Flying Crane
Sr. Grandmaster
Solidman82 said:The weapons stuff I've seen is like this. Footwork is Capoeira, Weapons work is basic arnis (I say that because I only know basic arnis estrella)
well, maculele is done as a playful, energetic, rhythmic dance within a circle, where two players use either sticks, or machetes that they smack together, all done according to the drum beat that sets the pace of the dance. Players use unusual improvised and acrobatic moves within the dance that could be mistaken for capoeira.
It is not played with aggression, however. it is clearly a playful dance. The sticks or machetes are not used in attacks on each other, but rather are timed so that the players cooperatively strike each other's weapon on a particular drum beat.
Since it is done in a circle like capoeira, and has a similar element of music and playfulness, it is understandable that someone might mistake it for a part of capoeira.
Personally, I believe the dance developed from African stick and machete fighting techniques. The slaves who were brought to Brazil brought many aspects of their culture that got mixed into new things like capoeira and maculele. I believe this probably evolved as a way to practice some striking techniques with the weapons, but keep the intent of the practice hidden from the slave owners. In this way, it is very similar to capoeira. The fight is hidden as a game and a dance.
While maculele doesn't practice specific attacks against people, it could still act as a way to practice basic striking techniques. And of course, maculele from 300 years ago was probably very different from maculele done today...