Punches vs Open hand to face for self defense.

clfsean

Senior Master
MT Mentor
MTS Alumni
Joined
Jun 15, 2004
Messages
3,687
Reaction score
400
Location
Metropolitan Tokyo
Good one. And now that I think about it, let's not forget the basic slap. Very useful for a variety of things, not least of which is ending a fight through humiliation.

Truth enough with that. A nice hard open handed slap across the face is a nice starter or stopper. As a starter you have as much of a psychological pause button as much as a first strike. It's a great way to start things & a great opener. Move it back from the face a smidge & into the jaw/ear area... nice love tap there. Not to mention the concussive impact that the open hand carries...
 

seasoned

MT Senior Moderator
Staff member
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
11,253
Reaction score
1,231
Location
Lives in Texas
A slap with focus is much more then a love tap. And as mentioned, it is a great opener with hands up palms out. Not to be underestimated. A slap is with finger tips, a focused open hand strike involves the whole hand.................
 

mook jong man

Senior Master
Joined
May 28, 2008
Messages
3,080
Reaction score
263
Location
Matsudo , Japan
A palm strike can be more powerful than a punch , mainly because there is one less joint for the force to be transmitted through , much like an elbow strike it is closer to the power source.
With the punch there will generally be some leakage of force due to a slight buckling of the wrist on impact.

In Wing Chun palm striking we use a slightly cup shaped hand formation , not only because it fits nicely over chins , jawlines etc but it helps to concentrate the force into a smaller surface area.

We use a few different types of palm strike , the common vertical palm strike , but we also use a side palm , a 45 degree palm , double palm strike , palm up - edge of the hand palm strikes that attack the side of the neck and underneath the side of the jaw.

Also an exotic one called Po Pai , that is a double palm strike with one hand vertical pointing upwards and the other directly beneath it vertically pointing downwards with the force directed slightly away from each other , supposedly designed to spread the organs apart and cause internal damage.
But that is one that requires not only immense force , but also a lot of wrist flexibility due to the bottom palm facing downwards.
 

Bill Mattocks

Sr. Grandmaster
MTS Alumni
Joined
Feb 8, 2009
Messages
15,627
Reaction score
4,435
Location
Michigan
A slap with focus is much more then a love tap. And as mentioned, it is a great opener with hands up palms out. Not to be underestimated. A slap is with finger tips, a focused open hand strike involves the whole hand.................

I was also considering the ear ringer (box the ears or one ear) and the open-hand soft-block techniques which hurt like the dickens and absolutely humiliate as well. There's not much more embarrassing for a tough guy, I think, than to have their hardest punches slapped out of the air and in a way which makes their arm numb and useless as well. Also done from a hands-up position. When our sensei is demonstrating, he has his uke throw as hard as possible, like real-life hard and fast, right towards his face. The harder one throws, the more useless one's arm becomes the moment he dead-hands it across the bicep of the incoming punch. Awesome mechanics. I can't quite do it, yet, but it's on my list of objectives, because it is devastating. It's great because it is so clearly defensive and yet at the same time such a fight-ender. You can't fight when you can't life your arm.
 

clfsean

Senior Master
MT Mentor
MTS Alumni
Joined
Jun 15, 2004
Messages
3,687
Reaction score
400
Location
Metropolitan Tokyo
A palm strike can be more powerful than a punch , mainly because there is one less joint for the force to be transmitted through , much like an elbow strike it is closer to the power source.
With the punch there will generally be some leakage of force due to a slight buckling of the wrist on impact.

In Wing Chun palm striking we use a slightly cup shaped hand formation , not only because it fits nicely over chins , jawlines etc but it helps to concentrate the force into a smaller surface area.

We use a few different types of palm strike , the common vertical palm strike , but we also use a side palm , a 45 degree palm , double palm strike , palm up - edge of the hand palm strikes that attack the side of the neck and underneath the side of the jaw.

Also an exotic one called Po Pai , that is a double palm strike with one hand vertical pointing upwards and the other directly beneath it vertically pointing downwards with the force directed slightly away from each other , supposedly designed to spread the organs apart and cause internal damage.
But that is one that requires not only immense force , but also a lot of wrist flexibility due to the bottom palm facing downwards.

Yep... We use a couple of additional ones in CLF but all the ones you mentioned we absolutely use. The last one you mention (Po Pai) we dont use to hit with, but we could if we need to. We call it Dip Jeurng (Butterfly Palm).
 

mook jong man

Senior Master
Joined
May 28, 2008
Messages
3,080
Reaction score
263
Location
Matsudo , Japan
Yep... We use a couple of additional ones in CLF but all the ones you mentioned we absolutely use. The last one you mention (Po Pai) we dont use to hit with, but we could if we need to. We call it Dip Jeurng (Butterfly Palm).

In the wooden dummy form here you see pretty much all of them , also the Po Pai that I mentioned.

