Martial artist claims in Kung Fu Magazine to have been an assassin of child traffickers for Interpol:
http://ezine.kungfumagazine.com/ezine/article.php?article=499
http://ezine.kungfumagazine.com/ezine/article.php?article=499
Does This Sound Letigimate? MA Claims to Have Been Assassin for Interpol...
- Thread starter Jonathan Randall
- Start date
sgtmac_46
Senior Master
Sounds like BS to me. Too much 'bang bang bang, super-agent' talk to be plausable.Jonathan Randall said:
Usually, men claiming they were assassins for <insert super-secret agency here> usually have either mental issues or simply a problem with the truth. If I had a penny for every 'Ex-Navy Seal or Special Forces super-commando' i'd be a rich man. What's more, if there were as many ex-Special Operations guys as claim that they are ex-Special Operations, it would be the largest branch of the military, with millions of ready operatives.
I call BS.
sgtmac_46
Senior Master
Here's a little more on him
http://charlotte.creativeloafing.com/2003-02-26/news_cover.html
Chuck Barris wannabe? Yeah, i'd say that's about right.
Here's the big question....why would a guy with a wife and kids, risk retaliation by revealing his identy to 'shadowy figures' he's obviously angered over the years? Answer? He wouldn't.
This guy could be telling the truth. My gut reaction, though, is that he's weaving an elaborate deception. If he's lying, some people are going to look awfully foolish.
http://charlotte.creativeloafing.com/2003-02-26/news_cover.html
Chuck Barris wannabe? Yeah, i'd say that's about right.
Here's the big question....why would a guy with a wife and kids, risk retaliation by revealing his identy to 'shadowy figures' he's obviously angered over the years? Answer? He wouldn't.
This guy could be telling the truth. My gut reaction, though, is that he's weaving an elaborate deception. If he's lying, some people are going to look awfully foolish.
digitalronin
Green Belt
theres a lot of fakes in martial arts magazines trying to sell tapes that will turn u into an instant killer.
sgtmac_46 said:
I was hoping you'd weigh in on this. My first thought was to call BS as well. I know that child trafficking is a major industry and, in my heart of hearts, I wish there WERE people doing this. One thing I do know; in the real thing (memoirs written by individuals with VERIFIABLE histories), operators tend to DISCOUNT the role of martial arts in Special Operations - less talk of mano a mano H2H and more talk of long distance snipers.
This is his book. It has a five star review:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0882822314/104-1871610-1121501?v=glance&n=283155
sgtmac_46
Senior Master
Jonathan Randall said:
You are correct. In the stories of real operators, there seem to be two things absent that are present in those of fakes. One is over-moralizing. Real operator's don't have to turn everything in to a moral plea. The real operator's i've met tend to be very matter of fact, concrete people. They don't explain things about 'sleepless nights'. In fact, most of them sleep rather well. They also don't talk about 'mano a mano' hand to hand fights either. If they do, they don't describe them as 'martial arts matches'. I believe at one point he says the most absurd thing, like
How lame. In addition, it sounds a little too much like an over-stylized version of a confrontation involving Richard Marcinko in one of his fictional Red Cell books where Marcinko's fictional self gets in a confrontation with an Okinawan security guard at an airfield (described as an old man) who whips Marcinko pretty good, before Marcinko's 'partner' grabs the old man from behind.
He did buy himself some time by picking a LARGE organization, like Interpol, that operates abroad, instead of a 'special forces unit'. The size and compartmentalized nature will prolong his ability to suspend disbelief. What's more, most American's know very little about Interpol, what it does or even where it does it.
I suspect his efforts to bring attention to child trafficking is shielding him from too much criticism as to the veracity of his claims. It wouldn't be the first time someone has had a good message built on lies and got a free pass for a long time because of it.
sgtmac_46 said:
Perhaps, then, this belongs in Horror Stories?
sgtmac_46
Senior Master
Possibly. Here's a little primer to compare with...Jonathan Randall said:
http://www.pownetwork.org/phonies/phonies86.htm
http://www.abc.net.au/foreign/stories/s415886.htm
http://www.homeofheroes.com/a_homepage/community/imposters/
This guy has been talked about on every forum devoted to martial arts frauds that exists.
Typical pattern; a past that no one seems able to confirm, denials from those that should know, explinations of secrecy to cover up that fact by guys who are all over the internet and media making their claims, multiple claims that all stroke the ego and (again) can't be confirmed,...etc.
Oh, I can't say that I have been on every interpol misssion and know everything that goes on in it. But based on the lack of facts, silliness of the claims, the obvious ego stroking and everything else, I am convinced this guy is just another idiotic fraud.
