Reclaiming Tai Chi

I am honestly surprised at the amount of this present in this and other threads. I understand the idea very well; some difference of opinion pops up, and people talk about it. But then, spectacular instances of -- as you have mentioned it -- Dunning-Kruger pop up. And in short order, two spectacular things happen, ironically related to Dunning-Kruger itself. The irony analogy is that most people (not you!) who invoke it misunderstand it while sounding confident, which is close to the overconfidence they’re accusing the other person of. This plays out across most of the subjects I've seen that kind of post occur in.

1. The people who disagree start making comments that indirectly quote previous posts and state that such behavior is indicative that someone "doesn't know" something -- or "doesn't understand". Of course, the implication being that they know and understand, and that they are right.

2. They find some way to disagree by saying something revealing -- in the exact ironic way that was predicted by the original dichotomy; i.e. they find a way to disagree in the way which is most ironic or self-revealing. [recacted]'s '[redacted]' comment on this thread is perhaps the most ironically humorous thing I have read online in many years. It isn't wrong, but is so off topic and ironic that the subject it raises often destroys the poster's credibility in the original debate.

You above said "yeah but what about this other thing? what if?" which is a caricature of what I have been doing all thread. It would be logical to assume you were talking about me, then, in saying I am way off track and I don't even know that I don't know. Yet overall I find your reserved attitude charming and commendable and I am most likely to listen to and believe what you said about me, than from others. I guess what I am trying to say, is "thank you!"
Yes you’re being unfairly approached , because when you wrote in your OP - ā€œpeople using Tai Chi to advertise some other martial art). particularly bothers me because it is incredibly dishonestā€ -
you didn’t insinuated any of us forum members but some other group or person that we don’t know about
 
Yes you’re being unfairly approached , because when you wrote in your OP - ā€œpeople using Tai Chi to advertise some other martial art). particularly bothers me because it is incredibly dishonestā€ -
you didn’t insinuated any of us forum members but some other group or person that we don’t know about
Then can we be honest for a moment please? If I had gone into Goju-ryu, Isshin-ryu, Aikido or a similar system I would be 3rd dan black belt by now. If I was 4th or 5th I would probably be expected to be running my own series of dojos, so I am not quite there yet. But coming up in a ratings system there is a structure and a path to mastery that does not exist in american tai chi. The idea of wushu as a career is dead in America.

When I was 12 or 13 I started in the Taoist Tai Chi society and I spent a decade in there dreaming I was learning Tai Chi. I volunteered a lot, I worked at the front desk in highschool. I helped with the food programs at the ten directions temple on D'arcy Street. I lived down the street on D'arcy and elsewhere in the area during that time. In my depression I failed university because I would just go out in the morning for 3 or 4 hours and follow the old people training. I think they adopted me as some sort of pet.

Where are all the other kids learning Tai Chi? They're in China. Kids in America don't learn Tai Chi. It isn't cool. Laugh and troll all you want, China has a Duan system and there is great wisdom in what they are doing. It would have been better if I moved to China when I was young instead of later in life. But how was I supposed to know that or do that? If went there I probably would have found some friends. Something I have come to realize is that if you really want to learn Tai Chi you probably have to just go to China.

I'm not saying there are no good Tai Chi schools in America. I am saying that because of the way it's advertised and presented kids don't find it. A ratings system would change that. That is a fact.
 
Last edited:
I don't think a ratings system = an advertising system, but maybe it's one tiny facet. You mean "colored belts" attract kids? It doesn't seem to be the case. There are colored belt in judo, but we don't seem to see a mcdojo for judo on every corner. Parents aren't looking for their kids to acquire "skills", otherwise why not send kids to judo and bjj and mma? They want "discipline", "respect", "confidence", "fun", "burn off energy", "exercise", "positive attitude", etc, etc, etc. The belts are a bit symbolic and fit into that entire picture where maybe the kids want a "belt" and the parents want the rest. The "ratings" you are talking about are presumably for something else. But you haven't been clear imho about what is the actual problem you want to solve, so it's hard to really answer or know if we are replying on topic. I don't think it was "how can we get kids doing taijiquan" but I may have missed it.
 
"how can we get kids doing taijiquan"
My Taiji teacher won't teach anybody who is under 30 years old.

Kids should not train Taiji. The sinking shoulder and hollow chest are not good for their posture. The kid's posture should be able to hold a pencil by their back muscle. To extend chest is a must for all kids.

