Between Brown & Black

M

MartialArtsGuy

Guest
Hi all

Id like to collect some opinions and factual info on the material between 3rd degree brown belt on through 1st degree black.

I have been in that range for a short time now and I'm starting to think as I advance through kenpo, it leans more toward the conceptual side. I undertand the techniques have always been interchangable/flexible ideas and not "the answer for a particular instance"

The techniques from yellow through green were more simplistic and even though were still ideas, i could see how one could react with the technique as written without too much "what-if". (sheild and hammer, clutching feathers, twirling sacrafice)

But now it seems as if the techniques are more giving you more tools and ideas and joining them end to end in a short dance. I have noticed that the foot work is a little more involved too.

The techniques last so long that to use them in a real situation would demand that the situation have the exact same variables as in the ideal phase of the technique. (timing, relative position of you to your opponents, number of attackers....etc...)
Something not likely to happen.

I do like the information in what I have seen so far, but I really think it is meant to be something you pick and choose from to meet the demands of the situation. I do think mainly of the initial moves at the start of the techniques will come out, but than after that its all formulation because of the high probability that the variables you ecounter will be different than those in the ideal form of the technique.

So anyway... what does everyone think of the material between brown and black. Any likes or dislikes, or info regarding anything.
Anything anyone thinks I should know. I'm interested in opinions and facts?
 
jfarnsworth

jfarnsworth

Grandmaster
MTS Alumni
Joined
Mar 17, 2002
Messages
6,550
Reaction score
34
Location
N.C. Ohio
Originally posted by MartialArtsGuy
Id like to collect some opinions and factual info on the material between 3rd degree brown belt on through 1st degree black.
Click to expand...

Depending upon which curriculum you follow (24,16,12) I consider 3rd brown about half way through the curriculum. There you are learning tech.'s, forms, and the sets. This is your first goal. After attaining 1st black then you must go over and re-learn or start to truely understand AK to get adavanced degrees.:asian:
 
OP
M

MartialArtsGuy

Guest
Sorry, I'm most familiar with the 24 system.
 
OP
M

MartialArtsGuy

Guest
huh?

yes yes, that is what i am saying. im refering to the curriculum as outlined in Infinite Insights.
 
OP
M

MartialArtsGuy

Guest
Mr. Conatser

Maybe we are misunderstanding each other. but yes I am training under the 24 tech per belt system if that helps you with my over all question listed in the initial post.

This is open to anyone though.
 
Goldendragon7

Goldendragon7

Grandmaster
Joined
Feb 15, 2002
Messages
5,643
Reaction score
37
Location
Scottsdale, Arizona
Originally posted by MartialArtsGuy

Mr. Conatser Maybe we are misunderstanding each other. but yes I am training under the 24 tech per belt system if that helps you with my over all question listed in the initial post.
Click to expand...

Yes, but in an earlier post you stated you were NOT familiar with the 24 Technique System.

I see you now know what that is....

thanks.

:asian:
 
OP
M

MartialArtsGuy

Guest
huh?
are you sure you got the right guy. i dont remember saying that. if i did it may have been a typo, or maybe i was drinking that night or something. As far as i know i have always trained the 24 tech system.

wow this is some real twilight zone stuff.

if you find the post please email it to me or something.
Thanks
 
OP
M

MartialArtsGuy

Guest
ok, i see what happend

I was saying "sorry" to jfarnsworth for not clarifying what system i train in my first post.

Than i went on to tell him what system i was most familiar with.

man if this wont fix it, than to hell with it. :D
 
Thesemindz

Thesemindz

Senior Master
MT Mentor
Joined
Oct 26, 2003
Messages
2,170
Reaction score
103
Location
Springfield, Missouri
Originally posted by MartialArtsGuy
I'm starting to think as I advance through kenpo, it leans more toward the conceptual side. I undertand the techniques have always been interchangable/flexible ideas and not "the answer for a particular instance"

The techniques from yellow through green were more simplistic and even though were still ideas, i could see how one could react with the technique as written without too much "what-if". (sheild and hammer, clutching feathers, twirling sacrafice)

But now it seems as if the techniques are more giving you more tools and ideas and joining them end to end in a short dance. I have noticed that the foot work is a little more involved too.

The techniques last so long that to use them in a real situation would demand that the situation have the exact same variables as in the ideal phase of the technique. (timing, relative position of you to your opponents, number of attackers....etc...)
Something not likely to happen.
Click to expand...



