Reclaiming Tai Chi

.For example to say the energies are expressions of a single character -- if they are, this is not shown from the classics, which list each as separate forces which must be carefully distinguished from one another. The closest we get is Tan Mengxian's treatise. Tan Mengxian treats one sense of peng as a property of the whole body, but nothing in the classics asserts it, and he specifically assigns different mechanisms to each force.

On that, the common teaching that all eight methods are really peng (or ā€œpeng jin runs through all eight methodsā€) is not, as far as I know, stated in the classical texts. It belongs to 20th-century oral tradition and modern commentary. It is not really consistent with the classics which say controlled by/issued by which describe a kind of kinetic chain or a one-qi as a baseline (one part moves, all parts move-- not a path inside the body).
Peng meaning -container as in an arrow-quiver, it’s the first of the 13, it correspond with the last - zhongding(central equilibrium), the two tie together the eleven in between.

I’ve never read the classics and have just eyed through the 13 postures written down
 
Brings a good point -
While Chen style has gained popularity for
it's martial aspect, a more unknown style -- Fu Style
takes throwing and punching to the exponent. Seems
GM Fu had similar sentiments to Prof Chang regards
adding / changing the mainstream Tai Chi practice.
 
An insightful comment. One may hope.
The more one learns (in any subject), the more one realizes how little one knows (unless Dunning Kruger etc). When we experience very good skill (very rare), I think we realize nobody around is at that level so how can we "rate" or judge? We can maybe realize our own difficulty or help someone who has the same difficulty, e.g., "not enough fangsong when xyz happens". That's about it. That might be the entire thing. Everything else everyone discusses ("yeah but what about this other thing? what if?") is way off track in the "you don't know you don't know" way. A very bad analogy would be that you must learn more than three chords to play music or understand musicality; getting far more technical or knowledgeable about music theory won't mean your song is good. Instead of wanting to "rate" or "teach" anyone else, maybe the inverse is better. If you have enough self-assessment honesty to realize someone you meet is better, try to learn from them. If you think others do not seem as good (too tense, etc.), try to learn from their mistakes because we probably make the same mistake. This works very well in music and sports, although I'm certainly not a good musician or athlete. No rating is needed to realize that.
 
Last edited:
Well, let's look at the intent of the author. First, on page 1 and 2 WPS says "With the popularization of these National Forms, interest in the study and mastery of taijiquan of the Yang school soon spread across the nation." and "There is also a chapter on how to comprehend and master the essentials of taijiquan" (i.e. from reading a book, which somewhat restrains the meaning of 'master'). However, we don't need to guess at what he means: in the paragraph subsequent to the comment on mastering the form, he states:

"Learners should practice regularly every morning or before going to bed. It is preferable to practice seven or eight times during the daytime; if one is hard pressed for time, then practice at least once in the morning and once in the evening."

So on the surface, Wang Peisheng is saying if you practice the form for 1 or 2 hours a day and follow the principles he lays out in the book, that will be sufficient. What I don't see are additional special requirements before learning push hands, such as requirements about nuturing neijin, or a caution regarding a lengthy practice time before learning push hands.

I get what you are saying -- it's just not the information I have received, and I think it is a realistic question to ask why what you are saying seems to be different than what the main lineage schools are saying in the literature.

On neijin. The term neijin is never mentioned anywhere in the classics and it is not described as a ground path either. I think what is really going on here is that the way we learnedtai chi is idiosyncratic to our teacher and school. We all learned in the way we learned, we are products of a particular club or school. So we should be careful not to assume we each have the one true individual way, or to assume the way we learned is by default the intent of the classics.For example to say the energies are expressions of a single character -- if they are, this is not shown from the classics, which list each as separate forces which must be carefully distinguished from one another. The closest we get is Tan Mengxian's treatise. Tan Mengxian treats one sense of peng as a property of the whole body, but nothing in the classics asserts it, and he specifically assigns different mechanisms to each force.

On that, the common teaching that all eight methods are really peng (or ā€œpeng jin runs through all eight methodsā€) is not, as far as I know, stated in the classical texts. It belongs to 20th-century oral tradition and modern commentary. It is not really consistent with the classics which say controlled by/issued by which describe a kind of kinetic chain or a one-qi as a baseline (one part moves, all parts move-- not a path inside the body).

