Jim Arvantis (sp?)
- Thread starter Cthulhu
- Start date
G
GouRonin
Guest
Hasn't this guy been around doing Pankration since dirt was invented? Heh heh heh...
G
GouRonin
Guest
I know it's going to be a demonstration sport at the Greece olympics, but does anyone know the status of the competitors?
I ask because there is a guy I know looking to make the Canadian team. I heard Keith Hackney of Kenpo fame and UFC fame is part of the USA coaching team.
Any other info?
I ask because there is a guy I know looking to make the Canadian team. I heard Keith Hackney of Kenpo fame and UFC fame is part of the USA coaching team.
Any other info?
G
GouRonin
Guest
Seems Hackney delved right into the grappling aspect of nhb and went head first into pankration.
Arvantis I hear is dead against the greece olympic coalition as he says it is not true pankration but that it's a bunch of wannabes. Some weird stuff going on.
Arvantis I hear is dead against the greece olympic coalition as he says it is not true pankration but that it's a bunch of wannabes. Some weird stuff going on.
G
GouRonin
Guest
I think he's pissed because they didn't make him the head or something or that he feels it's not real PK and that it's a money grab.
Pretty adament about it.
Pretty adament about it.
I
Icepick
Guest
Does it seem odd to anyone else that arvantis is the only guy who knows about a martial art that is like, 3,000 years old? It's kind of silly to argue about what's "real pankration", when the only evidence of it is drawn on a few vases. IMHO, it's just a marketing thing.
K
Kyle
Guest
Didn't I see an ad in Black Belt for his instructional course? One vase a month, first month is kitrinos, second month is portokali, with the last the mavros vase. After a year or so, you have the complete system as well as a nice collection for your china cabinet.
- Kyle
- Kyle
I
Icepick
Guest
Cancel at any time! Keep only those vases you want! And if you act know, we will include this fabulous Mesopotamian firearms course! :rofl:
B
bryans
Guest
Arvantis.....he's like 6'2" ........... 6'5" with the afro
(I can't take the credit - that line is from Fletch):shrug:
(I can't take the credit - that line is from Fletch):shrug:
B
Bake
Guest
Oohh....those vases would really compliment my Norman Rockwell plate collection!
I largely agree, thoug I suppose with the growth in popularity of the Oriental arts at the time there may also have been a national pride issue ("We too have ancient fighting arts, or at least we did."). Even in the 70s it seemed clear to me that this was about making money not mastering martial arts, and that much must have been reconstructed (like the new mythology of some Korean systems).
I like the vase-of-the-month club approach!
I
Icepick
Guest
Bake -
I had you pegged as a "hummel" kind of guy...
I had you pegged as a "hummel" kind of guy...
Originally posted by Icepick
Does it seem odd to anyone else that arvantis is the only guy who knows about a martial art that is like, 3,000 years old? It's kind of silly to argue about what's "real pankration", when the only evidence of it is drawn on a few vases. IMHO, it's just a marketing thing.
Icepick,
From what I've read, and the amount of time Mr.Arvantis has publicly stated his skills. I gotta believe he is the real deal. I don't recall his m.a. roots, but I think his approach is reminisent of Bruce Lee's. I do recall the mentioning of research being one of the cornerstones of his system. Hence the Pankration/M.T. connection? Not a claim of singular knowledge of a centuries old system. Just my 2 cents based on material I have read.
Salute in Christ,
Donald :asian:
Does it seem odd to anyone else that arvantis is the only guy who knows about a martial art that is like, 3,000 years old? It's kind of silly to argue about what's "real pankration", when the only evidence of it is drawn on a few vases. IMHO, it's just a marketing thing.
Icepick,
From what I've read, and the amount of time Mr.Arvantis has publicly stated his skills. I gotta believe he is the real deal. I don't recall his m.a. roots, but I think his approach is reminisent of Bruce Lee's. I do recall the mentioning of research being one of the cornerstones of his system. Hence the Pankration/M.T. connection? Not a claim of singular knowledge of a centuries old system. Just my 2 cents based on material I have read.
Salute in Christ,
Donald :asian:
I
Icepick
Guest
donald -
I've never seen Mr. Arvanitis, and he may be an outstanding martial artist. My point is that it is ridiculous to argue what is "real pankration", when there is so little recorded about it. To assume that only Jim Arvanitis knows whether Achilles knew how to use a heel hook is silly. The techniques propounded as "real pankration" have all been used for some time in other martial arts, and there has been no continuous practice of pankration. If you are choosing techniques from other styles, and repackaging them as "pankration", you are just marketing yourself as an expert of this "ancient" martial art.
JAMA is the closest thing I've seen to an academic journal on martial arts, and I've never seen the fruit of research on ancient pankration.
I've never seen Mr. Arvanitis, and he may be an outstanding martial artist. My point is that it is ridiculous to argue what is "real pankration", when there is so little recorded about it. To assume that only Jim Arvanitis knows whether Achilles knew how to use a heel hook is silly. The techniques propounded as "real pankration" have all been used for some time in other martial arts, and there has been no continuous practice of pankration. If you are choosing techniques from other styles, and repackaging them as "pankration", you are just marketing yourself as an expert of this "ancient" martial art.
JAMA is the closest thing I've seen to an academic journal on martial arts, and I've never seen the fruit of research on ancient pankration.
OP
OP
JAMA is great! Unfortunately, I haven't picked one up for quite some time ($10 per issue!). However, in the past 6 years or so, I've never seen an article on pankration.
Then again, JAMA stands for 'Journal of Asian Martial Arts', which could partly explain the reason it doesn't cover pankration
Cthulhu
Then again, JAMA stands for 'Journal of Asian Martial Arts', which could partly explain the reason it doesn't cover pankration
Cthulhu
I just found this thread. Keith is a friend as is Tom Saviano who is also involved in Pankration. I don't know that much about what's going on because it really is not my thing. If you have some questions, I could ask both Keith and Tom Saviano about it and get back to you on it.
