Question on Kumdo - Shanai

[Gemini]

What's the difference (or advantage) of the man made shanai over the traditional bamboo? I want to try one, but don't really want to spend $80 + for one if there's not much more to it? Anyone?

 

[MSUTKD]

The man made ones last longer....so they say. I use the bamboo, cheap and effective. I have never seen a Hachi dan (8th Dan) use a man made.

ron

 

[Gemini]

I've had bamboo that didn't last the first night, but most last for several months. The one I'm currently using, I've had for about 9 months. Pretty good for $20. I've never seen anybody use one. Just curious as to what the attraction would be. Do you know if they're legal in tournaments?

 

[MSUTKD]

They are legal. I have never seen an $80 one. Most of the carbon fiber ones are about $150-300. I used to break a lot of shinais, now only after several months.

ron

 

[Miles]

Is there any difference between a Kendo shinai and one for Kumdo?

TIA!

Miles

 

[Gemini]

Is there any difference between a Kendo shinai and one for Kumdo?

TIA!

Miles

Nope. Exactly the same.