Fortunately, none of this matters! We do not have to define what push hands is to note that push hands is often used to compare skill across styles. If you want to use ground path, go ahead and do so!
I personally don’t care how anyone else chooses to practice. ā€œSkillā€ is relative and vague depending on one’s focus. For instance, if I decide skill means the ability to use it to fight, then push hands only matters if you can use it or the expertise you learned from it to stop me regardless of what I try. If skill means you can topple me in a structured game of competition with no risk, that is a very different thing altogether. I think we all know how it works out when Sensei Dan from the point fighting karate school tries out at the local MMA competition…
 
if I decide skill means the ability to use it to fight, then push hands only matters if you can use it or the expertise you learned from it to stop me regardless of what I try.
Agree! The combat value of PH need to be addressed. If you spend 10 years in PH training and still cannot block/deflect a punch, there is something wrong in your PH training. Even if you may be able to block/deflect 1 punch, can you block/deflect 10 punches, 20 punches, ...?

If you can stop all the punches that coming toward your head, your MA training has given you great reward no matter which MA style that you have trained.
 
šŸ¤” Depends on the taiji ā€œstyle ā€œ practiced.
Or do you feel all taiji methods are the same ?
Let's not talking about the offense skill yet and just talk about the defense skill only. Also let's not talking about the wrestling art yet and talk about the striking art only.

No matter which Taiji system that you may train, you still need to have the ability to block/deflect punches. In order to block/deflect a punch, your arm has to start from non-contact to contact. This is not trained in the PH process.
 
Last edited:
The more one learns (in any subject), the more one realizes how little one knows (unless Dunning Kruger etc). When we experience very good skill (very rare), I think we realize nobody around is at that level so how can we "rate" or judge? We can maybe realize our own difficulty or help someone who has the same difficulty, e.g., "not enough fangsong when xyz happens". That's about it. That might be the entire thing. Everything else everyone discusses ("yeah but what about this other thing? what if?") is way off track in the "you don't know you don't know" way. A very bad analogy would be that you must learn more than three chords to play music or understand musicality; getting far more technical or knowledgeable about music theory won't mean your song is good. Instead of wanting to "rate" or "teach" anyone else, maybe the inverse is better. If you have enough self-assessment honesty to realize someone you meet is better, try to learn from them. If you think others do not seem as good (too tense, etc.), try to learn from their mistakes because we probably make the same mistake. This works very well in music and sports, although I'm certainly not a good musician or athlete. No rating is needed to realize that.
I am honestly surprised at the amount of this present in this and other threads. I understand the idea very well; some difference of opinion pops up, and people talk about it. But then, spectacular instances of -- as you have mentioned it -- Dunning-Kruger pop up. And in short order, two spectacular things happen, ironically related to Dunning-Kruger itself. The irony analogy is that most people (not you!) who invoke it misunderstand it while sounding confident, which is close to the overconfidence they’re accusing the other person of. This plays out across most of the subjects I've seen that kind of post occur in.

1. The people who disagree start making comments that indirectly quote previous posts and state that such behavior is indicative that someone "doesn't know" something -- or "doesn't understand". Of course, the implication being that they know and understand, and that they are right.

2. They find some way to disagree by saying something revealing -- in the exact ironic way that was predicted by the original dichotomy; i.e. they find a way to disagree in the way which is most ironic or self-revealing. [recacted]'s '[redacted]' comment on this thread is perhaps the most ironically humorous thing I have read online in many years. It isn't wrong, but is so off topic and ironic that the subject it raises often destroys the poster's credibility in the original debate.

You above said "yeah but what about this other thing? what if?" which is a caricature of what I have been doing all thread. It would be logical to assume you were talking about me, then, in saying I am way off track and I don't even know that I don't know. Yet overall I find your reserved attitude charming and commendable and I am most likely to listen to and believe what you said about me, than from others. I guess what I am trying to say, is "thank you!"
 
Agree! The combat value of PH need to be addressed. If you spend 10 years in PH training and still cannot block/deflect a punch, there is something wrong in your PH training. Even if you may be able to block/deflect 1 punch, can you block/deflect 10 punches, 20 punches, ...?

If you can stop all the punches that coming toward your head, your MA training has given you great reward no matter which MA style that you have trained.
Again, it only matters if it is relevant to the goal. If they don’t plan to fight, then it’s a sport or game, which is fine.
 
Again, it only matters if it is relevant to the goal. If they don’t plan to fight, then it’s a sport or game, which is fine.
If one only trains Taiji form, he may not plan to fight. If one also trains PH, I assume he plans to fight. Since this tread is talking about PH training, I assume this thread is talking about "plan to fight".

