Second Dan

Headhunter

Senior Master
Joined
Aug 26, 2016
Messages
4,765
Reaction score
1,598
so tonight I tested for and passed my second Dan in kenpo.

I've had a rough go of things with kenpo but since November I've been working with a 5th Dan who's very much open minded towards other styles and accepts that kenpo needs to adapt to stay relevant. He's constantly asked for opinions and asked what other systems do. Anyway I've been doing sessions with him and his black belts plus assisting a few classes here and there and last week he basically said to me "I reckon you should be a second Dan I'm going to promote you" but I refused it. I said I don't want a rank given to me. I said if he wants me to advance then I have to test for it I said I'd refuse to accept it without testing not as a sign of disrespect but simply i want to work for what I get not just get given it. So he agreed I could jump in on a black belt test for a couple his students tonight. So I did it and it was a 4 hour test went through pretty much everything answered questions and a small bit of sparring and the panel which had a 8th and a 10th Dan agreed I was good enough to pass. They gave me good advice on what to work on which I'll do.

It's nice to have but more than anything I just enjoyed blasting myself in the test more than the stripe on my belt but hey new ranks always nice can't lie
 

Monkey Turned Wolf

MT Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jan 4, 2012
Messages
12,212
Reaction score
6,308
Location
New York
I don't know why, but in my head I thought you quit kenpo a tiny bit ago. Anyway, congratulations! From the tests I've been in or seen, not easy to just up and join a four hour test with a nights notice.
 

DocWard

Purple Belt
Joined
Aug 13, 2008
Messages
305
Reaction score
179
Location
Ohio
Congratulations! I'm impressed and a bit inspired by your attitude.
 

_Simon_

Senior Master
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
4,398
Reaction score
2,906
Location
Australia
Maaaaaaate..... massive congrats, that's awesome. And sounds like you've found the place/instructor for you :)
 

dvcochran

Grandmaster
Joined
Nov 7, 2017
Messages
7,047
Reaction score
2,297
Location
Southeast U.S.
so tonight I tested for and passed my second Dan in kenpo.

I've had a rough go of things with kenpo but since November I've been working with a 5th Dan who's very much open minded towards other styles and accepts that kenpo needs to adapt to stay relevant. He's constantly asked for opinions and asked what other systems do. Anyway I've been doing sessions with him and his black belts plus assisting a few classes here and there and last week he basically said to me "I reckon you should be a second Dan I'm going to promote you" but I refused it. I said I don't want a rank given to me. I said if he wants me to advance then I have to test for it I said I'd refuse to accept it without testing not as a sign of disrespect but simply i want to work for what I get not just get given it. So he agreed I could jump in on a black belt test for a couple his students tonight. So I did it and it was a 4 hour test went through pretty much everything answered questions and a small bit of sparring and the panel which had a 8th and a 10th Dan agreed I was good enough to pass. They gave me good advice on what to work on which I'll do.

It's nice to have but more than anything I just enjoyed blasting myself in the test more than the stripe on my belt but hey new ranks always nice can't lie
That is how it is done. The test is for you. How you will look back on it means everything. Great to hear stories like this. Congratulations.
 
OP
H

Headhunter

Senior Master
Joined
Aug 26, 2016
Messages
4,765
Reaction score
1,598
That is how it is done. The test is for you. How you will look back on it means everything. Great to hear stories like this. Congratulations.
Yeah to me I don't see the point of being presented rank. It's like going to school and expecting to be given your exams just because you're there. If I don't earn it then all it is is a cheap piece of tape on my belt. I may not get any higher rank but if I do it will be because I test for it. I don't know anyone in kenpo who has tested for any higher than a 4th dan. After that it's all presented. If I do ever get that high then I will still either want to test or stay where I am. My ego is secure enough that I don't need to be given belts to prove myself. I personally believe the higher Dan ranks in kenpo at least are more of an ego thing than a skill thing. Just my opinion. If I get a rank I'm either doing a test on the mat for it and I'm not having it and I will happily refuse to accept a rank if it's presented to me because I in myself wouldn't feel like I've properly earned it. How can I expect students to push themselves hard in gradings when me as a instructor and high rank is just getting given my ranks. I wouldn't be able to look at students in the eye and tell them to work hard. I'd feel like a fake. Right or wrong that's just how I've always been
 

