what are the main differences between these two styles? what are their similarities?
TSD and TKD
- Thread starter Nightingale
- Start date
(WARNING: THE FOLLOWING IS A GENERAL DISCRIPTION PLEASE BE ADVISED AND DO NOT TAKE OFFENSE!!! THANK YOU)
Tang Soo Do is the art from which Tae Kwon Do came from. Tae Kwon Do sas most of thier emphisis on Kicking and is usualy more sports oreinted. TKD is also the largest martial art in the world (Tai Chi can actualy be argued for largest, but is is at least the largest Karate practiced in the world).
Tang Soo Do is about 50/50 hands/feet, as well as joint locks, grabs, thows, self defence, trapping, ect. Tang Soo Do is more philisophical and ART oreinted.
I know I might get posts shotting me down for saying some of this stuff. I am aware that not all TKD is only sport oreinted, as well I know there is some Tang Soo Do that is not really Tang Soo Do. But understand, I am only talking generaly here....
If you also just look at the names you can also see the differnce:
Tae Kwon Do : Way of the Hands and Feet (implies only phisical traing)
Tang Soo Do : Way of the Virtues (China/Empty) Hand (implies phisical and mental training)
The simularities : They are Both Korean. They both have punches, blocks and kicks.
So does Shotokan. So does Kung Fu. ect ect ect.......
Forms are different and use of hip is emphisied more in Tang Soo Do.
Again, I am speaking generaly here.
(just so everyone knows, generaly is the key word)
:asian:
TANG SOO!!!
M.Tabone
Tang Soo Do is the art from which Tae Kwon Do came from. Tae Kwon Do sas most of thier emphisis on Kicking and is usualy more sports oreinted. TKD is also the largest martial art in the world (Tai Chi can actualy be argued for largest, but is is at least the largest Karate practiced in the world).
Tang Soo Do is about 50/50 hands/feet, as well as joint locks, grabs, thows, self defence, trapping, ect. Tang Soo Do is more philisophical and ART oreinted.
I know I might get posts shotting me down for saying some of this stuff. I am aware that not all TKD is only sport oreinted, as well I know there is some Tang Soo Do that is not really Tang Soo Do. But understand, I am only talking generaly here....
If you also just look at the names you can also see the differnce:
Tae Kwon Do : Way of the Hands and Feet (implies only phisical traing)
Tang Soo Do : Way of the Virtues (China/Empty) Hand (implies phisical and mental training)
The simularities : They are Both Korean. They both have punches, blocks and kicks.
So does Shotokan. So does Kung Fu. ect ect ect.......
Forms are different and use of hip is emphisied more in Tang Soo Do.
Again, I am speaking generaly here.
(just so everyone knows, generaly is the key word)
:asian:
TANG SOO!!!
M.Tabone
M
MountainSage
Guest
I agree the TSD and TKD came from the same base arts, I believe they were just different kwan prior to the combining that created TKD and the TSD folks chose not to play that game. TKD is Karate influenced art, probably coming from the Shotokan system and TSD is Chinese influenced which is more than likely closer to the orgininal Korean MAs. As a TKD person I would have to say,IMHO, that TSD is more like a traditional Korean MA than TKD.
Mountainsage
Mountainsage
OP
- Thread Starter
- #4
what does kwan mean?
S
Shinzu
Guest
i believe it is translated as school or group.
eg: moo duk kwan = school of martial virture.
eg: moo duk kwan = school of martial virture.
The Hyungs we do are Japanes in origin. We have the Pyung Ahns (Pinans/Hinans), Ni Han Ji (NahBoJin) (I dont know the Shotokan name) ect ect ect...
We also have the Chil Sung forms.
I do agree that Tang Soo Do has definent Chinies influences, one can see that be the observation of soft and hard execution of tech. Though, we have alot of Japanes (Shotokan) influences as well.
I once heard someone joke around after hering that JKD is an "Artless Art." So he said, "TSD is stylized JKD." That always makes me smile.
TANG SOO!!!
M.Tabone
We also have the Chil Sung forms.
I do agree that Tang Soo Do has definent Chinies influences, one can see that be the observation of soft and hard execution of tech. Though, we have alot of Japanes (Shotokan) influences as well.
