Changing or Developing your own Art.....

OP
Goldendragon7

Goldendragon7

Grandmaster
Joined
Feb 15, 2002
Messages
5,643
Reaction score
37
Location
Scottsdale, Arizona
Kembudo-Kai Kempoka said:
GD7...

When I do teach, I teach an amalgamation of Kenpo (& a couple offshoots), Japanese Judo & Jujutsu, BJJ, JKD modified kick-boxing, and Thai. I don't claim it as my invention, or as anything new. In fact, I'll make it a point to say, "this is from AK"...or..."this is from Judo", etc.
Dave
From what you state, you are being honest and truthful not trying to take credit from someone else's works and giving credit where credit is due.

Kembudo-Kai Kempoka said:
I haven't magically conferred a new rank on myself (although Dr. Dave, Super-Master does have a unique ring to it), nor do I claim to be the fountainhead of all knowledge from which this information sprung. Just the source for this class, citing references as I go (old habit from too many research papers).
Dave
Again, commendable and not what I'm talking about.


Kembudo-Kai Kempoka said:
Am I, by not being a purist, one of the reprehensible founders, or merely someone sharing what he's learned along the way, to the best of his limited ability to recall it? (a diminished capacity to which I also frequently admit to students).
Dave
From what you state...... you are safe......LOL expanding and coming up with new ideas or drills is what we are suppose to do. Please continue along your path and enrich the Art.

Kembudo-Kai Kempoka said:
I'm not saying this to be antagonistic, btw. Just wondering if I managed to become one of "them" when I wasn't looking.
Dave
LOL, well, one of "them" on which side of the coin......LOL if you are talking about those that mislead folks ........ I would say NO, you blew it...... we can crack crab together.:)

:asian:
 

pete

Master Black Belt
Joined
Aug 31, 2003
Messages
1,003
Reaction score
32
Location
Long Island, New York
When I do teach, I teach an amalgamation of Kenpo (& a couple offshoots), Japanese Judo & Jujutsu, BJJ, JKD modified kick-boxing, and Thai. I don't claim it as my invention, or as anythig new. In fact, I'll make it a point to say, "this is from AK"...or..."this is from Judo", etc. - Kembudo-Kai Kempoka

looks like you've earned your spot on the continuum~
 
O

OC Kid

Guest
Ok now I have a question, along the lines of this thread.
I was orginally ranked in a Japanese system. But shortly after that I moved 3 states away. I started traning in kempo (epak and tracys at the same time) not necessarily to get a rank but I loved the training and I liked to fight tournments and kickboxing. I also attended the basics classes and learned the basics. but I never really learned the forms ect. I always belonged to the japanese association.

So now Im teaching M/A, I use the japanese basics along with the kempo and the japanese forms, my self defense is based on kempo but no set techniques but simular movements ( I really like the power and focus of them) and due to changes in the japanese association, My instructor and the master retireing along with a lot of the guys I came up through the ranks with and the new master of the system I dont really care for ( call it a lack of respect for him) and so basically there all new people who I dont really know and I dont live near them Im 3 states away. I joined a loose association made of people of different arts who are local and have recongnized me and I have trained with in one of the kempo schools so they know me and my ability.

So am I developing my own art?

Am I dissing my Instructor?

Is this system Im teaching considered MMA (I also incorporate Muay Thai training)?

Is my linage in tack meaning would I be considered a legitimate school because I broke away but I can trace my history to my instructors ?

Though rather than calling it after the "japanese system name or OC Kids kempo" Im choosing to call it Christian Martial Arts Academy something to that effect. Would I be considered a Mc Dojo if I opened up my own school?

just curious.
 

Michael Billings

Senior Master
MTS Alumni
Joined
Apr 5, 2002
Messages
3,962
Reaction score
31
Location
Austin, Texas USA-Terra
Definitly NOT a McDojo based on what you teach. That is more a business model based on maximizing, to the point of using and abusing your students, while the product being turned out is not so good. (my definition only)

The rest is up to you. The name has nothing to do with it, it sounds like you are giving credit to your instructors ... that is good. It is OK to disaffiliate due to whatever reason, with an association, that does not mean you are creating your own ART, you can even start your own organization without claiming to be founding a "new system".

So long as you are honest in your approach, credit the Kenpo with being Kenpo, distinguish the Kickboxing as coming from Muay Thai, etc., there is no dishonesty in terms of what you are offering, so it depends on how you package and market yourself, and you have just told us what you are doing. You may be combining things from Japanese, Thai, American or Chinese Kenpo ... but to me, this does not make a new system. Rather you are offering your students the opportunity to train with an instructor who is well rounded in several Arts. That is more honest than saying "I created THIS ... and THIS IS GOOD!".

I teach Kenpo, but that does not mean I do not teach some kickboxing drills on the bag, or some lock-flow from Larry Hartsel, or some pressure point application from SL-4 or Shen Chuan. I still am a Kenpo-Man and everything else stems from that base, or is part of Kenpo that I had just not been exposed to. I learn something at a seminar I had never seen as part of Kenpo, and was pressure point or akijitsu related, then I hear Mr. Sepulveda talk about Mr. Parker trying the same thing on him.