Gerry Seymour

MT Moderator
Staff member
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
29,976
Reaction score
10,535
Location
Hendersonville, NC
Yeah to me I don't see the point of being presented rank. It's like going to school and expecting to be given your exams just because you're there. If I don't earn it then all it is is a cheap piece of tape on my belt. I may not get any higher rank but if I do it will be because I test for it. I don't know anyone in kenpo who has tested for any higher than a 4th dan. After that it's all presented. If I do ever get that high then I will still either want to test or stay where I am. My ego is secure enough that I don't need to be given belts to prove myself. I personally believe the higher Dan ranks in kenpo at least are more of an ego thing than a skill thing. Just my opinion. If I get a rank I'm either doing a test on the mat for it and I'm not having it and I will happily refuse to accept a rank if it's presented to me because I in myself wouldn't feel like I've properly earned it. How can I expect students to push themselves hard in gradings when me as a instructor and high rank is just getting given my ranks. I wouldn't be able to look at students in the eye and tell them to work hard. I'd feel like a fake. Right or wrong that's just how I've always been
In some cases, I think it may be a matter of a rank that was earned without testing. If someone's ability (and other traits) clearly exceed the standards for a given rank, then it's not an unearned rank. I think a lot of us prefer the satisfaction of passing the actual test, but (with some exceptions) the test is mostly about verifying the person meets those standards. There are some other things we can do with a test, but that's usually the primary purpose.

EDIT: Once again, clicked before I was done. For those ranks that have no standard testing/physical requirements, those are more about organizational development. Within the NGAA, for instance, 3rd dan is for folks who've developed a body of trained instructors, and 4th is usually for folks whose students have founded several schools - or (in both cases) something equivalent. I don't personally see much need for those.
 

JR 137

Grandmaster
Joined
Apr 26, 2015
Messages
5,162
Reaction score
3,224
Location
In the dojo
Yeah to me I don't see the point of being presented rank. It's like going to school and expecting to be given your exams just because you're there. If I don't earn it then all it is is a cheap piece of tape on my belt. I may not get any higher rank but if I do it will be because I test for it. I don't know anyone in kenpo who has tested for any higher than a 4th dan. After that it's all presented. If I do ever get that high then I will still either want to test or stay where I am. My ego is secure enough that I don't need to be given belts to prove myself. I personally believe the higher Dan ranks in kenpo at least are more of an ego thing than a skill thing. Just my opinion. If I get a rank I'm either doing a test on the mat for it and I'm not having it and I will happily refuse to accept a rank if it's presented to me because I in myself wouldn't feel like I've properly earned it. How can I expect students to push themselves hard in gradings when me as a instructor and high rank is just getting given my ranks. I wouldn't be able to look at students in the eye and tell them to work hard. I'd feel like a fake. Right or wrong that's just how I've always been
@gpseymour brings up some good points. To further it, where does the curriculum/syllabus end in Kenpo? If there’s no new material after 4th dan, what could you test someone on? So let’s say you’ve finished the syllabus at 4th dan, every rank above that would be an honorific type thing based on your contribution to the art - teaching, number of students who’ve earned a higher rank, number of students who went on to teach and have their own high ranking students; stuff like that.

Let’s say I’m a 4th dan and 10 of my students opened their own dojos, and a few of those guys taught students who opened their own dojos too. In a weird way I’m like a grandfather to those dojos. I don’t see any issues with promoting me based on that, so long as the quality of my students and their students was solid. If there’s no curriculum left for me, there’s not much you can test me on anymore. And by that time I’ve hopefully already proven my own skills in tests several times anyway. Sure people can be jackasses and promote everyone and their brother just to advance in rank themselves, but there’s always ways to cheat no matter how much you try to make it foolproof. Not everyone’s out to cheat the system.
 

dvcochran

Grandmaster
Joined
Nov 7, 2017
Messages
7,047
Reaction score
2,297
Location
Southeast U.S.
@gpseymour brings up some good points. To further it, where does the curriculum/syllabus end in Kenpo? If there’s no new material after 4th dan, what could you test someone on? So let’s say you’ve finished the syllabus at 4th dan, every rank above that would be an honorific type thing based on your contribution to the art - teaching, number of students who’ve earned a higher rank, number of students who went on to teach and have their own high ranking students; stuff like that.

Let’s say I’m a 4th dan and 10 of my students opened their own dojos, and a few of those guys taught students who opened their own dojos too. In a weird way I’m like a grandfather to those dojos. I don’t see any issues with promoting me based on that, so long as the quality of my students and their students was solid. If there’s no curriculum left for me, there’s not much you can test me on anymore. And by that time I’ve hopefully already proven my own skills in tests several times anyway. Sure people can be jackasses and promote everyone and their brother just to advance in rank themselves, but there’s always ways to cheat no matter how much you try to make it foolproof. Not everyone’s out to cheat the system.
I am making a guess that @Headhunter is younger than most of us. I like hearing his/her moxy in the description of lower Dan promotions. They should be rough in most cases. But, as you said, there is a bigger picture that will hopefully develop for headhunter. Somewhere in the journey for most folks it becomes more than just about their own personal development. It has everything to do with how/what they are taught. Some people never get past solely personal growth, I see it all the time in people who show up for class just to workout and never engage in anything else going on in the dojo/dojang. Most TMA schools expect a student to help clean the school sometimes for example.
 

Gerry Seymour

MT Moderator
Staff member
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
29,976
Reaction score
10,535
Location
Hendersonville, NC
@gpseymour brings up some good points. To further it, where does the curriculum/syllabus end in Kenpo? If there’s no new material after 4th dan, what could you test someone on? So let’s say you’ve finished the syllabus at 4th dan, every rank above that would be an honorific type thing based on your contribution to the art - teaching, number of students who’ve earned a higher rank, number of students who went on to teach and have their own high ranking students; stuff like that.

Let’s say I’m a 4th dan and 10 of my students opened their own dojos, and a few of those guys taught students who opened their own dojos too. In a weird way I’m like a grandfather to those dojos. I don’t see any issues with promoting me based on that, so long as the quality of my students and their students was solid. If there’s no curriculum left for me, there’s not much you can test me on anymore. And by that time I’ve hopefully already proven my own skills in tests several times anyway. Sure people can be jackasses and promote everyone and their brother just to advance in rank themselves, but there’s always ways to cheat no matter how much you try to make it foolproof. Not everyone’s out to cheat the system.
I also assume some of that approach was designed around the idea of life-long involvement. You can't keep expecting a higher level of physical skill as people age. We can get technically more competent for a time after our bodies start to succumb to time, but that's limited. So how does an aging practitioner keep moving forward? By contributing to the art and association.
 

Tony Dismukes

MT Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Nov 11, 2005
Messages
7,577
Reaction score
7,611
Location
Lexington, KY
Yeah to me I don't see the point of being presented rank. It's like going to school and expecting to be given your exams just because you're there. If I don't earn it then all it is is a cheap piece of tape on my belt. I may not get any higher rank but if I do it will be because I test for it.
Probably the majority of BJJ schools award ranks without a formal test. I feel pretty safe saying those ranks aren’t unearned. If I promote someone it’s because I see them prove what they can do day in and day out on the mats.

I have nothing against schools that hold formal test procedures on a given day. I’ve been through some of that in different arts and I can see how some people might appreciate that as a rite of passage. For myself as a teacher and a student, I prefer the approach where every day on the mat is a test.
 

Gerry Seymour

MT Moderator
Staff member
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
29,976
Reaction score
10,535
Location
Hendersonville, NC
For myself as a teacher and a student, I prefer the approach where every day on the mat is a test.
I feel more that way as time goes by. If I were convinced nobody I train will ever have their own students (and need some help figuring out how to rank people when they start) I'd probably do all ranking without formal tests. The tests are comfortable to me - it's what I've always done in any training that had ranks - but as an instructor I get to a point where I just want to say, "Listen, I know what you can do, and you know what you can do. This belt color matches that ability and knowledge."

Someday I might end up going that way. That might be the same day I decide to do away with colored belt ranks.
 

Flying Crane

Sr. Grandmaster
Joined
Sep 21, 2005
Messages
15,230
Reaction score
4,920
Location
San Francisco
I am making a guess that @Headhunter is younger than most of us. I like hearing his/her moxy in the description of lower Dan promotions. They should be rough in most cases. But, as you said, there is a bigger picture that will hopefully develop for headhunter. Somewhere in the journey for most folks it becomes more than just about their own personal development. It has everything to do with how/what they are taught. Some people never get past solely personal growth, I see it all the time in people who show up for class just to workout and never engage in anything else going on in the dojo/dojang. Most TMA schools expect a student to help clean the school sometimes for example.
I believe that @Headhunter is actually an older gentleman.
 

Finlay

Green Belt
Joined
Jan 7, 2016
Messages
161
Reaction score
44
Location
Kuala Lumpur
Well done man

There are many who would have been tempted and who maybe thought they deserved the promotion without testing.
 

dvcochran

Grandmaster
Joined
Nov 7, 2017
Messages
7,047
Reaction score
2,297
Location
Southeast U.S.
Honestly have no idea why people would assume I'm younger just because I want to push myself and not get given anything. I've been that way since I first started and I'll be the same until the day I die
I was not implying anything negative. I commend the attitude as I said earlier. I get it. People are all driven differently and sometimes it is hard to see. I love hearing a person have
Honestly have no idea why people would assume I'm younger just because I want to push myself and not get given anything. I've been that way since I first started and I'll be the same until the day I die
I meant it as a compliment. I love hearing your passion and abandon. My old fart horn may have been going off too loudly. I competed at a very high level in my early MA career and that element of what I do has mellowed. But yes, I feel that same drive which is what I think you are referring to. Push the envelope as long as you can. MA needs this.
 
OP
H

Headhunter

Senior Master
Joined
Aug 26, 2016
Messages
4,765
Reaction score
1,598
I was not implying anything negative. I commend the attitude as I said earlier. I get it. People are all driven differently and sometimes it is hard to see. I love hearing a person have

I meant it as a compliment. I love hearing your passion and abandon. My old fart horn may have been going off too loudly. I competed at a very high level in my early MA career and that element of what I do has mellowed. But yes, I feel that same drive which is what I think you are referring to. Push the envelope as long as you can. MA needs this.
Nah it's fine I didn't take it as an insult just curious why others thought that
 

Latest Discussions

Top