Bujinkan Bashing

Obi Wan Shinobi

Green Belt
Joined
Jul 28, 2007
Messages
174
Reaction score
7
Location
Lakeland, FL USA






Hey guys I've come across these clips on youtube bashing the Bujinkan. Quite frankly I feel that this person does not understand the principles of the Bujinkan way of fighting. They are obviously biased and do not understand the difference between training for sport and training for self defense. I am a Deputy Sheriff in Florida and have also work as a State Corrections Officer and Detention Deputy and can say that Bujinkan has saved my rump more than once. I have also served in the USMC for 5 years as a grunt (0351, 0331) prior to the MCMAP and can say that no matter how effective an system the Marines use they still will train you slow at first until you become effective. Those Marines are more likely to be trainers themselves and therefore are training at a different level than what the line troops will be. Also theres the fear of Marines becoming injured and therefore causing a shortage of deployable troops. Also if I'm not mistaking Jack Hoban himself was a subject matter expert in creating the MCMAP. So this guy doesn't really have a clue to the MCMAP. Also this guy compares what seems to be MMA competition to an Bujinkan instructor teaching a waza slowly to his students. First of all most MMA fighters only fight maybe 3-4 fights per year where their opponents are of the same weight class and view prior fights to set up a strategy. Not to mention that in the cage there are no unknowns. There are no weapons, no eye gouges, no biting, no finger bends, no ear popping, the cage is clean and there is a referee to stop the fight if it one gets knocked out or is unable to defend himself. Not to mention that after five minutes you get a break. We fight to survive not to win....and we don't walk away with a belt and money just hopefully with our lives. As for the fight clips shown I've seen worse in the jails. The thing is we have to assume that our assailants will almost always be bigger, stronger and faster so then we train to use superior techniques and training. I'm only 5'7" 200lbs most people in the world are bigger than me. Those fighting clips only show that fighters that are pretty much wailing on each other until the stronger guy prevails. Basically survival of the fittest. Well thats the western philosophy towards fighting that you have to be bigger and faster in order to win. Which is why this guy doesn't understand what the Bujinkan offers to those who are vertically and physically challenged. I do believe and I'm guilty of it that alot of Bujinkan members physicaly fitness is lacking. I do work 12hr shifts and train in BBT twice a week and teach once a week. I am a single father of two so therefore life gets in the way. And I'm sure I'm not the only one but we do what we can when we can. These MMA guys and Marines are paid to stay in shape and have all the facilities and time to do so. The average Joe works, take cares of his/her family and trains whenever possible. I only say this since whoever this guy that posted these clips on youtube seems to have a vendetta against the Bujinkan. Even though not all Shodans are created equally within the Booj and some schools trains harder and faster than others doesn't qualify this person to discount and disrespect the Bujinkan in the manner he does.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Tez3

Sr. Grandmaster
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2006
Messages
27,608
Reaction score
4,901
Location
England
I would have been grateful if both they and you had left MMA out of it. As I repeated say on here (I'm sure someones counting the times!) MMA is a sport, we train differently for SD. MMA fighters are very capable of doing other things in a street fight, they are not sole defined by their sport. many are very good TMAs.
I understand where you are coming from and personally I would ignore stuff like these videos ( I only saw the second one, you have to register to see the first) but in a way you are doing to MMA what they are doing to you. MMA fighters are more than the sum of their parts! We like competing and there's no need to put us down for that! We can also defend ourselves outside the ring using different 'rules' if you like or no rules if you prefer to put it that way and we too can hopefully walk away with our lives.
Very few MMA fighters get paid to keep fit, they will be paid a purse to fight but they all have jobs, careers, families etc and train as and when they can. There is only a handful of fighters that make any money at all out of MMA let alone a living. Micheal Bisping was working in his job until very recently. I can't think of another MMA fighter in this country who is supported by MMA fighting. many will also travel to train not always having facilities on their doorsteps.
Yes you have your 'superstars' but literally a handful compared to the thousands of MMA fighters who do it for the love of martial arts just like many thousands of others pursuing their martial arts dreams.
 

Bigshadow

Senior Master
MTS Alumni
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Messages
4,033
Reaction score
45
Location
Saint Cloud, Florida
Just let it go... Obviously the person who produced the videos has an elementary school level of understanding about self defense and martial arts, more specifically Bujinkan Budo Taijutsu.

