EARL WEISS SAID: ↑ Are you arguing that courtesy nd respect are the same? Well therein we have a disagreement on how terms are defined / applied...
So, you are comparing what General Choi consistently taught with what someone else says he thinks General Choi taught - got it. You base your...
From your post 421 "I hope you listen very carefully to how he completely disrepects the KKW and thus violates his own principles of respect."...
Sir, so, support for your claim your claim is your belief that somewhere in some book someone said that someone said something. Got it....
What you said at post 408 was: "General Choi at one point reportedly did a 180 and claimed that Karate is a Taekkyon derivative." I...
Clearly - Again, you misunderstand. Try again. Volume 3 contains Hand techniques. Attack principles are the first General section followed...
Refutes your claim of General Choi saying Taekyon came from Karate and citing "A Killing Art" being a source to support your claim in that it...
Except that is not even close to what I said. Classic example of "False equivalency".
Please point me to where he specifies his own principle of "respect" or are you confusing it with "Courtesy"
Actually in the book at page 42 (1st Edition) Gillis references Pres. Rhee after seeing the demo and being told "it is Tang Soo Do" Pres. Rhee...
This has exactly what to do on your claim that he changed what he said when he taught the hip twist / turn / jerk for punches. Anytime you want...
A. Not a problem, since this is what he taught consistently. B. Hard to imagine how you can misinterpret and claim "Attack techniques need to...
Approximate page please. I have the book, I will check it out - Plus, I wrote Mr. Gillis and pointed out several things he got wrong.
Sir, link to source for this claim please.
It would seem Contact point is different and Chang Hon Crescent only goes from shoulder toward center line but there is another difference and as...
Sir, you know this how? How many classroom hours did you spend with General Choi? Did you take notes on what he said? Did you highlight...
Sir, To the contrary. If he is not a Chang Hon person (he may be) and he sees that punches are attacks and you do not see the connection, the...
Sir, really? You said it was my problem to solve vis a vis differences in Hand techniques between patterns and sparring drills. I don't see a...
↑ "Crescent Kick" Please define. Chang Hon? KKW? Based upon the above posts it would seem not. Chang Hon is used for Blocking with the sole of...
Sir, 1. Perhaps "Distinct" is the wrong word. I would say they have common principles. 2. Not a problem at all, since I never viewed everything...
Sir, everyone has a right to an opinion - even erroneous ones.
Sir, not unique at all . Mitt punching is a free sparring exercise. ITF competitors do not punch in sparring as they do in patterns. Or do you...
Sir, I see your confusion now. . What I said and as you quoted "Once again you misstate what I said. I never claimed he "Created" something- only...
Sir, Again, you misstate my position. I have ignored nothing . You mistakenly claim the general principles stated for attacks are not part of...
Surprised no one posted this. You can skip to the 45 second mark. [MEDIA]
Perhaps Mr. Weiss? Sir, the Chang Hon "Pick Shape kick" did not exist as such until the 1983 Encyclopedia. Even then just seeing it on a page...
thought perhaps Acronym would like this photo pictured along with General Cho are 2 of the people he posted videos of.
Once again you misstate what I said. I never claimed he "Created" something- only what he applies. General Choi himself clearly states that...
Sir, Since I have no idea what he's doing other than what you state and it seems there are some definite perception and terminology issues I would...
Sir, last I checked "Punching" was part of Attack techniques. How can you claim something specified for attacks would not be part of punching?
Separate names with a comma.
