Okinawian Kempo, Shaolin Kenpo, American Kenpo

[phlaw]

Hello, I would like some info please. I would love to train in American Kenpo, but there are currently no schools in the area. I do have Okinawian Kempo and Shaolin Kenpo available to me. I am wondering which would be closer to American Kenpo?

Through some basic web searches I am guessing Shaolin Kenpo, but I am hoping to hear from people who have trained in each?

Thanks

[Blindside]

Just get the best instructor regardless of style. If you ever do go on and learn AK you'll have to start over anyway.

That probably isn't the answer you are looking for, but nothing beats a good instructor.

Lamont

[Carol]

Agree with what Blindside said. Find the best teacher.

The technique structure that you would learn in Shaolin Kempo is likely more similar to American Kenpo. However the mechanics of the Okinawan styles may make for an easier future transition to American Kenpo.

[Hand Sword]

If it is real Okinawan kempo, meaning taught the same way as it is in Okinawa, by a good instructor, go with that style.

[marlon]

I have a bias for shaolin kempo but as others have mentioned the instructor can make all the difference. Equally important is what you are looking to get out of a style. Why do you want to start a martial art and what are you looking to gain from it? these questions can help tremendously in picking a style...anbd even an instructor. Also, visit the school and pay attention to the higher belts. How they act with each other and the lower ranks, how the speak of thier style and other styles is a veryt good indicator of who thier teacher is in terms of character.

respectfully,
Marlon

[arnisador]

Originally Posted by Carol Kaur

The technique structure that you would learn in Shaolin Kempo is likely more similar to American Kenpo. However the mechanics of the Okinawan styles may make for an easier future transition to American Kenpo.

I agree with this, though I'd emphasize that the three arts are dissimilar and Okinawan (i.e., Ryukyu) Kempo is essentially unrelated to the other two. Shaolin Kempo may or may not be related to American Kenpo depending on which Shaolin Kempo is meant: Shorinji Kempo is quite different, but the arts of Fred Villari and Ralph Castro bear a closer (though not necessarily admitted) relationship to American Kenpo (see here, to be taken with a grain of salt).

To me, Okinawan Kempo is an easy call here, all other things being equal. It's an excellent art. But as stated, the instructor makes a much bigger difference than the art.

[kidswarrior]

Originally Posted by arnisador

To me, Okinawan Kempo is an easy call here, all other things being equal. It's an excellent art. But as stated, the instructor makes a much bigger difference than the art.

Agreed. Even though my training is Shaolin Kempo.

[LawDog]

Instructors who strive for excellence and have the knowledge needed to do so will make the difference.

[phlaw]

Asking around I am not too impressed with what I have heard of the Okinawian Kempo instructor. The Shaolin Kenpo instructor is of the Castro lineage.


Thanks

[John Bishop]

Originally Posted by phlaw

The Shaolin Kenpo instructor is of the Castro lineage.


Thanks

That would be something worth looking into to. There's usually some pretty solid people from that lineage.

[LocknBlock]

Well about the Castro lineage, one might have to do more research,cause they were more known for their 'katas' then their fighting. a friend from Hawaii recommended a man named Bill Chun Jr. who actually trained with Prof. Chow and finished his training, you see he lived at his house to train on a continuous basis( at night with no lights) this developes one's sensitivity where you feel the attack rather then see it, when you see him teach you know that it is more combat oriented then what is seen at most 'tournaments'. My friend had a long conversation with him at a recent 'Kajukenbo' luau in California and his cousin's step-dad is Bobby Lowe. I am from Hawaii born in the 50's, grew up in the 60's, so guys like my friend, Bill Chun Jr. and myself grew up seeing the real deal, heck I took Judo at Palama Settlement, heck there were real escrima matches in Hawaii where the loser went home hurt, their were real underground kumite like 'Bloodsport' or like human 'cockfights', rural Hawaii in the 50's and 60's was little bit like Philippines is now a mixture of the old and the new. Make sure before you start training that you actually check out the instructor's lineage because many are in it for the money and the glory but are not really that good. So check out everything you can before you train !! Remember your gi or belt will not do the fighting it will be you that will be fighting if you ever get in a situation where you have to truly defend yourself, so get as much of the realistic training as possible. Aloha

[John Bishop]

Good advice. But the big problem with that is, Bill Chun Jr. lives in No. Calif, and phlaw lives in Fargo, No. Dakota. There's probably not a lot of old time Hawaiian stylists in Fargo.

[Karatedrifter7]

Is Okinawan Kenpo another name for Shorin Ryu? I thought I read that somwhere. Or is it a different style altogether from it?

[John Bishop]

Originally Posted by Karatedrifter7

Is Okinawan Kenpo another name for Shorin Ryu? I thought I read that somwhere. Or is it a different style altogether from it?

Just about any Okinawan karate style can be called "Kempo". To the Okinawan's, "Kempo" just meant the systems roots came from China. Goju Ryu, Shorin Ryu, Shorei Ryu, have all been referred to as "Kempo" in the past.

[Danjo]

If it says, Shaolin KeMpo, be very very careful. Most of it isn't worth training in IMO. I understand that there are exceptions to this, but you need to really check them out and watch the prices.