I once heard someone joke around after hering that JKD is an "Artless Art." So he said, "TSD is stylized JKD." That always makes me smile.
TANG SOO!!!
M.Tabone
T
Teacher
Guest
Just a little clarification for the readers. The classical hyung do predominantly follow the styling used by the Japanese (which they refer to as Kata). However, the majority of them are evolutions out of a crystalized form developed on Okinawa before Okinawa was officially a part of Japan proper. Of these, again most of them were based upon art forms from Souther China. Now...this is not an absolute...as some of the Hyung have migrated to Korea not through Okinawa/Japan but from China directly as well as from places like Taiwan, Hong Kong and Thailand. The Sang Keuk Kwan form apparently is derived from Preying Mantis Kung Fu as practiced in Thailand which in turn resulted from migrations out of China to avoid the Communist as they took over China.
Please remember the correct translation for Tang Soo Do is "China Hand Way". There is no mention of virture or knife hand or any of that stuff in the name 'Tang Soo Do'. The words Moo Duk Kwan mean 'Martial Virtue School'. In this instance, the use of the word 'Kwan' is most appropriately translated as School. It may also be translated as 'gymnasium' or 'institute'...but both of these would still be referencing it as a place to learn...i.e. a school.
Literally, the word 'Dojang' means 'Way Place'...or for you that need a more western translation 'Place of the Way'. In this instance the words refer to 'Way' as a 'practice', 'methodology' or metaphysically, as a 'discipline'. Oftne the words are translated as 'school', but a dojang is a lot more than just a school. The 'practice' overtime time takes on meaning that equals that of religious worship. While you are not worshiping the art or a member or a school, you do develop an emotional centering during the practice that can easily be equated to the feelings one has during true meaningful worship. Therefore, a dojang...as a way place...takes on very personal meaning. A dojang can be anywhere...not necessarily a building. A favourite spot in a park, or yard, street or hillside can be a dojang.
Commonly, when you see the word 'Kwan' we are referring to a building, whereas when you see it as 'kwon', we are referring to a 'fist'. Kwon then should be translated as 'fist'....a closed hand. 'Soo' means hand...and usually is referring to an open hand. This is why we refer to a knife hand as a 'Soo Do' because these two words mean...'Hand and Knife' respectively.
With regard to Tae Kwon Do, Tang Soo Do and Kong Soo Do. These translations are the most commonly accepted and accurate:
Tang Soo Do = China Hand Way
Tae Kwon Do = Foot Fist Way
Kong Soo Do = Empty Hand Way.
Please be especially careful not to mistake Tang Soo Do with Karate-do as the words are used in Japan. In Japan, they changed the original character of the first word from Kara meaning China to 'Ku' which means 'empty'. However, they continued to refer orally to the art as Kara Te Do. Overtime, Kara then also came to be defined as meaning either 'China' or 'empty' in Japan. However...that is the only place that the character for Kara has this meaning. In Korea...the character for 'Kara' is pronounced 'Tang'. The character for 'Ku' is pronounced 'Kong'.
Just a few little tid bits that often get confused.
JH
Please remember the correct translation for Tang Soo Do is "China Hand Way". There is no mention of virture or knife hand or any of that stuff in the name 'Tang Soo Do'. The words Moo Duk Kwan mean 'Martial Virtue School'. In this instance, the use of the word 'Kwan' is most appropriately translated as School. It may also be translated as 'gymnasium' or 'institute'...but both of these would still be referencing it as a place to learn...i.e. a school.
Literally, the word 'Dojang' means 'Way Place'...or for you that need a more western translation 'Place of the Way'. In this instance the words refer to 'Way' as a 'practice', 'methodology' or metaphysically, as a 'discipline'. Oftne the words are translated as 'school', but a dojang is a lot more than just a school. The 'practice' overtime time takes on meaning that equals that of religious worship. While you are not worshiping the art or a member or a school, you do develop an emotional centering during the practice that can easily be equated to the feelings one has during true meaningful worship. Therefore, a dojang...as a way place...takes on very personal meaning. A dojang can be anywhere...not necessarily a building. A favourite spot in a park, or yard, street or hillside can be a dojang.
