I have one of his books, in my honest opinion after studying with a Fist Generation Student of Yip Mans, Randy Williams teachings come across a little too complicated i.e. he takes a simple concept and creates a big long thesis out of it, when the most simple explanation is the best, I also found some of his fundamental teachings on SLT lacking, particulary in fundamental concepts such as rotation of the shoulder, thesinking of the arms in SLT and the forward moving Energy in SLT. Aside from that he does have some reasonable stuff to share. I it is a matter of picking the meat from the bones.SilatFan said:
perhaps you should more closely read my postSifu Barry Cuda said:
Perhaps you should think more closely about what you say and about whom you say it on a public forum, for you can never be sure who will be reading it and calling you on the carpet to substantiate what you've said.bcbernam777 said:
"picking meat from the bones" is a euphumism for when you take out good information that is picked out from a pool of information being offered and leaving what you consider bad information behind. At no point did I criticise Randy's Kung Fu, my critique was of some of his teaching, if you would have spent more then 2 seconds looking at my post and looking at what I said instead of shooting your mouth of, you would have noticed that I also said that "Aside from that he does have some reasonable stuff to share".Nanalo74 said:
I pretty much gave up on this thread. You can imagine how excited I was when I read that there were 9 replies to it. To bad the converstation got a little of trackSifu Barry Cuda said:
I would like to thank all you guys for your input. I know that it was genuine and with good intentions! 