[video=youtube_share;w0pudWjTNNk]http://youtu.be/w0pudWjTNNk[/video]
 

MJS

Administrator
Staff member
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2003
Messages
30,187
Reaction score
430
Location
Cromwell,CT
I was also considering the ear ringer (box the ears or one ear) and the open-hand soft-block techniques which hurt like the dickens and absolutely humiliate as well. There's not much more embarrassing for a tough guy, I think, than to have their hardest punches slapped out of the air and in a way which makes their arm numb and useless as well. Also done from a hands-up position. When our sensei is demonstrating, he has his uke throw as hard as possible, like real-life hard and fast, right towards his face. The harder one throws, the more useless one's arm becomes the moment he dead-hands it across the bicep of the incoming punch. Awesome mechanics. I can't quite do it, yet, but it's on my list of objectives, because it is devastating. It's great because it is so clearly defensive and yet at the same time such a fight-ender. You can't fight when you can't life your arm.

And I"m sure everyone is raising their hand when he asks for an uke..lol. :) Or if he just calls on someone, they're probably thinking, "Well, there goes the use of my arm for the rest of the night."

But yes, I like the idea of the ear slap.
 

Bill Mattocks

Sr. Grandmaster
MTS Alumni
Joined
Feb 8, 2009
Messages
15,627
Reaction score
4,435
Location
Michigan
And I"m sure everyone is raising their hand when he asks for an uke..lol. :) Or if he just calls on someone, they're probably thinking, "Well, there goes the use of my arm for the rest of the night."

What I especially love is saying "I didn't quite get that sensei, can you show us again?"

But then we get to practice it on each other (a bit less power and speed, but still hard enough to get the general idea), so we all get a taste anyway.

But yes, I like the idea of the ear slap.

That's one of those that you can't practice in the dojo, unfortunately. But it's disorienting as I understand it.
 

zDom

Senior Master
Joined
Aug 21, 2006
Messages
3,081
Reaction score
110
Early in my training, I remember preferring the palm strike: I could generate more power that my wrists could stand in punching position while training on heavy bag (unwrapped wrists.. I've never trained heavy bag with supported wrists).

Later, as I trained wrist strength and gained more power through hips and body weight shifting, I found my palm sinking far enough into the bag that it was uncomfortably bending my wrist backward. Since then I have preferred to train punches on the bag as a fist sinks in to the bag with no discomfort.

I am only referring to straight line punching, by the way. And I do regularly train all my striking on a bag — some palm strikes, some knifehands, some ridgehands ... but I like seeing how hard I can hit that bag without my wrists folding.

The best self defense option for you, I think, would be the techniques you feel most comfortable and confident with. But remember that could change with time and training.
 

Dirty Dog

MT Senior Moderator
Staff member
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
23,363
Reaction score
9,102
Location
Pueblo West, CO
God this is stupid. If anyone here actually KNEW how to fight and actually got into a fight (heaven forbid) you'd know that the ol palm vs fist thing goes out the window. In a real fight you are trying to hit the other guy and fear for your safety...you dont have the luxury of choosing between palm or fist.

View attachment 16208
 
  • Like
Reactions: MJS

chinto

Senior Master
Joined
Apr 18, 2007
Messages
2,026
Reaction score
38
Firstly I'd like to apologize for asking so many questions. I seem to have hit a bit of an inquisitive stage this week.

There are pros and cons to both techniques, for example in the hands of a martial artist who knows how to strike the punch can be quite deadly, but just the same if those fragile knuckles ( assuming one has not endured iron palm training ) collide with the skull, it will cause damage or even break your hand.

Palm strikes are safer but also slower and have less range. That are also unnatural to most people.

Obviously there are situations where one is more effective than the other. For example if you were trying to deescalate a conflict but your opponent swung on you anyway, smashing your palm into their face is quite a simple and natural task.

But what of after? If the fight is prolonged more than those first few seconds of your initial reaction.

One thing I have noticed is that in most forms/katas I have see/performed, punches are usually aimed towards the imaginary enemies torso area. Some go towards the face yes, but the stance and motion of the punch usually is striking towards the body. Does that mean anything?

Appreciate your thoughts.


Both strikes work, if you work the makawara you are much less likely to brake your knuckles or metatarsals. That said, a good palm shot will often and a fight, the Okinawans targeted vitals and ribs more then the head with empty hand as you can fight with a lot of damage to the face and head, ribs brake easier and if you can not breath you can not fight... and well vitals destroyed and your dead. ( ribs were often fatal back in the day before definitive medical care too.) So in answer I would say both are great. a palm to the chin will often end a fight instantly.... so I would say go with what your system teaches till you are say a brown belt or so, but if in a self defense situation, use what ever feels right..
 

chinto

Senior Master
Joined
Apr 18, 2007
Messages
2,026
Reaction score
38
Questions are always welcome. And even the most experienced people here ask more than they sit back and pontificate. It`s by bringing these things up for discussion that we all learn more.

