Nope, you're not the only one. I myself am surprised at how seriously some folks are taking the whole premise of the show. There are some of us that plead to suspend disbelief and just enjoy the story while keeping both feet on the ground knowing that it's just what it is... a scary camp-fire story told in long form. Alas, some folks... I enjoy the show and just ignore the improbability of it all. It does raise some morality questions that are good for discussions however.