skribs176 196
Grandmaster
Rokas is in the process of releasing USDC Season 4, having also just released the women's version as well. This season features a smaller Sambo player, a strongman with no fighting skills, a "normal man" in a metalhead with no fighting skills, a TKD guy that hurts his neck in the first challenge, a HEMA expert, and a professional bodyguard.
In my opinion, the show's production value has gone up, but the content is worse. In fact, I've taken it off of my "all notifications" list and have stopped watching this season. There's two issues that most folks have brought up in the comments, and a third issue that I'll present as well.
- The judging is absolutely horrible
- The show is now just "getting jumped simulator"
- There are too many "underdogs" this season
The judging this season has drawn so many comments that one of the judges made a video trying to explain them. The judging has seen numerous issues. Most of these stem from the scoring being entirely subjective to the two judges. One of the judges in particular seems to have designed these scenarios with specific solutions in mind, and judges contestants based not on their performance, but on how close they were to his solution.
A great example of this is in the first episode when a contestant is blindfolded, and as soon as the blindfold is removed, there is an attacker in front and an attacker behind, and the attacker behind immediately sucker-punches the contestant. Contestants aren't supposed to meta-game (in fact, in the first round of challenges, one contestant gets 0 points for a challenge because he had a pre-planned solution that he "meta-gamed" which would be unrealistic in the scenario). So what's the contestant supposed to do?
The judge's response video said they expected the contestant to immediately attack the person in front of them. But the person in front of them has given them no reason to. But he scored contestants based on how closely they fit his expectations for how the challenge should go.
On top of that, there's several situations where the judging doesn't even make sense. A later episode features a situation where you are supposed to be on a date at a bar, and the date's ex-boyfriend shows up. The bodyguard did an excellent job de-escalating and started to leave with the girl. Looks back to make sure that they aren't being followed, and the attacker throws a glass at him. He avoids being hit and engages the attacker. He got minus points for "lack of awareness" and for re-engaging a fight that didn't need it. Again, the contestant's decision was held up by those in the comments and the judges were lampooned for their bad take.
What worked in the past? Season 1 mostly featured fights of contestant vs. contestant, which did a very good job of creating a scoreboard. It's much easier to balance a PvP game than PvE game (Player vs. Player or Player vs. Environment), because the players balance the score against each other. However, Seasons 2 and 3 focused more on scenarios than on fights, and there were usually specific criteria in those scenarios. For example, how close did you get to achieving a goal? How long did you last? How many times did you get stabbed in the shank tank? Metrics make it easy to see who did the best in the challenge.
Getting Jumped Simulator
In both of the above examples, we see the show starts to become more about dealing with getting jumped than the wide range of self-defense skills including de-escalation, avoidance, running away, etc. Granted, the first two episodes focused on surprise attacks with the blindfold, but contestants were getting sucker punched or getting taken down immediately upon the blindfold being removed. In the third episode, we have blind attacks with a beer glass and a table (in the same scenario) and then a man who just walks up and slams a glass into the date's face.
All of these scenarios had a very quick escalation from 0 to fighting for your life. While this is an important part of self-defense, it seems to be every scenario this time around. Honestly, I would've wanted to participate in something like this, especially in seasons 2 and 3, but season 4 looks like it's just a recipe for CTE.
Underdogs
In this season, 1/3 of the contestants don't even have a fighting background. It would be more fine if this season had 8 contestants like season 3. But we have 2 contestants that aren't fighters. We have a third contestant that is "small" and they keep going on about that. We have a HEMA fighter participating in unarmed competition and they keep talking about his lack of experience with striking. So far, the season seems focused on what people can't do instead of what they can. And then going back to the judging: folks who aren't fighters get points for "fighting spirit" instead of their performance in the situation.
The comments have also been pretty brutal about the attitudes of the contestants (calling them "crybabies" or too emotional), which I think is a bit harsh, but also not completely wrong. I think this stems from a few things:
- We don't have charismatic folks like Natan Levy or Sensei Seth, or big personalities like Icy Mike or Master Ken (who wasn't a contestant, but did add to the entertainment value).
- The directing and editing seems to focus more on people's problems. This goes for how frustrated they are a their performance in the challenges, to how challenges connect with them emotionally (such as in the CPR challenge, where some contestants have had experiences with loved ones having a heart attack), or what problems they're facing (such as a sore neck or diabetes).
- Going back to the judging and the "getting jumped" simulator, this doesn't seem like a fun season. I think its clear the contestants aren't having fun. When the entertainers aren't enjoying the show, it's very difficult for the audience to enjoy it as well.
I really enjoyed USDC Season 1. I thought they stepped it up for Season 2. Season 3 was more entertaining, but I also felt strayed away from the original intention of the show in order to make it more entertaining. For example, there was one club fight where the contestants were encouraged to make a highlight reel. But at lest it was fun. Season 4 (both the women's season and men's season) seem to be stripped of all entertainment value and focus too much on specific scenarios that the judges have created. I think the judges have really taken this season down, and I'm not a fan of this season.
For those who are watching, what are your thoughts on the show? What are your thoughts on the commenters or on my review?