I'm just curious. I think switchblades nearly everywhere in the US. But why? Especially as there are knives that can open just as fast with a flick of the wrist, or as you remove it from your pocket?
Switchblades - why are they illegal?
- Thread starter Carol
- Start date
lady_kaur said:
I believe the issue falls into technicality of how the laws are written. (* research your own local areas for what is and is not legal. *)
Those that have assist such as a spring, also usualy have a level that has to be moved such as a thumb stud.
Some areas have stated that gravity knives as well are not legal.
The technicality is that some motion is required to open them or assisted opening versus being an auto open from a button alone.
tsdclaflin
Green Belt
The government is trying to protect us from our selves...all the time.
Seat belt laws.
Motorcycle helmet laws.
Drivers licenses.
etc.
-Ken
Seat belt laws.
Motorcycle helmet laws.
Drivers licenses.
etc.
-Ken
tsdclaflin said:
This is true.
tsdclaflin said:
They actually do save lives as do air bags or Supplemental Restraint Systems, but peopel remember the 40's and 50's and 60's without safety glass and the one story of the window breaking and if they had not hit their head on the dash board then the window would have cut their neck.
tsdclaflin said:
Unfortunately I do not have the links handed, I will try to get them. I thnk from memory though that it does save lives less then 25 MPH and the person is ok. Above 25 MPH they are alive but more likely to be paralized or unable to function as well as before but they are alive.
tsdclaflin said:
Yeah those pesky licenses to have minimum standards that really do not mean you can drive, because come on just watch people in snow or on ice.
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2005
- Messages
- 10,826
- Reaction score
- 617
Simply put, a switchblade is no more dangerous than any other knife of at least equal blade length. If anything, I would feel better about facing someone who has such a blade, than one who has something like my Spyderco Police lockback knife.
It all goes back to what a governing body believes is "best" for the people. They'll make some laws forbidding a certain item, just because a couple of gangbangers were caught with that particular item in their possession. One can only imagine the thoughts that went through the minds of certain gov't officials when they saw movies such as "West Side Story," and saw the horrors inflicted by switchblades. This "panic" was probably further amplified when they would find an occasional gangbanger carrying one.
Legislation like this crops up all of the time, where an inanimate object is banned, but is really no more deadly than another one of similar type. Many folks remember the Assault Weapons Ban of 1994, where a weapon could be banned simply because it had certain cosmetic features. For example, taking an ordinary Ruger Mini-14 rancher's rifle made after 1994, and welding on a bayonet lug (
) would result in an unlawful weapon being created.
It all goes back to what a governing body believes is "best" for the people. They'll make some laws forbidding a certain item, just because a couple of gangbangers were caught with that particular item in their possession. One can only imagine the thoughts that went through the minds of certain gov't officials when they saw movies such as "West Side Story," and saw the horrors inflicted by switchblades. This "panic" was probably further amplified when they would find an occasional gangbanger carrying one.
Legislation like this crops up all of the time, where an inanimate object is banned, but is really no more deadly than another one of similar type. Many folks remember the Assault Weapons Ban of 1994, where a weapon could be banned simply because it had certain cosmetic features. For example, taking an ordinary Ruger Mini-14 rancher's rifle made after 1994, and welding on a bayonet lug (
KenpoTex
Senior Master
Exactly right. These types of laws are nothing more than a reaction on the part of government officials who really have no clue what they are talking about. The assault-weapons ban you mentioned was nothing but a joke. It did nothing to reduce violent crime, and when it was not renewed, crime DID NOT increase. In fact, a government study admitted that it had "no measurable effect" on crime.Grenadier said:It all goes back to what a governing body believes is "best" for the people. They'll make some laws forbidding a certain item, just because a couple of gangbangers were caught with that particular item in their possession. One can only imagine the thoughts that went through the minds of certain gov't officials when they saw movies such as "West Side Story," and saw the horrors inflicted by switchblades. This "panic" was probably further amplified when they would find an occasional gangbanger carrying one.
