I was taught the Muay Thai round kick in JKD the other night. Does anyone here practcie it? Any advice on perfecting it? I still throw a snappy roundhouse kick with my instep from years of karate and it may be a hard habit to break.
Muay Thai Round Kick.
- Thread starter arnisador
- Start date
T
ThuNder_FoOt
Guest
Hi everyone, I'm just posting in request to Kumasan.
I'll try to point out a few subtle differences that I have noticed. Well,in the first part of MT, the pivot of the hip begins at the start of the kick. AS you chamber you begin to pivot so you can generate more power. Upon impact, you continue into your target until there is almost no recoil, then pivot your hips back to facing your opponent and drop your leg down straight in front or in back and resume fighting stance (no rechamber position). During this time, you are in on-guard in fighting stance, and can easily launch another kick if the situation calls for it.
With TKD, you don't pivot on the chambering portion of the kick. In TKD, you bring the kick up chambered like a front snap kick, then pivot your hip as you extend your leg. So the first half of the TKD roundhouse kick, is actually a front kick. Then upon impact, you continue into your target until about half recoil. You use the rest of the recoil energy to recover, getting in a quick rechambered position. From this crane stance, you are pretty much on-guard in fighting stance, as TKD uses crane stance for advanced offense and defense techniques. Even so, you could still place your leg down, while still ready to lauch another kick if need be.
Basically MT kicks seem to dig in a bit more than TKD kicks. TKD kicks do have more potential to be faster because they travel a shorter distance, and the reverse that MT kicks have the potential to be stronger because they travel a further distance. To tell the truth, both kicks pretty much have the potential for the same speed and pretty much same power. The only thing that might differ would be the initiation of the kicks.
Generally speaking though, MT kicks are a bit stronger, and TKD kicks are a bit faster.
Let me know if you guys have any other view on this. I think its a very controversial subject, as this was only my personal experience.
:asian: :asian:
I'll try to point out a few subtle differences that I have noticed. Well,in the first part of MT, the pivot of the hip begins at the start of the kick. AS you chamber you begin to pivot so you can generate more power. Upon impact, you continue into your target until there is almost no recoil, then pivot your hips back to facing your opponent and drop your leg down straight in front or in back and resume fighting stance (no rechamber position). During this time, you are in on-guard in fighting stance, and can easily launch another kick if the situation calls for it.
With TKD, you don't pivot on the chambering portion of the kick. In TKD, you bring the kick up chambered like a front snap kick, then pivot your hip as you extend your leg. So the first half of the TKD roundhouse kick, is actually a front kick. Then upon impact, you continue into your target until about half recoil. You use the rest of the recoil energy to recover, getting in a quick rechambered position. From this crane stance, you are pretty much on-guard in fighting stance, as TKD uses crane stance for advanced offense and defense techniques. Even so, you could still place your leg down, while still ready to lauch another kick if need be.
Basically MT kicks seem to dig in a bit more than TKD kicks. TKD kicks do have more potential to be faster because they travel a shorter distance, and the reverse that MT kicks have the potential to be stronger because they travel a further distance. To tell the truth, both kicks pretty much have the potential for the same speed and pretty much same power. The only thing that might differ would be the initiation of the kicks.
Generally speaking though, MT kicks are a bit stronger, and TKD kicks are a bit faster.
Let me know if you guys have any other view on this. I think its a very controversial subject, as this was only my personal experience.
:asian: :asian:
Thank you sir, that's exactly the sort of information Iwas looking for. I'm not interested in the "you're style sucks, mine is better" kind of junk. I appreciate the info.
:asian:
:asian:
T
ThuNder_FoOt
Guest
Thats good to here. I'm glad you appreciate the martial arts, because one can grow tired of trivial crap bewtween arts. So you train Muay Thai right?
Have you experienced a similar situation in your training, another kicking style... then MT? I often find myself throwing some TKD combinations, with a couple exceptions. They seem to work well! I love the feel of both the arts. Most boxers are used to standing at mid-distance, but my stance is at far distance, because of my TKD. Now I have a better understanding altogether.
Also, do you feel a tingling sensation in you r striking area rite before you strike? I've noticed it before, but recently the feeling has been getting stronger for me. It doesn't hurt at all, it actually kinda tickles... I just wonder if anyone else feels this.
Have you experienced a similar situation in your training, another kicking style... then MT? I often find myself throwing some TKD combinations, with a couple exceptions. They seem to work well! I love the feel of both the arts. Most boxers are used to standing at mid-distance, but my stance is at far distance, because of my TKD. Now I have a better understanding altogether.