A: I don't train MA for fighting.
B: Why do you train "iron palm" for?
A: ...
 
I am honestly surprised at the amount of this present in this and other threads. I understand the idea very well; some difference of opinion pops up, and people talk about it. But then, spectacular instances of -- as you have mentioned it -- Dunning-Kruger pop up. And in short order, two spectacular things happen, ironically related to Dunning-Kruger itself. The irony analogy is that most people (not you!) who invoke it misunderstand it while sounding confident, which is close to the overconfidence they’re accusing the other person of. This plays out across most of the subjects I've seen that kind of post occur in.

1. The people who disagree start making comments that indirectly quote previous posts and state that such behavior is indicative that someone "doesn't know" something -- or "doesn't understand". Of course, the implication being that they know and understand, and that they are right.

2. They find some way to disagree by saying something revealing -- in the exact ironic way that was predicted by the original dichotomy; i.e. they find a way to disagree in the way which is most ironic or self-revealing. [recacted]'s '[redacted]' comment on this thread is perhaps the most ironically humorous thing I have read online in many years. It isn't wrong, but is so off topic and ironic that the subject it raises often destroys the poster's credibility in the original debate.

You above said "yeah but what about this other thing? what if?" which is a caricature of what I have been doing all thread. It would be logical to assume you were talking about me, then, in saying I am way off track and I don't even know that I don't know. Yet overall I find your reserved attitude charming and commendable and I am most likely to listen to and believe what you said about me, than from others. I guess what I am trying to say, is "thank you!"
Taijiquan is really "Taoist". "The Tao that can be told is not the real Tao". It's hard to talk about. You think you know, then later, you realize "oh that wasn't it". I don't mean to put everyone down in saying this. I think it happens to everyone. A very bad analogy is I watch some tutorial that says the next chord in a song is A, but then you find the better, more experienced musician with a better ear or perfect pitch who says "ah, this is Asus4". And then you can hear it and you're like "ahh right ... why didn't I know that, now it makes more sense". I think progress in "internal" is something like that, except it's much more difficult. In music, they have names for certain frequencies that programs can reproduce. There is more objectivity that can be easily explained or demonstrated. We don't have that with qi and jin and so on. If you cannot "hear" what's happening, you don't really need to go on to the next chord; that may or may not help. I think my point is it's better to try to "discover" for oneself what we didn't know we didn't know. Someone saying "you didn't get it" may or may not help; it depends.
 
Agree! The combat value of PH need to be addressed. If you spend 10 years in PH training and still cannot block/deflect a punch, there is something wrong in your PH training.
If you spend that amount of time training and still cannot demonstrate any Taiji skill sets, perhaps what you're training isn't Taiji. Taiji doesn't emphasize blocking or deflecting punches as its fundamental method. Instead, it speaks of:

Zhān (粘) — Adhere
NiĆ”n (黏) — Stick
LiĆ”n (連) — Connect
SuĆ­ (隨) — Follow

These principles, together with bù diÅ« bù dǐng (äøäøŸäøé ‚) — neither losing contact nor resisting directly — describe a fundamentally different approach to dealing with an opponent's force. Whether through contact or without physical contact, the underlying principles remain the same.

Even if you may be able to block/deflect 1 punch, can you block/deflect 10 punches, 20 punches, ...?

If you can stop all the punches that coming toward your head, your MA training has given you great reward no matter which MA style that you have trained.

Discussing push hands as though it isn't an integral part of most Taiji training methods is kind of strange.

Push hands is used to develop specific skill sets, ting jin (listening skill) being one of them.

Through the development of ting jin, along with timing, positioning, and sensitivity to an opponent's intention, one may move without needing to block or deflect a punch. If movement isn't possible, one may influence the developing interaction, preventing the punch from being initiated in the first place.

The Taiji principle of "start late, arrive first" (å¾Œē™¼å…ˆč‡³) speaks directly to this.
 
preventing the punch from being initiated in the first place. The Taiji principle of "start late, arrive first" (å¾Œē™¼å…ˆč‡³) speaks directly to this.
This thread is discussing "rating Taiji skill".

How does one test this Taiji skill? How about just ask someone to stand in front of a non-Taiji guy and prove that he can do this?

A: If you try to punch me, I'll kill you.
B: Show me right now!
A: ...
 

Latest Discussions

Back
Top