Agree with my definition of 'warrior spirit' or disagree....

Do you agree or disagree with my definition of "warrior spirit"

  • Agree! Paul Janulis you are a genius!

  • Disagree! Paul Janulis you are still a genius!


Results are only viewable after voting.

Cruentus

Grandmaster
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
7,161
Reaction score
130
Location
At an OP in view of your house...
We were having a bit of trouble trying to define warrior spirit in a different thread.

Here is my definition:

I believe that a "Warrior" spirit is the inner drive to preserve ourselves, our families, our morals/beliefs, and our way of life.

Agree or disagree!

:asian:
 

loki09789

Senior Master
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
2,643
Reaction score
71
Location
Williamsville, NY
"will to survive, thirst for challenge, or strength to stand for a cause."

Subtle difference, but it is different.

I am not into preservation because it connotes things staying the same. I am all for survival so progress can happen.

Thirst for challenge can be educational, experiential... anything that pushes us to some limit.

strength to stand for a cause is similar to the presented definition.

Paul M.
 
OP
Cruentus

Cruentus

Grandmaster
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
7,161
Reaction score
130
Location
At an OP in view of your house...
O.K.

What is the difference between survival and "self preservation"?

Also, with your modified definition, how does "family" "morals/belief" and "way of life" fir in, if at all?

:cool:
 
B

Black Bear

Guest
I like PAUL's fine, except that I'd put something in there specifically about the willingness to use force or violence when these things are threatened. That seems to be a part of what we mean by warrior spirit.

I'm not sure how that definition would look like.

I kind of felt like I have no idea what ppl mean by "warrior spirit", like it's just some vague idea. But I like Paul's defn.
 

Tgace

Grandmaster
Joined
Jul 31, 2003
Messages
7,766
Reaction score
409
To me "warriorship" involves so many things I have a hard time distilling it into a definition. This article in the NCO Journal (USArmy) is a good source and is what one of the modern "warrior socities" views as the "warrior spirit".

http://www.usarc.army.mil/100thdiv/xxi/spirit1.htm
 

Makalakumu

Gonzo Karate Apocalypse
MT Mentor
Joined
Oct 30, 2003
Messages
13,887
Reaction score
232
Location
Hawaii
Originally posted by PAUL
We were having a bit of trouble trying to define warrior spirit in a different thread.

Here is my definition:

I believe that a "Warrior" spirit is the inner drive to preserve ourselves, our families, our morals/beliefs, and our way of life.

Agree or disagree!

:asian:

I think the root of this statement is "the ability to reject those not of our tribe."

The heart of humanity is xenophobia and I think this is imprinted into everysingle one of our cells. Time is changing this definition as homo sapians becomes a global organism. We are evolving. Hence the disagreement and general confusion regarding this concept.
 

pesilat

3rd Black Belt
MTS Alumni
Joined
Feb 16, 2003
Messages
982
Reaction score
15
Location
Cuenca, Ecuador
I believe that a "Warrior" spirit is the inner drive to preserve ourselves, our families, our morals/beliefs, and our way of life.

I agree - but think that's only part of it.

Not only the inner drive to preserve but also the inner drive to persevere. The willingness to fight and overcome any obstacle. The inability to quit - though a tactical retreat (to gain some sort of leverage) is sometimes warranted. And wisdom to know determine what is worth fighting for and what isn't.

My dad was the embodiment of what I consider the warrior spirit after his stroke a few years ago. The doctor told him, "You'll be in the hospital for 4 weeks going through rehab. When you leave, you'll probably still be in a wheelchair but might be on a walker. Keep up the rehab on your own and you'll probably get to a cane at some point - may even eventually not need the cane."

Dad said, "Nope. I'll walk out of the hospital without aid and I'll drive home."

Doctor said, "Sorry, Mr. Casto, that's not going to happen."

Dad said, "Hide and watch."

Four weeks later, they took him to the doors in a wheelchair - hospital policy - where he stood and walked unassisted to the car. It took him a couple of days to get to the point where he could drive - but the doctor was dumbfounded. Dad made front page of the local paper. He still walks with a pretty good limp, his left hand sometimes twitches oddly, and he's partially blind in his left eye - but he's considerably more functional than the doctor thought he would be.

Mike
 

Rich Parsons

A Student of Martial Arts
Founding Member
Lifetime Supporting Member
MTS Alumni
Joined
Oct 13, 2001
Messages
16,835
Reaction score
1,079
Location
Michigan
Paul,

I did not vote. I disagree just ot disagree as you know me ;)

Maybe I will change the Poll to include the other options mentioned here?

Nope then people who already voted could not revote.

:asian:
 

7starmantis

Grandmaster
MTS Alumni
Joined
Aug 13, 2002
Messages
5,493
Reaction score
55
Location
East Texas
I didn't vote simply because I don't see what any of this has to do with martial arts. What does someone's definition of a word or two words have to do with anyone training?

I guess I'm mising the whole "bandwagon" of using the term "Warrior Spirit".

7sm
 

pesilat

3rd Black Belt
MTS Alumni
Joined
Feb 16, 2003
Messages
982
Reaction score
15
Location
Cuenca, Ecuador
Originally posted by 7starmantis
I didn't vote simply because I don't see what any of this has to do with martial arts. What does someone's definition of a word or two words have to do with anyone training?

I guess I'm mising the whole "bandwagon" of using the term "Warrior Spirit".

