View Full Version : Place of Sanchin


punisher73
05-07-2008, 03:31 PM
For those of you that practice Sanchin kata, I was curious as to where you style places it.

I have heard that Sanchin is the root of Okinawan Karate and is the foundation of all other katas, so it is the first one learned.

I have also heard that Sanchin will slow a student down if it is introduced to early, and therefore is the last kata learned.

If your style does practice it, what style and where in the order does it lie?

Also, I would be interested to hear if your style does not incorporate Sanchin, have you done so for your own study (either sanchin or even something similiar like "iron thread" from Hung Gar).

tshadowchaser
05-07-2008, 08:26 PM
Sanchin was the 2nd form I learned in my system.
I useualy teach it to students with in the first 6 months of training

If nothing else Sanchin would be the one thing they would be tested on each and every test

now consider that I teach a FMA but my instructors first roots where Okinawan and the forms he learned where also passed on to us

Live True
05-08-2008, 10:55 AM
I study Uechi Ryu, an Okinawan form, and this is the first and most important kata. As we learn, "all is within sanchin". For me, at my begginer's stage, this kata teaches rootedness, body coherence, muscle hardening and muscle looseness in movement, and more. It is part of every belt test, from white to black, with nuances determined at each level. I started learning this kata on day one of my training, and it will be part of my first belt test at the end of this month.

I am finding that it creates a moving meditation for me, and helps me center and focus. Recently, because of my pregnancy, my sensei has started to teach me a Goju Ryu version of sanchin, because the difference in breathing and movements may be beneficial.

I'm excited to see what different versions of sanchin will bring to my practice.

Never_A_Reflection
05-08-2008, 07:56 PM
My style teaches Sanchin roughly in the middle--you need to learn it for your brown belt (san-kyu). There are variations on the kata as you progress, but the basic Sanchin kata is taught at yon-kyu. We have found that if you teach it too early, it can be too technical and difficult for the student to stick with it, and it can take a very long time to understand the techniques, breathing, and tension. By the same token, if you learn it too late, it will take you a very long time to gain the benefits of practicing the kata, because you may attempt to perform it the way you have been practicing other kata all this time.

D Dempsey
05-09-2008, 04:12 AM
When I was doing Gojuryu, it was the second kata I learned after Saifa. We did Sanchin multiple times every class with out fail followed by Tensho.

Zero
05-11-2008, 06:09 PM
Like D Dempsy our club pick up the study and practice of Sanchin as the fourth kata, coming after Saifa. I find this is probably the most technically challenging of kata, even harder to appreciate all aspects and master than Suparinpei. In the 'hierachy' of kata, as I said Sanchin comes 4th, but my club is quite open minded in its applications and training and this is often made accessable to junior karateka just starting out. As a foundation point for goju the sooner one starts off with this the better - although I do take the comments that without proper explanation and guidance it could be totally misinterpreted and possibly detrimental to a student's understanding of movement.

shoshinkan
05-14-2008, 02:48 PM
Historically (I beleive) sanchin is the fundamental form of the Shorei Ryu (ie Goju/Uechi Ryu) systems.

I train shorin ryu and therefore do not teach sanchin as part of the standard kata at the dojo, however I do train sanchin (a really personal version) myself as an exploritory vehicle working white crane methods.

It may be something I pass on to students but that would happen after shodan, I like them to focus on the core shorin kata (Pinan Sho/Ni, Naihanchi Sho/Ni and Passai) at least till then.

Sanchin certainly represents the foundation of the majority of Southern Chinese arts IMO.

Dr Rubin Frank Rhode
05-21-2008, 08:18 PM
Hi Fellow Martial Artists,
I practice Goju Ryu Karate-Do, we practise Sanchin and Tensho after learning the Taikyoku and Gekisai Kata (i.e. the preparatory forms). In some of our Dojos the Saifa Kata is introduced before the Sanchin Kata. Tensho and Seinchin are taught after this. As we adavnce in our practice Sanchin becomes more important, as we sometimes use this as a testing and body conditioning training.Later we learn the Bunkai or application of these Kata (Sanchin and Tensho) in our training. For me the Kata is a personal training and challenge to work hard at perefecting my Karate. I am so grateful for my Teacher Eddie Cave, Sensei 9th Dan who is such a compassionate and hard-task Master Kata Teacher. We are corrected every time we have the opportunity to train with him (ven though we are 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th Dans). Thank you so much for your posting on Sanchin.

