in favor of winning competitions.
Others have taken a different direction, incorporating outside methods to become more competitive. Sanda, for example, developed around a different competitive focus and is often trained separately from traditional CMA.
However, if preserving those fundamentals is no longer a concern, why continue to associate the practice with traditional CMA?