I don't give them much thought. I "KNOW" that BBT works and is all that matters to me.
 

Grey Eyed Bandit

Master of Arts
Joined
Mar 14, 2004
Messages
1,503
Reaction score
49
Location
MAP Hell
I am a Deputy Sheriff in Florida and have also work as a State Corrections Officer and Detention Deputy and can say that Bujinkan has saved my rump more than once.

Sounds to me like you did, not the Bujinkan.

Those fighting clips only show that fighters that are pretty much wailing on each other until the stronger guy prevails. Basically survival of the fittest. Well thats the western philosophy towards fighting that you have to be bigger and faster in order to win

Flat-out not true.
 

MJS

Administrator
Staff member
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2003
Messages
30,187
Reaction score
430
Location
Cromwell,CT
I don't train in the Bujinkan or any other X-Kan, but I have seen the videos in question and of course, I've seen my share of bashing of arts. I have to agree with Dave (Bigshadow) just let it go. I certainly know its hard to sit back and see someone bash something you like, but it happens with every art. I train in Kenpo and I've heard my share of comments.

The sad part is, is that way too many people bash their opinion of something off of a clip. IMHO, if someone has no idea about an art, how can you get an accurate description of what the art is all about? People who post clips like that, I'd bet, probably have never set foot in a good Bujinkan school. And if they have, they should not necessarily base their opinion off of just that school, seeing that there're thousands of schools. So unless someone sees how everyone in the world trains, you can't really judge anything with 100% accuracy.

As for whats better...IMO, there is no perfect art. If there was, that art would have all the students and everyone else would close up shop. Every art has their strong and weak spots, and I feel that we can all learn from one another. I'm a MMA fan and I have just about every UFC and still watch them. Is it the best art? No. But, I've picked up ideas and added them to my training. I cross train in grappling, which I never really did until the UFC craze came about. Do MMA people train for things outside the ring? I'm sure they do, although I don't know the percentage of who does/doesnt.

In the end, I really don't care what anyone thinks of my arts that I train in. I'm more than happy with my teachers and I wouldn't have been with them all this time if they weren't giving me what I'm looking to get from training. :) I know how I train, and I know what I can/can't do, and I work to improve in my weak areas all the time. :)

If someone would rather spend their time forming opinions from youtube, and bashing arts, rather than getting on the mats and training hard, more power to them. I know where I'm going to be and what I'm going to be doing, and its certainly not what they are. ;)

Mike
 
OP
O

Obi Wan Shinobi

Green Belt
Joined
Jul 28, 2007
Messages
174
Reaction score
7
Location
Lakeland, FL USA
Tez3 you are right I was a little hasty in the MMA comparison. The MMA guys do have abilities on and off the mat so I apologize for that one. Its just that I was in boxing for 5 years during my teen years and alot of what worked in the ring didn't in a streetfight so I did a hasty comparison. Again my apologies.

Grey Eyed Bandit while I appreciate your confidence in my ability I do have to say that the training I received in the Bujinkan did in fact helped in getting myself out of some hairy situations. The Florida Criminal Justice Standards and Training Commission which pretty much tells us what techniques are to taught during the Academy and annual recertifications. In all those techniques which are similar to the ones used in Aikido, Judo and in some instances the Bujinkan are suppose to be soft style moves that have been converted to hard style. Which now teaches a move that should have used body movement and momentum against the aggressor. Now teaches them the same move using only strength and power. I am not a big guy and therefore I cannot afford to meet someone bigger, stronger and faster than me with strength and technique alone. Its been my experience in both the military and law enforcement that emphasis on size, strength and speed is what makes someone an good fighter. Just my opinion. Anyways Big Shadow you make a good point, thank you sir.
 

Brian R. VanCise

MT Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 9, 2004
Messages
27,758
Reaction score
1,520
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada
I think that you have to take this kind of stuff with a grain of salt. Many, many people who train in Budo Taijutsu and have used it in real life confrontations. Also MMA is very,very effective in its own right. (I love mma as well) Bottom line is that big organizations attract people disagreeing with what they do and that is fine.

Find what works for you and what you can use in the moment. Pressure test it when you can so that you know it works as well. That is important!
icon6.gif
 

Grey Eyed Bandit

Master of Arts
Joined
Mar 14, 2004
Messages
1,503
Reaction score
49
Location
MAP Hell
while I appreciate your confidence in my ability I do have to say that the training I received in the Bujinkan did in fact helped in getting myself out of some hairy situations.