I think you're point has some merit. The two man techniques especially are very conceptual and depend greatly on ideal and robotic responses by the dummies to work "as is." In general they teach strategies and maneuvers that can be applied to a dynamic situation, and their practice encourages the use of reverse motion, but they are not "the answer," techniques never are.

Other techniques on this list though, are complex manifestations of simple ideas. Glancing Spear, Circling Fans, Raining Lance, and Blinding Sacrifice all begin with effective defensive maneuvers. Once the initial attack is disrupted, they continue to teach important lessons about position and motion.

There are some techniques on this list that are like catalogues of motion. Falling Falcon is one of these catalogue techniques. It teaches a series of methods that can be used to accomplish a single goal. Hooking Wings is an earlier example of this. This gives you the option of exercising a variety of responses in a similar situation. Performing the entire technique on one person, is probably not possible. Besides which, it would require a very sadistic mind set. If the opponent is still ready to go after you break his arm five times, you need to be breaking something else.

All of these techniques contain short simple movements which can be adapted to a wide variety of situations. As I practice these techniques more and more I find short parrying patterns and footwork sequences bleed into my spontaneous more and more.

You already mentioned the footwork, and you're right on. It is more complicated. It contains a huge amount of buckling and striking attacks with the legs. It helps to teach us to make the legs a weapon at all times, whether or not they leave the ground.

In the end, these techniques are just like all the others. It's Stance Set 1 again and again. You compared them to dance, but I'd call them Short Forms. It's the application that makes all the difference and the techniques give us one possible interpretation of that.

Techniques never happen as written. Not even Delayed Handsword. They work because you apply what you've practiced to the situation at hand. You never know, of all the possible physical responses an opponent could have to a technique, the ideal one probably has about as good a chance as most.

-Rob
 
Dominic Jones

Dominic Jones

Orange Belt
Joined
Jun 9, 2002
Messages
60
Reaction score
0
Location
Sendai City, Japan
Looking to the future. I believe that Mr Kevin Mills from England will have the greatest impact on my ;) (EPAK) Kenpo training over the next 10 years.

His dedication to Kenpo regulary involves travelling to far parts of the world (Japan-last week, America-this week, back to England the following week!).

Being a student of the arts, on behalf of the British Kenpo Karate Union, he is continually seeking excellent instruction, pushing his training to new levels. As an excellent instructor he is pulling kenpo students up to new levels as well.

You might not know his name, but if you ever have the chance to train with him. I recommend it, you won`t be disappointed.:D

Cheers Dominic
PS. The BKKU in the UK, founded by GM Bob Rose, has had the greatest impact on my ;) (EPAK) Kenpo training so far. :asian:

PPS. Isn`t it great that there are so many :D different people who will have a great impact on EPAK in the future.:)
 
OP
M

MartialArtsGuy

Guest
Thesemindz

Thanks for the good reply.
 
T

TwistofFat

Green Belt
Joined
May 4, 2004
Messages
176
Reaction score
2
Location
Waxhaw NC
Folks I am new to this site (and the computer do hicky) but have been reading and reading...awesome stuff.
I have been in 'limbo' as a 1st brown for years. I lost my first instructor to booze, moved, got ripped off, found a 4th in Charlotte, NC who got his belt "from the old man" (no disrespect on my part) that knew far less than I did. Anyway, my point to all of this is when I found a good teacher (200 miles away, once a week) and learned Forms 4 and 5 the techniques and position recognition began to click. The timing and settling with the strikes, leg work timing, etc. made me go back and reexamine yellow-green with a renewed interest and sense of application. It has taken me just under 10 years after my 3rd brown to be ready to test for my bb (almost) and boy am I glad I stuck with it.

Best Regards- Glenn
 
Michael Billings

Michael Billings

Senior Master
MTS Alumni
Joined
Apr 5, 2002
Messages
3,962
Reaction score
31
Location
Austin, Texas USA-Terra
Welcome to MartialTalk.

I like the effort you have put into your training, and committment it has taken to reach the level you have. It is great to see someone from the old school, willing to take the extra step by travelling, and recognize that it is important to have a good teacher. Not everyone can tell the good from the bad, separate the wheat from the chaff when it comes to instructors. Glad you found a "good one".

-Michael
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Tatum: TOW (outsiders perspective)

Previous Thread

Can anyone verify these people?

Next Thread

Latest Discussions

Top