That being said, Proper punching technique protects the knuckles during a punch....but proper punching isn`t natural and it has to be trained over a long period so that full power can be delivered into an opponant. Lots of people THINK they`re hitting full power. What they`re doing is using their full EFFORT, but because their technique is poor the impact potential is bled off before it transferrs into the opponant. But this talk isn`t about proper punching, it`s about palms vs fists.
I like both, but I use open hands more often because it`s easier to transission into grabs (which make the next strike more effective) and throws. I`ve never found open hand strikes to be slower than fists, just the opposite. Since my arm is more relaxed with the hand open it travels faster. Yes, the range is slightly less, but not significantly so. And because I`m a bigger guy I usually only use strikes in the first instance of an altercation anyway. After that I close to shorter range and depend on knees, elbows, grappling, and such instead of longe range punching. So the choice of fist or open hand isn`t really an either-or scenario in my opinion.

I do think that some type of regular hand conditioning is a HUGE help with both types of strikes though. Whether it`s as simple as working your strikes on the heavybag, or more traditional hand conditioning meathods. You need to build muscle memory to strike well, you need to create hand-eye-coordination, and learn to read distance to your target so you can strike properly. Of the 3 , I think the last one is the most important part of bagwork, and one very few people ever talk about.

I would also suggest you get some training from a QUALIFIED instructor on how to use a Makawara. That will help harden the bones, increase your focus and really make your alinement on your wrist improve vastly quickly!
 

Dirty Dog

MT Senior Moderator
Staff member
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
23,363
Reaction score
9,102
Location
Pueblo West, CO
Both strikes work, if you work the makawara you are much less likely to brake your knuckles or metatarsals. That said, a good palm shot will often and a fight, the Okinawans targeted vitals and ribs more then the head with empty hand as you can fight with a lot of damage to the face and head, ribs brake easier and if you can not breath you can not fight... and well vitals destroyed and your dead. ( ribs were often fatal back in the day before definitive medical care too.) So in answer I would say both are great. a palm to the chin will often end a fight instantly.... so I would say go with what your system teaches till you are say a brown belt or so, but if in a self defense situation, use what ever feels right..

Metatarsals are in the feet. And if you brake them, there certainly won't be much impact.... :)
 

seasoned

MT Senior Moderator
Staff member
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
11,253
Reaction score
1,231
Location
Lives in Texas
Anybody familiar with Tensho (turning palm). Number 7 out of 12 Okinawan GoJu kata. Great kata.
 

Zenjael

Purple Belt
Joined
Feb 27, 2012
Messages
355
Reaction score
6
Location
Fairfax Virginia
I've always felt anytime you could punch, a palm strike is just as sufficient. Honestly, I don't think I can break a cinder-block with my fist, but I have a palm. I'd feel safer with the former to keep serious harm from happening to a person... but if necessary I believe a palm can execute far more force in a strike than a fist, because the durability constraints are significantly less.

You have less fear of hurting your hand... but greater of harming the other. Knowing when it is appropriate, and how much force, is to know when to place the strike at its proper place.
 

Buka

Sr. Grandmaster
Staff member
MT Mentor
Joined
Jun 27, 2011
Messages
12,952
Reaction score
10,444
Location
Maui
I know folks who slap similar to a boxing left hook. Their slaps could knock the bejesus out of you. Palms, punches, ridge hands etc, thrown properly, all hurt a whole bunch. I'll bet if all of us here spent a week together in a Dojo, the true power strike of many of us would be completely different. And I don't think that's dependent on what styles we might have studied, I think it comes from what we've all personally developed over a jillion hours of training.

My face has never actually met a strike that it liked. Neither has my body.
 

seasoned

MT Senior Moderator
Staff member
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
11,253
Reaction score
1,231
Location
Lives in Texas
Anybody familiar with Tensho (turning palm). Number 7 out of 12 Okinawan GoJu kata. Great kata.
I mention this because it is an advanced kata pertaining to open hand techniques.
 

seasoned

MT Senior Moderator
Staff member
Lifetime Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
11,253
Reaction score
1,231
Location
Lives in Texas
I've always felt anytime you could punch, a palm strike is just as sufficient. Honestly, I don't think I can break a cinder-block with my fist, but I have a palm. I'd feel safer with the former to keep serious harm from happening to a person... but if necessary I believe a palm can execute far more force in a strike than a fist, because the durability constraints are significantly less.

You have less fear of hurting your hand... but greater of harming the other. Knowing when it is appropriate, and how much force, is to know when to place the strike at its proper place.
Great point. Knuckles cut, and blood is bad press. But, that heavy open hand strike to the side of the head will make you beg for a punch. :)
 

Zenjael

Purple Belt
Joined
Feb 27, 2012
Messages
355
Reaction score
6
Location
Fairfax Virginia
Great point. Knuckles cut, and blood is bad press. But, that heavy open hand strike to the side of the head will make you beg for a punch. :)

Execellent point. I believe this is one teacher I said, over and over like a mantra, 'If your punch doesn't put them down in the first strike... you aren't doing enough push-ups.'

I suspect there was a deeper message of, don't escalate unless prepared to.
 

frank raud

Master of Arts
Joined
Mar 23, 2006
Messages
1,867
Reaction score
696
Location
Ottawa, ON
Execellent point. I believe this is one teacher I said, over and over like a mantra, 'If your punch doesn't put them down in the first strike... you aren't doing enough push-ups.'

I suspect there was a deeper message of, don't escalate unless prepared to.

You develop most of your power in a punch by doing pushups?
 

Latest Discussions

Top