Typical pattern; a past that no one seems able to confirm, denials from those that should know, explinations of secrecy to cover up that fact by guys who are all over the internet and media making their claims, multiple claims that all stroke the ego and (again) can't be confirmed,...etc.
Oh, I can't say that I have been on every interpol misssion and know everything that goes on in it. But based on the lack of facts, silliness of the claims, the obvious ego stroking and everything else, I am convinced this guy is just another idiotic fraud.
Don Roley said:
That about sums it up, IMO. Given your MA and Military Experience, I think your post has significant credibility. Those in the know discount such stories. There are ex- spec. ops. who DO rescue children overseas, but they DO NOT work for Interpol and they only use force in self-defence.
Dan G
Green Belt
Interpol is an international police organisation coordinating the international police work of member states. If the gentleman in question was busy assassinating anyone Interpol would be looking for them, not hiring them.
His involvement with the Kwanju riots (South Korea's Tianamen Square) is highly suspect, and if true (and I am confident it isn't) would likely prevent his return to South Korea. One former Korean president received a commuted death sentence for their role in quelling the riots, and as I understand it the official US position is that no US troops were involved, and the US controlled Korean units were returned to Korean command prior to the incident.
The marked focus on child abuse quoted on the site below, and the associated aggression is disturbing, and could benefit from the attention of an expert in criminal psychology. http://charlotte.creativeloafing.com/2003-02-26/news_cover.html
This isn't just BS, it deserves the serious attention of local law enforcement.
His involvement with the Kwanju riots (South Korea's Tianamen Square) is highly suspect, and if true (and I am confident it isn't) would likely prevent his return to South Korea. One former Korean president received a commuted death sentence for their role in quelling the riots, and as I understand it the official US position is that no US troops were involved, and the US controlled Korean units were returned to Korean command prior to the incident.
The marked focus on child abuse quoted on the site below, and the associated aggression is disturbing, and could benefit from the attention of an expert in criminal psychology. http://charlotte.creativeloafing.com/2003-02-26/news_cover.html
This isn't just BS, it deserves the serious attention of local law enforcement.
Dan G said:
This is correct. In fact contrary to what you see in spy movies, there are no interpol field agents.
They are basically a international clearing house for criminal records and warrants. They do no enforcement themselves, only technical support to member countries.
The closest thing they have to field agents is their crisis response teams. And these teams are made up of technicians and records clerks who set up command posts, with communication equipment, and technical and records research expertise.
John Bishop said:
Yes, that is what I thought.
BTW, I thought a bit about this guy after I last posted and the obvious thought occurred to me that NO European nation would risk having half-baked vigilantes running loose on their payroll, ready to cause an international incident at any time. Also, this guy supposedly received three months of intensive training before being sent out into the field as an operator. Three months? I doubt any American or European special forces or intelligence agency would send a member alone on missions with less than three years training and apprenticeship.
Thanks all who responded. The MT members most likely to know weighed in and I am gratful.
Also, as SGTMAC pointed out, traffickers fight with guns, not Hung Gar!
sgtmac_46
Senior Master
What bothers me most, is the lack of any serious challenge to this guys weak credibility. In fact, if you look on his site, you'll see book reviews from several national news sources, who, apparently, simply takes this guy at his word. Honestly, I believe it's his 'message' (about child trafficking) that is buying him a free pass. Some people are going to look awfully stupid when this is said and done.
There are some very good ex Special Operations guys doing some good debunking on those claiming veteran status with various elite US units, but apparently this guy has found, in 'Interpol' a shadowy enough claim to side-step criticism for a while.
There are some very good ex Special Operations guys doing some good debunking on those claiming veteran status with various elite US units, but apparently this guy has found, in 'Interpol' a shadowy enough claim to side-step criticism for a while.
BlackCatBonz
Master Black Belt
i watched a documentary on the child trade in europe about 2 months ago......more often than not, the police agencies of the asian and east european countries most affected tend to turn a blind eye to it, because of their own internal corruption.
tradrockrat
2nd Black Belt
yeah, this guy is a total fraud, IMHO. His martial arts are sooo weak! I remember one time, when we were fighting a large group of seven foot tall Russian Child trafficers. His skills were so weak that he would have died if I hadn't disarmed them all with my Chi balls of force.
My book will be out later this month.
My book will be out later this month.
evenflow1121
2nd Black Belt
I dont buy it but thats just me
I'll agree I doubt that if the man did have of what he claims :
1 he would not be able to talk about it
2 he would not discribe it in the ways he is uness he was selling books
3 he would not want his face shown