Also, do you feel a tingling sensation in you r striking area rite before you strike? I've noticed it before, but recently the feeling has been getting stronger for me. It doesn't hurt at all, it actually kinda tickles... I just wonder if anyone else feels this.
I don't have very much direct experience with other kicking styles. A friend showed me the basics of performing the sidekick, but that's about all I have. I have sparred people that had a TKD background, and the big problem I have is the number of different kicks. They can easily catch you off guard. If you get locked into a MT mindset, then you only expect teeps and round kicks. The axe kick or side kick (just to name two) can catch you completely unawares. I like that, it forces me to keep an open mind.
No, I've never got a tingly feeling right before striking. Sounds kind of odd.
No, I've never got a tingly feeling right before striking. Sounds kind of odd.
Damian Mavis
Master Black Belt
I teach Tae Kwon do but train at a Muay Thai school. I agree with the poster that said tkd kicks are faster and muay thai is stronger, that has been my experience too. But i think you were asking for advice on how to perfect the Muay thai roundkick?
Hmmm.. when I first joined Muay Thai I found it extremely difficult to make the transition from tkd to thai. Basically I just really focused on keeping the knee slightly bent and keeping the shin prominently exposed for the striking area without straightening my leg on impact. The other major concept I kept in my mind was really turning the hip and shoulder into the kick. In TKD we often fudge a little and dont turn all the way to increase speed. Other than that I just practiced it a zillion times until it became natural. My best advice to anyone about any technique is always pratice it over and over until your body recognises it as a natural movement.
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
Hmmm.. when I first joined Muay Thai I found it extremely difficult to make the transition from tkd to thai. Basically I just really focused on keeping the knee slightly bent and keeping the shin prominently exposed for the striking area without straightening my leg on impact. The other major concept I kept in my mind was really turning the hip and shoulder into the kick. In TKD we often fudge a little and dont turn all the way to increase speed. Other than that I just practiced it a zillion times until it became natural. My best advice to anyone about any technique is always pratice it over and over until your body recognises it as a natural movement.
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
T
ThuNder_FoOt
Guest
Wow Damien, that's my exact training situation. I teach TKD, but I'm currently learning MT along with perfecting my TKD techniques under tutolage of my Master. I have never really had a problem with executing an MT kick from TKD. I practice constantly to keep my MT separate from my TKD and vice versa. For some reason, this seems to help me when I want to mix up in combinations. Keeping the two martial arts separate, allows me to better transfer from one techniqe to another between arts if necessary.
So, you too feel that MT kicks are stronger, and TKD are faster? Yes, I've noticed in my MT class I can usually score the kick faster than my fellow juniors and seniors. Obviously, I'm speaking in general terms, but I openly share my knowledge with my classmates, so they may be better prepared against various styles.
I must admit, I am more skilled in TKD, as I have more training time in TKD. Mixed with leg kicks, you can take full advantage of TKD kick cuts and proceed to set up from just about anything!!!! Do you find your TKD techniquea valuable in the MT ring? What are some of your views of associating MT with TKD?
:asian:
So, you too feel that MT kicks are stronger, and TKD are faster? Yes, I've noticed in my MT class I can usually score the kick faster than my fellow juniors and seniors. Obviously, I'm speaking in general terms, but I openly share my knowledge with my classmates, so they may be better prepared against various styles.
I must admit, I am more skilled in TKD, as I have more training time in TKD. Mixed with leg kicks, you can take full advantage of TKD kick cuts and proceed to set up from just about anything!!!! Do you find your TKD techniquea valuable in the MT ring? What are some of your views of associating MT with TKD?
:asian:
Damian Mavis
Master Black Belt
In the ring I find hammer kick and sidekick catches my opponent off guard alot. The hammer kick comes from an angle they don't train to defend from and the sidekick can look like a round kick and then go up the middle while they are shielding on the side for a round kick so it works pretty good too. Spinning hook kick is good too...but I find that unless I use it as a counter and full speed and power (no pulling that kick) it won't work. If I counter with it full speed it lands...the only problem is it is dangerous if I catch them in the face instead of the head gear. When sparring with a buddy I won't use it unless I'm goofing around and pull it...it's the kind of kick you gotta go full power or not at all. When we do serious sparring I use it if the opurtunity arises and hope I don't hit a soft target. One of my students caught a full power heel in the face in my TKD class and he had to get a steel plate put into his face to keep his eye from sinking into his head (the cheek was cracked and shifting). Not something I want to do to someone unless it's life and death.