 
Last edited:
Then can we be honest for a moment please? If I had gone into Goju-ryu, Isshin-ryu, Aikido or a similar system I would be 3rd dan black belt by now. If I was 4th or 5th I would probably be expected to be running my own series of dojos, so I am not quite there yet. But coming up in a ratings system there is a structure and a path to mastery that does not exist in american tai chi. The idea of wushu as a career is dead in America.

When I was 12 or 13 I started in the Taoist Tai Chi society and I spent a decade in there dreaming I was learning Tai Chi. I volunteered a lot, I worked at the front desk in highschool. I helped with the food programs at the ten directions temple on D'arcy Street. I lived down the street on D'arcy and elsewhere in the area during that time. In my depression I failed university because I would just go out in the morning for 3 or 4 hours and follow the old people training. I think they adopted me as some sort of pet.

Where are all the other kids learning Tai Chi? They're in China. Kids in America don't learn Tai Chi. It isn't cool. Laugh and troll all you want, China has a Duan system and there is great wisdom in what they are doing. It would have been better if I moved to China when I was young instead of later in life. But how was I supposed to know that or do that? If went there I probably would have found some friends. Something I have come to realize is that if you really want to learn Tai Chi you probably have to just go to China.

I'm not saying there are no good Tai Chi schools in America. I am saying that because of the way it's advertised and presented kids don't find it. A ratings system would change that. That is a fact.
Kids in China are factually not lining up to learn Taiji any more than kids in the U.S, except for Wushu performance nonsense. It isn't cool in China either. A rating system would in no way change that, unless you're planning to water down things significantly. That is a fact. The Duan system is respected little outside of Wushu performance circles and by foreigners who think rank inherently must mean skill, which it does not. I think you're living in some delusions about the realty of Taiji, the reality of China, and then conflating them with some personal life disappointments that have little to do with the reality of learning Taiji anywhere in the world.
 
The "ratings" you are talking about are presumably for something else. But you haven't been clear imho about what is the actual problem you want to solve, so it's hard to really answer or know if we are replying on topic. I don't think it was "how can we get kids doing taijiquan" but I may have missed it.

šŸ™‚

The current practice of competitive push hands is partly an outgrowth of efforts to promote Taiji and make it more accessible to the general public. The same process occurs in many martial arts as they attempt to broaden participation. Judo comes to mind.

I'm not particularly a fan of competitive push hands in general, but I understand its attraction for some and why they train for it. Outside of competitions, the places where these groups regularly practice can provide good opportunities to test one's skills against people from different backgrounds.

It's a way to learn something about one's own abilities. However, I would caution against attempting to learn training methods from others in these settings, or imposing one's own methods by trying to teach them, particularly when those involved come from different training backgrounds and have different objectives. Unless, of course, competition itself is the focus of one's practice.

I once worked with two Olympic-level judoka who were interested in Taiji. They happened to work for the same company I did.

Both complained about the state of Judo at the time. Although the training was quite demanding, they felt it had become increasingly oriented toward competition, concentrating on a few high-percentage techniques that produced results under competition rules.
 
Then can we be honest for a moment please?
Absolutely
, China has a Duan system and there is great wisdom in what they are doing. That is a fact.
Yes, and it’s available, the Chinese Wushu Association have representatives outside China.

ā€œStarting in 2024, Overseas Personnel Duan Examinations have been conducted through international events such as the 8th World Tai Chi Health Congress, establishing a Standardized Promotion Network covering both domestic and international regions.ā€
 
The current practice of competitive push hands is partly an outgrowth of efforts to promote Taiji and make it more accessible to the general public. The same process occurs in many martial arts as they attempt to broaden participation. Judo comes to mind.

This is part of a long process of development. Originally, the Japanese and Korean styles didn't have belts or ranks either. It was part of a process of modernization and classification -- although some may say ossification, I disagree. Overall I think the process was beneficial for those particular styles.

I once worked with two Olympic-level judoka who were interested in Taiji. They happened to work for the same company I did.

Both complained about the state of Judo at the time. Although the training was quite demanding, they felt it had become increasingly oriented toward competition, concentrating on a few high-percentage techniques that produced results under competition rules.
It may be possible to take the best from the successful systems (like Judo) and learn lessons from the mistakes they made. The model that they created probably shouldn't be imported wholesale, but it very nearly could be.

the Chinese Wushu Association have representatives outside China.

