what's new in brazilian?

[mantis]

im sure a bunch of people asked this before
but maybe you can point me in the right direction
what did the brazilian family add to japanese jujutsu?
ie what's the difference between the japanese one and the brazilian one?
also, how high are kicks in JJ? or BJJ?
does it really take like 9 years to get to the black belt?
what are the belts, and how many?
thanks

 

[Andrew Green]

What they added was more of a change of focus from Judo, which did throws, to submission.

Kicks, well, depends on what you are doing, in sport BJJ there are no kicks, many clubs don't really train them.

Belts are white, blue, purple, brown, black

Yes, it can take 9 (or even more) years to get a black in it.

 

[Jonathan Randall]

im sure a bunch of people asked this before
but maybe you can point me in the right direction
what did the brazilian family add to japanese jujutsu?
ie what's the difference between the japanese one and the brazilian one?
also, how high are kicks in JJ? or BJJ?
does it really take like 9 years to get to the black belt?
what are the belts, and how many?
thanks

BJJ has more similiarities to pre-war (WW2) Judo than it does to Japanese Jujutsu. From my lay perspective, BJJ is simply a more competitive (more techniques allowed) form of Judo that has retained more of the "martial" than many Japanese arts, post WW2, have.

My Judo school offered a Danzan ryu Jujitsu (this is 20 years ago) and I studied jujitsu up to blue belt. I have a BJJ text that covers techniques through blue belt and, with the exception of breakfalls, the material is entirely different. We did little to no groundwork in JJJ in the first belt. Other's experiences may be different; these are just mine.

 

[arnisador]

Yes, BJJ is more like earlier versions of Judo. The big change was in emphasis.

Yes, 10 years to black belt is common in BJJ.

 

[Marvin]

Another big difference is the use of forms in BJJ there are no katas. I believe most all JJJ have katas of some sort. Also randori or free sparing is emphasized a great deal in BJJ.

 

[Shogun]

It would be pretty difficult to type out the answers here, but I have experience in both, so I'll do what I can. (note: this is based on MY experience, and what I have discovered)

Q: what did the Gracies add to Japanese JJ?
A: Carlos Gracie was taught Japanese Judo and Jujutsu by Maeda, a judo champion with an unorthodox ground fighting style. Carlos' little brother Helio was very small and weak, and found much of the techniques did not work for him. he used the Japanese JJ methods of leverage, and his own theories that would work for a smaller man. His style would evolve into a ground fighting style using leverage and technique over strength.

Q: Kicks in JJ? BJJ?
A: Kicks (in pure BJJ) are not really focused on. they are used in self-defense/standing techniques to set up other techniques, and in ground sweeps. in Japanese Jujutsu (depending on the style) they are used but not to a large extent. thrusting kicks that bring a person into a certain range is common.

Q: Does it take 9 years to get a black belt?
A: most definitely. There is approximately 88 basic techniques for each belt level. GM Helio Gracie says that he could teach someone all the basics in 40 lessons, bu it takes 10 years to "know" the person's character. BJJ has a feeling that can only be learned by time.

Q: Belts?
A: white, Blue, purple, brown, black. White is the phase where one learns the concepts of leverage, and positioning. Blue to purple is considered the hardest phase. as for time, 1-3 years for blue. 2-4 for purple. 2-4 for brown, and 1-4 for black. depending on your skill, and who your teacher is.


The thing to recognize, is the difference between the various schools and styles. each has there own strengths and weaknesses. for example:

Gracie Jiu jitsu - This is the school that trains directly under GM helio Gracie. Rickson gracie, Royce, and Pedro Sauer to name a few. this style focuses on leverage, and application of self defense techniques.

Brazilian Jiu Jitsu - a common name given to the art, BJJ refers mostly to the sport, as used for mma and competitions. some practitioners of this style combine wrestling or other styles, along with strength with Jiujitsu. Joe Morreira, Rigan Machado, and Carlson Gracie are notables.

Luta Livre - basically, this is Jiu jitsu without a gi. Hugo duarte is a notable practitioner of this style.

Bravo Jiu Jitsu - an unorthodox style in, like Luta livre, uses no-gi techniques exclusively. the style is based on under and overhooks. Eddie Bravo invented it, but stylists such as gerald strebendt, Jean jeaques machado, BJ penn, and others.

there are a few styles out there. its best to try a few different linages and find out what suits you best.

 

[arnisador]

It's worth mentioning that those who compete usually advance more rapidly. As a rule of thumb, once will be promoted to the next belt when one starts beating those at the next level on a more than just occasional basis.

 

[mantis]

It would be pretty difficult to type out the answers here, but I have experience in both, so I'll do what I can. (note: this is based on MY experience, and what I have discovered)

Q: what did the Gracies add to Japanese JJ?
A: Carlos Gracie was taught Japanese Judo and Jujutsu by Maeda, a judo champion with an unorthodox ground fighting style. Carlos' little brother Helio was very small and weak, and found much of the techniques did not work for him. he used the Japanese JJ methods of leverage, and his own theories that would work for a smaller man. His style would evolve into a ground fighting style using leverage and technique over strength.

Q: Kicks in JJ? BJJ?
A: Kicks (in pure BJJ) are not really focused on. they are used in self-defense/standing techniques to set up other techniques, and in ground sweeps. in Japanese Jujutsu (depending on the style) they are used but not to a large extent. thrusting kicks that bring a person into a certain range is common.

Q: Does it take 9 years to get a black belt?
A: most definitely. There is approximately 88 basic techniques for each belt level. GM Helio Gracie says that he could teach someone all the basics in 40 lessons, bu it takes 10 years to "know" the person's character. BJJ has a feeling that can only be learned by time.

Q: Belts?
A: white, Blue, purple, brown, black. White is the phase where one learns the concepts of leverage, and positioning. Blue to purple is considered the hardest phase. as for time, 1-3 years for blue. 2-4 for purple. 2-4 for brown, and 1-4 for black. depending on your skill, and who your teacher is.


The thing to recognize, is the difference between the various schools and styles. each has there own strengths and weaknesses. for example:

Gracie Jiu jitsu - This is the school that trains directly under GM helio Gracie. Rickson gracie, Royce, and Pedro Sauer to name a few. this style focuses on leverage, and application of self defense techniques.

Brazilian Jiu Jitsu - a common name given to the art, BJJ refers mostly to the sport, as used for mma and competitions. some practitioners of this style combine wrestling or other styles, along with strength with Jiujitsu. Joe Morreira, Rigan Machado, and Carlson Gracie are notables.

Luta Livre - basically, this is Jiu jitsu without a gi. Hugo duarte is a notable practitioner of this style.

Bravo Jiu Jitsu - an unorthodox style in, like Luta livre, uses no-gi techniques exclusively. the style is based on under and overhooks. Eddie Bravo invented it, but stylists such as gerald strebendt, Jean jeaques machado, BJ penn, and others.

there are a few styles out there. its best to try a few different linages and find out what suits you best.

thanks for spending the time to put this together...
your words are as clear as crystals
thanks