Commonly, when you see the word 'Kwan' we are referring to a building, whereas when you see it as 'kwon', we are referring to a 'fist'. Kwon then should be translated as 'fist'....a closed hand. 'Soo' means hand...and usually is referring to an open hand. This is why we refer to a knife hand as a 'Soo Do' because these two words mean...'Hand and Knife' respectively.
With regard to Tae Kwon Do, Tang Soo Do and Kong Soo Do. These translations are the most commonly accepted and accurate:
Tang Soo Do = China Hand Way
Tae Kwon Do = Foot Fist Way
Kong Soo Do = Empty Hand Way.
Please be especially careful not to mistake Tang Soo Do with Karate-do as the words are used in Japan. In Japan, they changed the original character of the first word from Kara meaning China to 'Ku' which means 'empty'. However, they continued to refer orally to the art as Kara Te Do. Overtime, Kara then also came to be defined as meaning either 'China' or 'empty' in Japan. However...that is the only place that the character for Kara has this meaning. In Korea...the character for 'Kara' is pronounced 'Tang'. The character for 'Ku' is pronounced 'Kong'.
Just a few little tid bits that often get confused.
JH
cali_tkdbruin
Master of Arts
Good descriptions. BTW, I come from the TKD school of thought.
karatekid1975
Master Black Belt
I did TSD and now do TKD, and I agree with mtabone's posts. I would have explained it like that, also.
G
Galvatron
Guest
Hey karatekid, off topic but shouldnt your sig say FORMERLY 5th gup?
TallAdam85
3rd Black Belt
tsd and tkd are close in some things but different in others only thing is most tsd people hate tkd people and most tkd hate tsd people you know what i mean Nightingale
In my 24 year's in the martial art's, That is the first time i have ever heard that !! Guess i have to start hatin now(sheeesh) Are you talking about olympic,sport T.K.D. ? If that's the case. I wonder. MITHIOS
karatekid1975
Master Black Belt
Originally posted by Galvatron
Hey karatekid, off topic but shouldnt your sig say FORMERLY 5th gup?
Oops, yea. My spelling is bad LOL
S
Shinzu
Guest
hmmmm... i don't think that is the case at all. to hate different martial artists because of their style is quite shallow. maybe those people need to look at the codes and tenets of TSD and TKD.
karatekid1975
Master Black Belt
I agree with Shinzu. The tenets in TSD and TKD are just about the same, as far as I know. And I don't hate people because of the art they study. And I have done both
Leaving out "hate" which is no doubt too strong, is there a lot of friction or tension between TSD and TKD practitioners?
TKD is bigger, but TSD considers itself more self-defense oriented.
TKD is bigger, but TSD considers itself more self-defense oriented.
S
Shinzu
Guest
i have never studied TKD so i am not inclined to say which is better or worse. my TSD school puts a lot of attention to self defense. my first TSD school did not. it all depends on where and who you train with, but it is not the martial way to dislike any other students or styles. after all we are all in it for a common goal of protecting ourselves one way or another.
i dont think the two systems are under competition at all. if anything they should benefit from each other by being both korean styles.
i dont think the two systems are under competition at all. if anything they should benefit from each other by being both korean styles.
karatekid1975
Master Black Belt
Both my TSD and TKD dojangs are self defense oriented. Neither was really into sport, eventhough they did give you the choice of both. They both have joint locks, take-downs, counter- grappling, ect. BUT my TKD school is the one that teaches throws, and ground grappling. Then again I saw dojangs of both syles that are mostly sport. So I say it depends on the school, not the style.
As far as each not liking each other, I have seen it in TSD. A few were TKD bashers. I used to be one of them. Because they think TKD is all sport. I was proven wrong with the dojang I am in now
But my TSD dojang used to host sparring clinics and TKD people attended and everyone had a blast ..... go figure *shrugs*
I hope that made sense. I'm kinda in a hurry LOL.
As far as each not liking each other, I have seen it in TSD. A few were TKD bashers. I used to be one of them. Because they think TKD is all sport. I was proven wrong with the dojang I am in now
But my TSD dojang used to host sparring clinics and TKD people attended and everyone had a blast ..... go figure *shrugs*
I hope that made sense. I'm kinda in a hurry LOL.
Yes karatekid1975, it's also been my experience that TSDers are more likely to take a slam at TKDers than the other way around.