I don't buy these kinds of arguments anymore, partially because I've met many people with similar professions who consider taijutsu methodology to be utterly worthless. But that's me.

The Florida Criminal Justice Standards and Training Commission which pretty much tells us what techniques are to taught during the Academy and annual recertifications. In all those techniques which are similar to the ones used in Aikido, Judo and in some instances the Bujinkan are suppose to be soft style moves that have been converted to hard style. Which now teaches a move that should have used body movement and momentum against the aggressor. Now teaches them the same move using only strength and power.

I noticed pretty much the same thing during my certification courses, especially the one that taught the usage of handcuffs.
 

punisher73

Senior Master
Joined
Mar 20, 2004
Messages
3,948
Reaction score
1,041
It's hard when the art that you love is misrepresenting by someone with little or no knowledge of it. I have been on that end before.

On the other hand, look at the fight clips and then take the time to look within your martial art and ask "If I was in that situation what tools/techniques would I use?" and then TEST THEM so you can apply them to a violent encounter.

It is NOT going to look pretty like in the dojo, but it doesn't have to be perfect, it only has to be effective.
 

allenjp

Brown Belt
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
456
Reaction score
10
Location
San Diego, California
You know, I am not interested in bashing the Bunjinkan, as a matter of fact I plan to train in this art as soon as I can figure out a practical way of getting to the nearest dojo (it's currently too far to fit into my schedule). In fact I already went to a trial lesson, and the instructor extended me an invitation to train there. I love the efficiency of movement they teach, and the lack of wasted energy. I also know that in many of those clips they are intentionally going slow so that people can really see what is being done, and to prevent serious injury to the ukes. And despite what is said on the video clips, I know that the weapons training is very useful in real life (I believe the length of those swords they use is roughly the same as a baseball bat or pool stick).

That said, I must say that I have had some of the same questions about the emphasis on lunge punches. I'm not sure if that is the type of punch that most people are going to throw at me these days (besides of course the average drunk idiot trying to throw haymakers). I AM sure that no trained fighter is going to throw that kind of puch because they know extending your arm like that is a great way to expose yourself to punishment (quite possible I am wrong on that). Most punches thrown today are going to be short boxing type punches that retract quickly and make it difficult to get a hold of the arm or wrist in the ways that are demonstrated. Can those techniques be adopted to deal with shorter quicker type punches?

Also, are lunge punches useful as an offense technique in a real fight? When I went to my trial lesson, the instructor taught me to throw a lunge punch and aim for the throat. There are two potential advantages I can see from this type of punch: they have a much larger range than boxing type punches, and they can be deceptive, in that the opponent may think that you are too far away to punch him, and you can still reach him. But if someone knows what they are doing, are you not opening yourself up by throwing a punch like that, or am I off base? Stephen Hayes seems to have tried to adopt some of his techniques to deal with shorter punches, but there are no quest centers anywhere near me, and I don't know if I like the atmosphere I have seen in the clips of his dojos.

Can anyone who has trained in Bujinkan comment on these thoughts for me? This will not affect my decision to train in Bujinkan, that is already decided, the only question is when. I would just like ideas on these thoughts from someone who knows.

Thanks guys.
 

punisher73

Senior Master
Joined
Mar 20, 2004
Messages
3,948
Reaction score
1,041
You know, I am not interested in bashing the Bunjinkan, as a matter of fact I plan to train in this art as soon as I can figure out a practical way of getting to the nearest dojo (it's currently too far to fit into my schedule). In fact I already went to a trial lesson, and the instructor extended me an invitation to train there. I love the efficiency of movement they teach, and the lack of wasted energy. I also know that in many of those clips they are intentionally going slow so that people can really see what is being done, and to prevent serious injury to the ukes. And despite what is said on the video clips, I know that the weapons training is very useful in real life (I believe the length of those swords they use is roughly the same as a baseball bat or pool stick).