Yours in the Spirit of Budo/Wushu

Dr Rubin Frank Rhode, Sensei (Godan)

twendkata71
05-24-2008, 08:00 PM
We teach it after the fukyu's, Pinans and naihanchi's The style we teach is similar to Shito ryu, It comes from the Koei kan. Which is a combination of the shuri te and Naha te.

chinto01
05-25-2008, 10:20 AM
I pose this question to people who practice sanchin on a regular basis (several times a class or a week). How much power do you use when doing the form? The reason I ask is that there are rumors that if you do this form at full power over a long period of time that it could have some adverse health conditions in the loing run (hemeroids and some stomach issues, even high blood pressure). I know it seems crazy but just wondering if you had heard this as well.

In the spirit of bushido!

Rob

Victor Smith
05-26-2008, 05:02 PM
As an Isshinryu stylist Sanchin is the last kata taught before sho-dan examination. The Isshinryu Sanchin is the Miyagi Sanchin, not the Hiagonna Sanchin.

I only teach it full speed with normal breathing. The only purpose for it's practice is to use it to take any sort of attack apart.

I also teach the Uechin Sanchin to my black belts, for a study in the essence of Uechi attack.

chinto
05-29-2008, 07:17 AM
For those of you that practice Sanchin kata, I was curious as to where you style places it.

I have heard that Sanchin is the root of Okinawan Karate and is the foundation of all other katas, so it is the first one learned.

I have also heard that Sanchin will slow a student down if it is introduced to early, and therefore is the last kata learned.

If your style does practice it, what style and where in the order does it lie?

Also, I would be interested to hear if your style does not incorporate Sanchin, have you done so for your own study (either sanchin or even something similiar like "iron thread" from Hung Gar).

we are a Shorin ryu system but do teach sanchin and seichin kata at brown belt level.

Live True
05-29-2008, 05:41 PM
I pose this question to people who practice sanchin on a regular basis (several times a class or a week). How much power do you use when doing the form? The reason I ask is that there are rumors that if you do this form at full power over a long period of time that it could have some adverse health conditions in the loing run (hemeroids and some stomach issues, even high blood pressure). I know it seems crazy but just wondering if you had heard this as well.

Rob,
Most of what I have found on injuries related to sanchin involves a particular type of breathing. Different schools teach variations on the breathing technique for Sanchin. In most injury type scenarios, the faulty breathing technique involved a bit of a Valsalva breathe (holding your breathe and bearing down while in the most strenous parts of the movement). There is some arguement over whether this is the correct type of breathing (as originally practices in Okinawa) and if the related health issues you mentioned were caused by this breathing or by other environmental factors (nutrition, etc.) of the old masters.

For our part, my club practices a combination of dragon breathing and "dolphin" breathing (continual light breaths that do not mirror the movements and maintain a constant slight inflation of lungs/core). The breaths are not supposed to match the movements, as that makes your movements more predictive. Not all schools agree with this type of breathing or the logic behind it.

My recent reading notes that Uechi Kanei would encourage students to breathe as comes naturally and also to practice Sanchin at various speeds for each practice (slow and relaxed, slow and focus, strongly/focused/fast).

That is one viewpoint, and I hope it helps.

jim777
05-30-2008, 10:49 AM
We start it after the taikyoku's and in house katas, at 6th kyu.

jim

Cirdan
06-02-2008, 07:36 AM
Sanchin is part of the 1.Dan curriculum at our Wado school. I am not sure if other practicioners of Wado use Sanchin much, but the chinese influence on Karate plays an importent role in the higher levels for us.

Jai
06-02-2008, 11:12 AM
We do not teach it as part of our system, and I really wish we did. There has been talk of allowing our black belts to study it as a "bonus" kata of sorts.

jkembry
06-04-2008, 03:49 PM
For my style, Uechi-ryu, Sanchin is the kata that is tested at every rank, and to me is the one that provides continuity to the art. My Sensei says "all is in Sanchin", which to me means a consolidation of breathing, strength and posture. Being new at this, I don't think I have ever done this correctly all the way through, but I can say that at times the bits and pieces that I do that are correct, I can feel it. I can also feel when it isn't correct.

Some elements are in other kata such as Kanshiwa and Kanshu. I practice Sanchin at home and mentally in my head during my commute to and from work and find that it seems to get me ready for the day.