In general TKD gave me a huge foundation to learn Muay Thai. The boxing aspects and clich knee were harder to learn than the kicking techniques thanks to 12 years of kicking training in TKD.
You have the same instructor for TKD and MT? Or 2 different instructors? And do you run your own school or teach for your TKD instructor?
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
In general TKD gave me a huge foundation to learn Muay Thai. The boxing aspects and clich knee were harder to learn than the kicking techniques thanks to 12 years of kicking training in TKD.
You have the same instructor for TKD and MT? Or 2 different instructors? And do you run your own school or teach for your TKD instructor?
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
T
ThuNder_FoOt
Guest
Damien,
I actually have two separate teachers for TKD and MT. My TKD teacher does't really have knowledge of MT, although I did mention to him that I was taking up the MA. He was a little disappointed at first, because he thought I was leaving TKD. Ever since then, he has increased my training vastly, so I don't forget my TKD training... because every now and then, I accidentally slip up and throw a MT technique which are always illegal.
I am an instructor (not to be confused with chokyonim), but I don't own my own school. My master asked me to open one, but I'm no where near ready for that kind of responsibility. Not only that, but I feel that I need major improvement on my techniques before I can consider myself good enough to operate my own school. I may be selfish, but I want to have more time to improve my own technique, instead of trying to improve other's. Also, with me working under his school, I can easily have time to study other systems while still getting the benefits of teaching and learning TKD.
I totally agree on the part of MT boxers not being able to defend against such kicks. I notice more and more MT boxers training in TKD so that they may expand their range of techniques, as well as being able to defend against them. Do you find it easier to throw an effective TKD roundhouse or a MT roundhouse? I seemed to be able to pick up on the MT roundhouse very easily... its actually easier than the TKD version, for me... but ALOT slower. AS far as the clinch techniques, they are fairly simple, but its a little hard to get into that mind set at first.
So how about you? 2 instructors or just 1? do you own your own school? Also, do you find yourself watching Ernie Reyes Jr. alot, as he has a TKD background, but is now competing in Fairtex? I've gotten a few inspirations from him. :asian: :asian:
I actually have two separate teachers for TKD and MT. My TKD teacher does't really have knowledge of MT, although I did mention to him that I was taking up the MA. He was a little disappointed at first, because he thought I was leaving TKD. Ever since then, he has increased my training vastly, so I don't forget my TKD training... because every now and then, I accidentally slip up and throw a MT technique which are always illegal.
I am an instructor (not to be confused with chokyonim), but I don't own my own school. My master asked me to open one, but I'm no where near ready for that kind of responsibility. Not only that, but I feel that I need major improvement on my techniques before I can consider myself good enough to operate my own school. I may be selfish, but I want to have more time to improve my own technique, instead of trying to improve other's. Also, with me working under his school, I can easily have time to study other systems while still getting the benefits of teaching and learning TKD.
I totally agree on the part of MT boxers not being able to defend against such kicks. I notice more and more MT boxers training in TKD so that they may expand their range of techniques, as well as being able to defend against them. Do you find it easier to throw an effective TKD roundhouse or a MT roundhouse? I seemed to be able to pick up on the MT roundhouse very easily... its actually easier than the TKD version, for me... but ALOT slower. AS far as the clinch techniques, they are fairly simple, but its a little hard to get into that mind set at first.
So how about you? 2 instructors or just 1? do you own your own school? Also, do you find yourself watching Ernie Reyes Jr. alot, as he has a TKD background, but is now competing in Fairtex? I've gotten a few inspirations from him. :asian: :asian:
Damian Mavis
Master Black Belt
I unfortunately had to leave my TKD instructor (after training with him for 9 years). So I don't actually attend a TKD school anymore, instead I get together with other instructors in my city to train and spar with; I also train with my students but it's not the same as training with a fellow instructor. I teach in the ITF and in my city the instructors often get together for black belt trainings. My ability and technique is light years ahead of what it was when I was training under my instructor, but he gave me the foundation.
As for Muay Thai I train at a Muay Thai academy that is under the Dan Inosanto/Ajarn Chai family tree. I train every day.
I find the Thai roundkick slower than a snappy TKD round kick but not a whole lot slower..... yes most Thai boxers kick pretty slow compared to TKD but I've seen professional Thai boxers that kick extremely fast. I think it just has to do with skill level.
I don't own my own school... I rent. I'd love to watch Ernie Reyes Jr. but I have no idea were to go to see him, give me some links!
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
As for Muay Thai I train at a Muay Thai academy that is under the Dan Inosanto/Ajarn Chai family tree. I train every day.