Legislation like this crops up all of the time, where an inanimate object is banned, but is really no more deadly than another one of similar type. Many folks remember the Assault Weapons Ban of 1994, where a weapon could be banned simply because it had certain cosmetic features. For example, taking an ordinary Ruger Mini-14 rancher's rifle made after 1994, and welding on a bayonet lug
The switchblade laws are really pointless because in the decades since those laws were passed, we've seen the creation of many designs that are just as fast but because of their designs, legal (assisted opening, the Emerson wave, etc.).
Same reasons apply to butterfly knives. Harder to handle without cutting your own knuckles off and I certainly would trust my locking folder over them for my own use (and yes, I have a few of each).
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2003
- Messages
- 9,998
- Reaction score
- 206
Well, I own two switchblades, and a CRKT folding knife with a thumb stud.
Amazingly, I can open the CRKT FASTER with one hand than I can the switchblades...
HOWEVER... like the recently repealed Assault Weapon ban...
Like Grenadier said Its not the Function of the weapon they are concerned with, but how intimidating it APPEARS.
Amazingly, I can open the CRKT FASTER with one hand than I can the switchblades...
HOWEVER... like the recently repealed Assault Weapon ban...
Like Grenadier said Its not the Function of the weapon they are concerned with, but how intimidating it APPEARS.
tsdclaflin
Green Belt
tsdclaflin said:
I'm not disagreeing with the above; I am just commenting that the government sometimes thinks that it is there responsibility to protect us.
There have been other good comments about gun control and other weapons control.
Btw, gun control is best defined as "using two hands."
-Ken
shesulsa said:
Actually I like my Balisong knife. The problem is that the size that fits nicely in my hands and I feel comfortable with is 7.5 inches closed and about 13 inches when open. Does not fit well into the average pocket. Looks normal in my hand but on the shelf or have you it looks bigger than necessary.
Technopunk said:
While I agree with you guys on the Appearance, they write the descriptions into the legislation, so many do not understand the under currents involved.
Well it's fun, to be sure ... but I have a few qvestions about those and I'll be happy to start another thread, Master Rich, if you could enlighten us anew on balisongs.Rich Parsons said:
shesulsa said:
I replied in your new thread, just a disclaimer, In no way to I consider myself to be an expert in knives. There are those that know how to make them. There are those that can use them, and those that can use them extremely well. I understand lots, by practice and understanding the attirbutes of the weapon, and thereby the strengths and limitations. Yet, I will leave the real knife videos to those that are in that market for they are the professionals of that field.
punisher73
Senior Master
- Joined
- Mar 20, 2004
- Messages
- 3,959
- Reaction score
- 1,058
The switchblade knives were passed when only "criminals" carried the knife. At the time you had knives that took a long time to open (had to use two hands) or it was a fixed blade for hunting. Some states passed laws regarding blade length as well and also have laws regarding other kinds of knives as well to try and limit it to "utility" carry only.
It's not illegal to own those knives, just to carry them around in public. And if there are better alternatives to carry then why take issue that they haven't changed an old law.
It's not illegal to own those knives, just to carry them around in public. And if there are better alternatives to carry then why take issue that they haven't changed an old law.
They are no longer illegal in Florida. The law was rewritten to clarify that ballistic knives were illegal (knives that actually shoot the blade out of the hilt/handle), but switchblades are not.
C
C
lady_kaur said:
KenpoTex
Senior Master
are they legal for everyone? my understanding was that they were only legal for those that have a concealed weapons permit.Cthulhu said:
bushidomartialarts
Senior Master
legal in oregon, but not legal to carry concealed in the portland area
Henderson
Master Black Belt
lady_kaur said:
To the best of my knowledge, Pennsylvania has no state-wide legislation that restricts knives according to method of opening (auto/manual/assisted) or blade length. Municipal ordinances will vary, of course.
KenpoTex
Senior Master
okay, thanks for clarifying.Cthulhu said:
