Kwan Jang
Purple Belt
Agreed. I should note though that there are likely far more people out there who believe that the block and strike interpretation of traditional forms and Olympic style are effective means of self defense. I would never advocate using XMA or defending with my hands down (or at my hip) for self defense. My point is just that many other posters who have been critical of XMA are living in glass houses as they warm up their pitching arms to throw those stones.
P.S. - I do feel that using the Kyusho/tuite (using the Okinawan terms) applications of forms can be a valuable resource in training IF you apply it well in your live training and don't just run the patterns. Also, WTF TKD rules, while limited, can be of value as a specific drill in your training and I did compete in that sport on the state, national and even international level many years ago (for any who are offended at my statements about TKD on this forum).
P.S. - I do feel that using the Kyusho/tuite (using the Okinawan terms) applications of forms can be a valuable resource in training IF you apply it well in your live training and don't just run the patterns. Also, WTF TKD rules, while limited, can be of value as a specific drill in your training and I did compete in that sport on the state, national and even international level many years ago (for any who are offended at my statements about TKD on this forum).