Discussion in 'The Rec Room (Sports and Entertainment)' started by billc, Dec 2, 2012.
Anyone going to see this right away? Do you have any thoughts so far at what it might be like?
Would love to go but medical matters prevent it sad to say .
This will be the 1st film I see in a long time in theaters.
We'll be there--hopefully at midnight! I've read it twice and am looking forward to it, as is my family.
My daughter is a Benedict Cumberbatch fan and is hoping his role in part one is nontrivial, even though most of his work would be nearer the end of the actual book.
Sorry to hear that Sukerkin. Will you be able to see it before it leaves the theaters?
Surely it'll play for months?
We will certainly be seeing it, but NOT right away. I don't do crowds...
I was really looking forward to it until I just heard they chopped it up into 3 movies.
I think it's just two--they floated the idea of three but then went back to two.
If they tried to make it one movie, they'd have to cut out WAY too much....
Glad its multiple movies, if they tried to fit it in one, too much would be missing and i'd just be disappointed.
Going to see it with my ex during winter break...somehow my gf's ok with that
It has been confirmed that it is definitely going to be a trilogy but to help flesh it out a bit there are rumours that parts of the Silmarillion are also included.
I enjoyed the LoTR Trilogy and think Pete Jackson did a pretty good job. There are aspects that are outstanding and other parts that bother me more every time I watch the films.
So, I'm looking forward to watching these films, but I can wait a few days or weeks, I think, to avoid the initial rush.
3 films. gonna be a fun ride
You like to live dangerously don't you?
Well, lets just say my life is never dull
Maybe, but how well it covers the book depends on what's cut out more than how much is cut out. The trilogy was 3 books/3 movies and though they cut out notable scenes, they gave an excellent representation of the books overall imo. Sometimes, more is just more and I don't see why it should be necessary a book over 3 movies. If they apply that kind of logic to the Silmarillion I can't even imagine how many books that would be.
I am expecting the added scenes to from the ROTK appendices, particularly the actions of the White Council against the Necromancer, which would provide another big dramatic fight scene in the middle and it would explain why Gandalf left the group in the middle of the quest. I don't see how they could add in Silmarillion material to this movie series, unless is it is in flashback form like how Fellowship opened.
I kind of wish they would have just done the Hobbit, in two parts. The added material might distract from the main story. If it is three books then we won't see you know who for another 2 years. I really wonder how they will handle him.
You know who?
I don't know, Orlando Bloom prancing around Mirkwood?123
Separate names with a comma.