While reading a recent issue of BB magazine, I came across an article written by Mark Jacobs. He was talking about some of the knife fighting 'masters' and how many of them have never used a knife in combat. He goes on to say that there is alot of inaccurate information out there, when it comes to knife defense and what a knife can/can't do.
So, he consulted with a NY based martial artist, who's trained many years in several systems that specialize in bladed weaponry. He's also an experienced medical professional who has studied knife attacks
***At this point I'll say that no mention of this 'experts' name is mentioned, other than Mark calling him "The Expert" so I can't confirm or deny any of this mystery mans background. So, that being said, take what he said, with a grain of salt.***
I'll go ahead and post a few small tidbits to the 4 'myths' that the "expert" talks about.
Myth #1: Its easy to kill a person quickly and easily with a blade. The "Expert" states: Wrong. There are few places that you can put a knife that'll drop them instantly. Someone under drugs could keep fighting despite the wounds. Someone stabbed in the heart could still go on or 30secs.
Myth #2: The areas a MAist is taught to target with a knife will work with any knife. The 'expert' states: Not always. The size of the blade will come into play when determining what types of injuries happen. The defanging of the snake, thats often found in the FMAs tend to be done with a large blade or sword, so alot of what you see probably wont have the effect thats usually claimed.
Myth #3: A MAist could block a slash with the outside of the forearm because a cut to the inside of the arm could be deadly. Expet says: Technically thats true, but with a small blade, you're less likely to suffer a fatal wound on the inside of the arm. Even if you did, you'll have enough time to make it to the hospital before losing consciousness.
Myth #4: A sharp knife will cut through clothing as though its not even there. Expert says: Nope. A heavy winter coat offers a degree of protection that few realize. But that still doesnt mean that you should neglect being cautious just because you may be wearing heavy clothing.
I figured I'd put this here, instead of the FMA or knife sections, because I wanted to hear from everyone, rather than just a blade specific art. So, what are your thoughts? Do you feel that this "Expert" knows what he's talking about?
So, he consulted with a NY based martial artist, who's trained many years in several systems that specialize in bladed weaponry. He's also an experienced medical professional who has studied knife attacks
***At this point I'll say that no mention of this 'experts' name is mentioned, other than Mark calling him "The Expert" so I can't confirm or deny any of this mystery mans background. So, that being said, take what he said, with a grain of salt.***
I'll go ahead and post a few small tidbits to the 4 'myths' that the "expert" talks about.
Myth #1: Its easy to kill a person quickly and easily with a blade. The "Expert" states: Wrong. There are few places that you can put a knife that'll drop them instantly. Someone under drugs could keep fighting despite the wounds. Someone stabbed in the heart could still go on or 30secs.
Myth #2: The areas a MAist is taught to target with a knife will work with any knife. The 'expert' states: Not always. The size of the blade will come into play when determining what types of injuries happen. The defanging of the snake, thats often found in the FMAs tend to be done with a large blade or sword, so alot of what you see probably wont have the effect thats usually claimed.
Myth #3: A MAist could block a slash with the outside of the forearm because a cut to the inside of the arm could be deadly. Expet says: Technically thats true, but with a small blade, you're less likely to suffer a fatal wound on the inside of the arm. Even if you did, you'll have enough time to make it to the hospital before losing consciousness.
Myth #4: A sharp knife will cut through clothing as though its not even there. Expert says: Nope. A heavy winter coat offers a degree of protection that few realize. But that still doesnt mean that you should neglect being cautious just because you may be wearing heavy clothing.
I figured I'd put this here, instead of the FMA or knife sections, because I wanted to hear from everyone, rather than just a blade specific art. So, what are your thoughts? Do you feel that this "Expert" knows what he's talking about?