I find the Thai roundkick slower than a snappy TKD round kick but not a whole lot slower..... yes most Thai boxers kick pretty slow compared to TKD but I've seen professional Thai boxers that kick extremely fast. I think it just has to do with skill level.
I don't own my own school... I rent. I'd love to watch Ernie Reyes Jr. but I have no idea were to go to see him, give me some links!
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
S
Shadowdean
Guest
Interesting, in my school, the TKD roundhouse is almost a hybrid...the leg is chambered, but there is no true 2 part round house..we leave back a bit and continually drive the hip through the kick.
N
nasigoreng
Guest
The 2 are actually very different. The Jun Fan kickboxing kick is also a straight leg kick so it LOOKS like a MT roundhouse.
The difference is the MT roundhouse kick generates more power by 'pushing through' the target with the hips.
The MT kicker will often take a small step towards opnt. and to the side ( like defensive triangle in arnis).
Whereas the j.f. kickbxr is more or less squared up with the opnt when throwing the kick, the MT fighter on the other hand is not. I've found that this orientation puts the MT fighter's oppnt. inside the kicker's 'power arc' = the oppnt will absorb a lot more energy from the kick.
The TKD kickers are fast and they've got some really confusing kicks. But MT kicks, even if blocked, will drive the opponent backwards to the ropes.
any comments?
The difference is the MT roundhouse kick generates more power by 'pushing through' the target with the hips.
The MT kicker will often take a small step towards opnt. and to the side ( like defensive triangle in arnis).
Whereas the j.f. kickbxr is more or less squared up with the opnt when throwing the kick, the MT fighter on the other hand is not. I've found that this orientation puts the MT fighter's oppnt. inside the kicker's 'power arc' = the oppnt will absorb a lot more energy from the kick.
The TKD kickers are fast and they've got some really confusing kicks. But MT kicks, even if blocked, will drive the opponent backwards to the ropes.
any comments?
S
sweeper
Guest
"The Jun Fan kickboxing kick" ?
I have always been told to throw a hook kick in as tight of an arc as posibal, basicly trying to get your foot to travel as close to a strate linne as you can, so it doesn't swing like a MT round kick. Am I thinking of the same kick as you are?
Also question about TKD round kicks. I don't know the first thing about TKD besides 1: it's korean 2: there are lots of kicks ;-) . Now I have a freind who practices TKD and one day we were talking about the way he trains and the way I train. Anyway we got on the subject of kicks and "non-telegraphic" kicks came up, basicly an unchambered speed kick, he didn't demonstrate but I was wondering, is this something particular to his school? Or is that a typical TKD method of kicking? And if so why does everyone say TKD fighters chamber their legs?
I have always been told to throw a hook kick in as tight of an arc as posibal, basicly trying to get your foot to travel as close to a strate linne as you can, so it doesn't swing like a MT round kick. Am I thinking of the same kick as you are?
Also question about TKD round kicks. I don't know the first thing about TKD besides 1: it's korean 2: there are lots of kicks ;-) . Now I have a freind who practices TKD and one day we were talking about the way he trains and the way I train. Anyway we got on the subject of kicks and "non-telegraphic" kicks came up, basicly an unchambered speed kick, he didn't demonstrate but I was wondering, is this something particular to his school? Or is that a typical TKD method of kicking? And if so why does everyone say TKD fighters chamber their legs?
Damian Mavis
Master Black Belt
Hello again Sweeper
TKD can chamber the leg but you don't have to. We are taught to chamber but if your looking for tricks to sneak in some kicks that your opponent might not see coming as well then not chambering is a good trick. It could be particular to his school or his style of TKD but I have often kicked unchambered in TKD and it was just a strategic way of kicking at that moment.
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
TKD can chamber the leg but you don't have to. We are taught to chamber but if your looking for tricks to sneak in some kicks that your opponent might not see coming as well then not chambering is a good trick. It could be particular to his school or his style of TKD but I have often kicked unchambered in TKD and it was just a strategic way of kicking at that moment.
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
S
sweeper
Guest
so than it is a part of TKD training.
I mean to say that TKD fighters kick from a chambered position is incorrect when comparing to another art because they don't only kick from a chambered position.
I mean to say that TKD fighters kick from a chambered position is incorrect when comparing to another art because they don't only kick from a chambered position.
Damian Mavis
Master Black Belt
Honestly I think you can label TKD as a chambering art.... I just happen to use unchambered kicks sometimes.
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
Damian Mavis
Honour TKD
S
sweeper
Guest
ok nevermind thanb
thanks for the info.
thanks for the info.