Keep it honest, keep it real and give credit where credit is due.
-Michael
 

pete

Master Black Belt
Joined
Aug 31, 2003
Messages
1,003
Reaction score
32
Location
Long Island, New York
So now Im teaching M/A, I use the japanese basics along with the kempo and the japanese forms, my self defense is based on kempo but no set techniques but simular movements -OC Kid

EP would be proud... its sunds just like what he did~
 

Brother John

Senior Master
Joined
Jan 13, 2002
Messages
2,530
Reaction score
59
Location
Wichita Kansas, USA
Goldendragon7 said:
To place themselves on the same level as these proven Individuals is just plain wrong. Give credit where credit is due, at least say that this is your "version" of a system based upon XYZ's work.

[/size][/font]

After thinking about it, I'd say that this is the central issue in my eyes.
I'd have to think that anyone who didn't give credit to their instructor(s) for what was given to them would pretty much be schmucks with a real character deficit.

As Mr. Mills wrote in the AKKI yellow belt manual, "When you drink the water, remember the spring from which it came."
When I think of the veneration with which Mr. Mills speaks of his own instructor and mentor, it humbles me. I'd bet he'd agree with you as well.

Your Brother
John
 

Old Fat Kenpoka

Master Black Belt
Joined
May 20, 2003
Messages
1,045
Reaction score
39
Location
Silicon Valley, CA
I would like to take this opportunity to announce that I have created my own art: It is called To-Fu. It contains absolutely no meat. ;)
 
J

jeffkyle

Guest
Old Fat Kenpoka said:
I would like to take this opportunity to announce that I have created my own art: It is called To-Fu. It contains absolutely no meat. ;)

Would that be vegetable MA? Or vegatarian MA?
 
O

OC Kid

Guest
Michael Billings said:
Definitly NOT a McDojo based on what you teach. That is more a business model based on maximizing, to the point of using and abusing your students, while the product being turned out is not so good. (my definition only)

The rest is up to you. The name has nothing to do with it, it sounds like you are giving credit to your instructors ... that is good. It is OK to disaffiliate due to whatever reason, with an association, that does not mean you are creating your own ART, you can even start your own organization without claiming to be founding a "new system".

So long as you are honest in your approach, credit the Kenpo with being Kenpo, distinguish the Kickboxing as coming from Muay Thai, etc., there is no dishonesty in terms of what you are offering, so it depends on how you package and market yourself, and you have just told us what you are doing. You may be combining things from Japanese, Thai, American or Chinese Kenpo ... but to me, this does not make a new system. Rather you are offering your students the opportunity to train with an instructor who is well rounded in several Arts. That is more honest than saying "I created THIS ... and THIS IS GOOD!".

I teach Kenpo, but that does not mean I do not teach some kickboxing drills on the bag, or some lock-flow from Larry Hartsel, or some pressure point application from SL-4 or Shen Chuan. I still am a Kenpo-Man and everything else stems from that base, or is part of Kenpo that I had just not been exposed to. I learn something at a seminar I had never seen as part of Kenpo, and was pressure point or akijitsu related, then I hear Mr. Sepulveda talk about Mr. Parker trying the same thing on him.

Keep it honest, keep it real and give credit where credit is due.
-Michael
Thank you Mike and Thank you also Pete. That is kind of what I was thinking. But I needed to hear a unbiased opinion. I was told the same thing from M/A freinds but its nice to get it reinforced here.
 

Kembudo-Kai Kempoka

Senior Master
Joined
Mar 9, 2004
Messages
2,228
Reaction score
113
Location
Dana Point, CA
OC Kid said:
Thank you Mike and Thank you also Pete. That is kind of what I was thinking. But I needed to hear a unbiased opinion. I was told the same thing from M/A freinds but its nice to get it reinforced here.
I like the premise...you may want to research the name, particularly in your demographic region. I remember a CMAA offering association memberships in the back of Black Belt, like, 20 years ago? Also, in your area, there have been a couple of christian kenpoka who have started AK or MMA training centers. Dave Poole (sp?) started one out of Calvary way back, and Chris Romero also did a bit later. Don't know the extent to which they're still active, but I'd bet a dime and a donut Mr. White does. Anyways, it's worth the asking.

Regards,

Dr. Dave
 
O

OC Kid

Guest
Yea I know Chris very well He started the Thunder Center. It was a very good place for training. He was a very good instructor. He is now doing BJJ and has for quite a while. I think Dave is still teaching at Calvary in Costa Mesa. I also trained with Mr White. I will stop by his school this Sat. I still work out with him on the weekends. Right now however Im starting a summer program at the local community center for disadvantaged children. It will be a while before I get this thing going and it will be out of State. probably Washington St.
 

Latest Discussions

Top