ā€œStarting in 2024, Overseas Personnel Duan Examinations have been conducted through international events such as the 8th World Tai Chi Health Congress, establishing a Standardized Promotion Network covering both domestic and international regions.ā€
I looked it up -- it is also promoted by the USAWKF and the IWUF. Today you can grade up to 5 Duan in America! How cool is that?
 
Last edited:
Doesn't everyone agree that is what push hands should be anwyays? A partner exercise for sharing and learning together?

Within one's own practice group, it has always been so.

Among those outside the group, not necessarily.

Part of the reason many in the Taiji world have difficulty using what they practice outside the push hands format. There is little incentive to develop beyond it when the exercise itself becomes the goal.
 
Within one's own practice group, it has always been so.

Among those outside the group, not necessarily.

Part of the reason many in the Taiji world have difficulty using what they practice outside the push hands format. There is little incentive to develop beyond it when the exercise itself becomes the goal.
Then standardization and increasing exposure among groups is the obvious next step. Pushing hands with your own group only is well known to cause deficiencies. You should push hands with as many people as possible.

This is hard to do today for some reason!
 
This is hard to do today for some reason!

Right šŸ™‚

look at it a little differently.
One should try to engage / spar with as many people as possible.

If your skill set is good gained through one’s practice, it shouldn’t really matter what they do. It’s all the same.

Which is why ā€œtrainingā€ with those who train for different purposes doesn’t make any sense depending on what one is looking for .

To win a contest, or functional usage outside of it. It’s important to understand the nature of one’s training.
 
Last edited:
This is part of a long process of development. Originally, the Japanese and Korean styles didn't have belts or ranks either. It was part of a process of modernization and classification -- although some may say ossification, I disagree. Overall I think the process was beneficial for those particular styles.
Actually a Dan ranking system can be traced back to early 1600.

Also before the Kyu/Dan scale of ranking there was(still are) the licensing systems.
 
One of my students' requirement for his students' ranking system include the following:

In order to get a Blue Belt all students need to compete; no need for a medal, but they need to be exposed to contact sports.

Black Belt is now all Sanda and they need to create their own combos and apply them. Black belts have to have at least one gold medal in any contact sport.
 
Last edited:
One of my students' requirement for his students' ranking system include the following:

In order to get a Blue Belt all students need to compete; no need for a medal, but they need to be exposed to contact sports.

Black Belt is now all Sanda and they need to create their own combos and apply them. Black belts have to have at least one gold medal in any contact sport.
Does this [contact sport] include push hand competition and so possibly the OP’s idea of ranking through PH ?
 
Does this [contact sport] include push hand competition and so possibly the OP’s idea of ranking through PH ?
If you can use your push hand skill to deal with Karate guys, kickboxers, TKD guys, MT guys, boxers, ... that will mean a lot.

I strongly believe that we should test our MA skill against different MA systems. From the Email that I have received from my student, I believe my student means full contact Karate, or full contact kickboxing (This just prove we are not just talking about it. we are actually doing it).

"I forgot to tell you yesterday that both Michael and Justin are preparing to compete in full contact Karate in San Antonio in February and then full contact kickboxing in Houston in April of next year. Even with a recovering knee I have already started to spar them, carefully, of course."
 
Last edited:
If you can use your push hand skill to deal with Karate guys, kickboxers, TKD guys, MT guys, boxers, ... that will mean a lot.

I strongly believe that we should test our MA skill against different MA systems. From the Email that I have received from my student, I believe my student means full contact Karate, or full contact kickboxing (This just prove we are not just talking about it. we are actually doing it).

"I forgot to tell you yesterday that both Michael and Justin are preparing to compete in full contact Karate in San Antonio in February and then full contact kickboxing in Houston in April of next year. Even with a recovering knee I have already started to spar them, carefully, of course."
Ok, so to gain a black belt In shuaijiao sport one must compete in kick boxing ?
 
Ok, so to gain a black belt In shuaijiao sport one must compete in kick boxing ?
Not kick boxing but Sanda (kick + punch + throw).

In the past 50 years, The SC art has been evolved into CSC (combat SC) that include kick/punch. If combat is your goal, you just can't lock yourself in the throwing art only.

This is why I strongly suggest that Taiji should also step out of it's comfort PH zone and go much further beyond.
 
Last edited:

Latest Discussions

Back
Top