So, that can explain a lot. If it parallels how Pioneer did things and retaining old habits that would parallel issues on how progeny of pioneers retained habits which filtered down to their progeny as opposed to following the standard set out by General Choi. (To the dismay of progeny or...
Coming at this from a non KKW perspective my questions would be: 1. Are there "Official videos" showing what should be the Optimal performance? 2. Is their an official written text setting forth the technical parameters? I ask because as a follower of General Choi's system there is such a...
Breathing for TKD s really no different than most athletic activities. (Certain Power lifts being a notable exception) Exhale with the exertion. In order to coordinate the exhale with the exertion as noted in posts above you control the exhale. I explain it to kids that it is like blowing...
Chang Hon has a "Sweeping Kick" so it is part of the system but not part of techniques allowed in competition. As with many things people can argue about definitions. Typically the purpose of the "Sweep" is to unbalance the opponent and is done very low down on the leg / foot which is why it...
Here is a summary of Breaking requirements. Boards are standard "1 x 12" pine with a width of 10" .
Black Belt Testing. Breaking Quick Reference
USTF Dan Testing Syllabus, 1996 Edition (Tile Alternatives By Earl Weiss A-6-39)
(Note: Peewee is age 10 and younger. Junior is age 11 thru 15...
The National Org has breaking requirements which vary by Rank, Sex and age all of which can be modified by the test board. The age variations take into account that younger students are still growing / developing and as we get older there is a natural loss of bone density.
A TKD person Boxer and Judoka walking together and see 3 thugs attack a guy. They are about to help, but The guy uses a hip throw to take out one attacker and Judoka says "Nice Technique". Before they jump in, intended victim deftly ducks a punch and takes out the next attacker with a hook...
Quick story from General Choi's lessons .
"You must teach your students correctly from the start since if they make a mistake for a day, it takes a day to fix. If they make a mistake for a month, it takes a month to fix. If they make a mistake for a year..... Hopeless. "
Gen Choi says he studied Shotokan Karate in Japan but when WWII ended, he did not train at the Chung Do Kwan (as did those 17 members, including GM NAM,Tae Hi who was personal secretary to GM LEE, Won Kuk before he started training). Gen Choi was given an honorary 4th dan by GM SON, Duk Song who...
HU Lee was also a Chung Do Kwan alum later associating with General Choi and the ITF, and later still leaving the ITF and doing his own thing with great success.
Instructors often may be "Up to Date" but that doesn't mean all old habits were eliminated. You see this in the ITF "stylists" where pioneers and their progeny have habits from their Kwan days and some think that this must have been how General Choi intended and it must have been changed...
Because that Video is from General Choi's system. While perhaps not entirely accurate a common comment was that the system had 2000 hand / arm techniques and 1200 foot / leg techniques. It always allowed punching to the head in sparring. . It was that other system coming some 10 years later...
For several decades we have used "Gup Requirement Sheets" First sheet is included with the student handbook each new student receives. When they pass they get the sheet for the next rank. These sheets include the National Org. core requirements plus my school requirements. They serve as a list...
So, since General Choi appointed 7 people to GM status and only one or 2 of those remained with an org that used the name "ITF" then the progeny of 5 of General Choi's most senior students plus various other Seniors that trained extensively with General Choi are not learning "real taekwondo"...
Punisher wrote:
But, in the meantime, here is an article about how applications didn't get passed on as karate became more popular.
From the Linked article: "Not only do the kata provide the techniques but, more importantly, they also include the principles upon which the techniques rest. The...
I look forward to seeing the quote. Now to the issue of "applications weren't really taught":. This depends on how you view applications. I view the applications that are taught as being learning tools . They help you learn how to move. They teach distance and direction. Now, how you...
Form variations are a fun exercise. However, doing a form really well takes lots of time and energy so it is a question of how you use your resources. Fun variations provide a nice break from the routine. Examples include: Combat Speed - Do it as quickly as possible without regard to...
I understand. but the point remains as to whether an evolution would consciously or not remove a tradition of blocking to the left side which would have been the non weapon / weaker side more likely to be attacked.
Good story but I expect if true I would have heard it before. Which is not to say only the Block / Punch / kick aren't taught, but doubting the line specifically stating anything bout not teaching "Deeper Meaning". Would luv to see a photo of the alleged line and get it translated. Also...