7sm

In my estimation, "warrior spirit" - no matter how it's phrased - is at the core of martial arts training. Without "warrior spirit" it's hard to be a "martial" anything.

Mike
 

loki09789

Senior Master
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
2,643
Reaction score
71
Location
Williamsville, NY
"What is the difference between survival and "self preservation"?"

A banker earning millions of dollars a year who starts cheating on taxes, ENRON ring a bell, is 'preserving his way of life'

survival is persistance and perseverance, putting up with sliding up and down the quality of life scale put pushing on.

"Also, with your modified definition,"

It is only a modified definition if yours is the source definition, my definition is MY definition. Different from yours, not a modification of yours.

"how does "family" "morals/belief" and "way of life" fir in, if at all?"

Those would fall under strength to stand for a cause.

The willingness to use force, in what ever form that fits, is implied to me because:

the will to survival may manifest as violence if you have to survive an attack, or hunting if you have to survive isolation/being stranded somewhere....

thirst for challenge might include entering a boxing match or getting a PhD, either case requires the willingness to use force - force of body or mind.

Strength to stand for a cause might include going to my son's school to argue on his behalf if he is wrongly treated by teacher/student. Or, enlisting in the service to defend the Constitution of the USA

Violence is a specific form of force employment, too limited for my view of warrior 'spirit'.

Paul Martin
 

Yari

Master Black Belt
Joined
Feb 1, 2002
Messages
1,364
Reaction score
22
Location
Århus, Denmark
Warrior spirit is to live by a code, and really live by it.
The code is something you choose, and stick to it, through thick and thin.

/Yari
 
B

Black Bear

Guest
Originally posted by 7starmantis
I didn't vote simply because I don't see what any of this has to do with martial arts. What does someone's definition of a word or two words have to do with anyone training?

I guess I'm mising the whole "bandwagon" of using the term "Warrior Spirit".

7sm
Just the idea of Warrior Spirit is often invoked by martial artists, so the idea is, what does it really mean?

Yari, that's WAY to inclusive. ANYONE who lives by ANY code of their choosing has warrior spirit, provided they stick to it? That sounds ridiculous.
 

Yari

Master Black Belt
Joined
Feb 1, 2002
Messages
1,364
Reaction score
22
Location
Århus, Denmark
Originally posted by Black Bear
Just the idea of Warrior Spirit is often invoked by martial artists, so the idea is, what does it really mean?

Yari, that's WAY to inclusive. ANYONE who lives by ANY code of their choosing has warrior spirit, provided they stick to it? That sounds ridiculous.


Why?

I think it's more difficult to 100% follow rules, than make your own. But if you change your code in the same direction as the wind blows, there's no warrior code. You choose a code, and live by it.

If you choose the code to follow your leader (president, or what ever), you do it no matter what. Even if he tells you to jump in the lake or shoot your wife.

Now you can choose to say your code is only to serve yourself. And that's ok, but I dont think that's a high value code. THat's a code for only self preservation. You can give a code a higher value by following a bigger meaning, and sticking by it no matter what. And that's my point, a warrior is a person is a person who will stand by his code, even if everybody else doesn't. He'll be the last person standing for the code.

But we dont' have to agree, but calling it ridiculous, and not stating why, triggers me.

/Yari
 

loki09789

Senior Master
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
2,643
Reaction score
71
Location
Williamsville, NY
Originally posted by Yari
Warrior spirit is to live by a code, and really live by it.
The code is something you choose, and stick to it, through thick and thin.

/Yari

Yari's definitions has some validity because it is acknowledging the selflessness of warriorship/warrior spirit (WS). Standing for a cause, preserving way of life/welfare, all require an element of selfless service.


Paul M
 

Makalakumu

Gonzo Karate Apocalypse
MT Mentor
Joined
Oct 30, 2003
Messages
13,887
Reaction score
232
Location
Hawaii
Originally posted by loki09789
Yari's definitions has some validity because it is acknowledging the selflessness of warriorship/warrior spirit (WS). Standing for a cause, preserving way of life/welfare, all require an element of selfless service.


Paul M

In a way, the act of using violence to protect something is selfish to the extreme. Which is why buddhists advocate giving up all worldly connections.
 

loki09789

Senior Master
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
2,643
Reaction score
71
Location
Williamsville, NY
UpNorth,

Jump back up to my personal def. of WS and see that I agree with you about the WS not just fitting a 'violent' approach.

But even the Buddhist monks of Shaolin, when philosophy met reality, practiced/applied martial arts. They, like all philosophies, seem to have established a criteria for when it was just to use violence/force. As long as that criteria was met, the individual was physically/mentally/spiritually okay.

Now, even saying that, the selflessness for a Buddhist might be defined as one who commits violence, putting their personal path to enlightment second to the immediate needs of of their group.

I agree with your de-escalation/violence as a last approach view across the board, but there are times when violence/force is necessary, even at the expense of the individuals standing in society. I am not saying that it isn't horrible, but in the long view, look at the statistical comparisons during WWII if we had not dropped the atomic bomb. The lives taken was tragic, but 'less' in degree compared to the damage done in more conventional drawn out campaigns.

Paul M.
 
T

Ty K. Doe

Guest
To me, warrior spirit is simply the drive to never give up. To have the heart to go on even when things get difficult. Kinda like the old saying, "Quiters never win, and winners never quit."

It's not an overly complicated philosophy, but a simplistic attitude.
 

Latest Discussions

Top