That said, I must say that I have had some of the same questions about the emphasis on lunge punches. I'm not sure if that is the type of punch that most people are going to throw at me these days (besides of course the average drunk idiot trying to throw haymakers). I AM sure that no trained fighter is going to throw that kind of puch because they know extending your arm like that is a great way to expose yourself to punishment (quite possible I am wrong on that). Most punches thrown today are going to be short boxing type punches that retract quickly and make it difficult to get a hold of the arm or wrist in the ways that are demonstrated. Can those techniques be adopted to deal with shorter quicker type punches?

Also, are lunge punches useful as an offense technique in a real fight? When I went to my trial lesson, the instructor taught me to throw a lunge punch and aim for the throat. There are two potential advantages I can see from this type of punch: they have a much larger range than boxing type punches, and they can be deceptive, in that the opponent may think that you are too far away to punch him, and you can still reach him. But if someone knows what they are doing, are you not opening yourself up by throwing a punch like that, or am I off base? Stephen Hayes seems to have tried to adopt some of his techniques to deal with shorter punches, but there are no quest centers anywhere near me, and I don't know if I like the atmosphere I have seen in the clips of his dojos.

Can anyone who has trained in Bujinkan comment on these thoughts for me? This will not affect my decision to train in Bujinkan, that is already decided, the only question is when. I would just like ideas on these thoughts from someone who knows.

Thanks guys.

Just an add on thought, I just recently went to some knife training and I was watching all of the students and ALL of the students that did not have prior training of some kind would have their left foot forward and the knife in their right hand (rear hand) and then step through and try to stab the other person, just like a typical lunge punch.
 

Bigshadow

Senior Master
MTS Alumni
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Messages
4,033
Reaction score
45
Location
Saint Cloud, Florida
ALL of the students that did not have prior training of some kind would have their left foot forward and the knife in their right hand (rear hand) and then step through and try to stab the other person


As opposed to stabbing first and the step following the hand?
 

Bigshadow

Senior Master
MTS Alumni
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Messages
4,033
Reaction score
45
Location
Saint Cloud, Florida
I think he means as opposed to holding the knife in the lead hand and jabbing with it?

Sorry, I was playing around the order of things. It really doesn't matter which hand or which foot is forward, the cut or stab comes FIRST and the step follows as part of ONE motion (if necessary).

He is right, many students step first then stab and some stab first and then step, but either way it is often done 2 disconnected movements.

However, the bashing is just noise... I ignore it. One cannot look at one particular school or just couple of people and make assumptions.
 

Grey Eyed Bandit

Master of Arts
Joined
Mar 14, 2004
Messages
1,503
Reaction score
49
Location
MAP Hell
Most punches thrown today are going to be short boxing type punches that retract quickly and make it difficult to get a hold of the arm or wrist in the ways that are demonstrated.

Most punches thrown by whom?

Can those techniques be adopted to deal with shorter quicker type punches?

Elbows move slower than hands.

Also, are lunge punches useful as an offense technique in a real fight?

About as useful as a shinai when compared to a katana.
 

allenjp

Brown Belt
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
456
Reaction score
10
Location
San Diego, California
I would say the majority of people who have any experience in fights would throw this type of punch, but I suppose I could be wrong.

I'm not sure I know what you're trying to say when you say elbows are slower than hands. Does that have something to do with the type of punch thrown?

I'm not sure what a shinai is (sorry) but I assume you're saying that lunge punches are not effective as an offense...then what would be the point of practising them so much?
 

Bigshadow

Senior Master
MTS Alumni
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Messages
4,033
Reaction score
45
Location
Saint Cloud, Florida
Regarding lunge punches, I am sure there are several threads on the topic in this forum that you may want to search for. They pretty much cover the basics of what is correct, not correct, over committed, sloppy kamae, etc. Feel free to search around.

It is a great question, but really, it is a subject for another thread as this one is about Bujinkan bashing.
 

Grey Eyed Bandit

Master of Arts
Joined
Mar 14, 2004
Messages
1,503
Reaction score
49
Location
MAP Hell
I would say the majority of people who have any experience in fights would throw this type of punch, but I suppose I could be wrong.

People who want to take your head off don't jab. People you're fighting do that.

I'm not sure I know what you're trying to say when you say elbows are slower than hands.

If elbows move slower than hands, which one is the easiest to control?

I'm not sure what a shinai is (sorry) but I assume you're saying that lunge punches are not effective as an offense...then what would be the point of practising them so much?

http://martialtalk.com/forum/showpost.php?p=736099&postcount=226
 

Latest Discussions

Top