While all kata are important in their own way, Sanchin holds a special importance for me.

- Jeff -

Tae Kwon Dave
06-25-2008, 04:52 AM
Hy guys!!!
It's possible to find pictures (diagrams, photos) of sanchin no kata?
Thanks a lot!

jkembry
06-25-2008, 09:41 AM
Search for "Sanchin Kata" on You will see a variety of styles presented.

TimoS
06-25-2008, 10:56 AM
Also, I would be interested to hear if your style does not incorporate Sanchin, have you done so for your own study (either sanchin or even something similiar like "iron thread" from Hung Gar).

Our style doesn't have Sanchin in it and while it might be interesting to learn it, I think that there's already so much stuff to learn in the kata that Seibukan has (5 Pinan, 3 Naifanchi, 2 Fukyu, Seisan, Ananku, Wansu, Passai, Gojushiho, Wanchin, Chinto, Kushanku and Passai-gwa plus Tokumine-no-kon) and especially learning how to really use what in those that I really don't even miss it.
For us I guess the nearest equivalent might be Seisan. It teaches the basics and it is also a good exercise.

tshadowchaser
06-25-2008, 11:53 AM
Yes from tha list Seisan would come the closest, and it is a good kata to practice

Tae Kwon Dave
06-26-2008, 09:50 AM
Our style doesn't have Sanchin in it and while it might be interesting to learn it, I think that there's already so much stuff to learn in the kata that Seibukan has (5 Pinan, 3 Naifanchi, 2 Fukyu, Seisan, Ananku, Wansu, Passai, Gojushiho, Wanchin, Chinto, Kushanku and Passai-gwa plus Tokumine-no-kon) and especially learning how to really use what in those that I really don't even miss it.
For us I guess the nearest equivalent might be Seisan. It teaches the basics and it is also a good exercise.

Yeah, i think so too...
I study korean karate hyungs (my school is Mudokwan - Tae Kwon Do Korean Karate), the same of japanese shotokan, as you know...but i like to practice them with the canons of J.K.A.
I studied Sanchin no kata as Kyokushin Karate praticioner (i'm 3th kyu)...but Seishan/Hangetsu (Banwol in my school) is a very good alternative.

wolfeyes2323
06-26-2008, 10:22 AM
Greetings – I am a practitioner of Okinawan Karate and kobudo,
In Isshin-ryu I was taught that Sanchin is the father, and naihanchi the mother ,
In Goju-ryu I was taught that Sanchin is complemented by Tensho .

Sanchin is the First kata I teach, it is taught after warm-up, and
Is used to establish the breath cycle , focus the mind ,
Invigorate the body, and draw the spirit out .

The second kata I teach is Naihanchi, This is our Shorin-ryu Root,
It embodies the opposite energies , uses snapping and relaxation,
(yin quality) .

Together these kata, form heaven and earth , Man is in the middle.

According to Chojun Miyagi , founder of Goju-ryu
Sanchin , Naihanchi and tensho are a separate class of kata,
They are Kihon, and distinct from all other forms.

These kata in my dojo are preparatory kihon,
They are often repeated later, or if we take a break for water ,
(class has been averaging about 3 hr lately) when we come
Back we perform them once again to focus our minds and
Extablish our breathing.

Toward the end of class we perform Tensho, which I was taught is our
Reward for training hard.

I do not Shime test my students via Sanchin until brown belt, and
Of course I believe it is a mandatory requirement durning a sho-dan test,

IMO it takes a long time to perform Sanchin correctly , and this is why I
Teach it first , I was not taught Sanchin until much later, and
I underwent Shime testing for which I had not had adequate training
For, I think it is a mistake to wait to begin sanchin, students need
The time to grow into it , and become comfortable with it ,
To come to understand it. It is like visiting a Art museum,
You can not fully appreciate each painting (movement) until
You have spent some time observing it , You
Can not fully appreciate a symphony without many listening,
You can not understand or appreciate Sanchin without much practice .

The sooner you start the better, the Quiz or test however will not
Be at the end of class, it will be years in the future, and with
Diligent practice , you will be well prepared and capable of acing it : )

Romney^..^

wolfeyes2323
06-27-2008, 12:12 PM
This summer Liu Ching I will be visiting my dojo to teach,
The feeding crane system he teaches also has a Sanchin
Kata, see:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cU5CEfDLHPI
(this video is mislabeled , should be Feeding Crane )

This is quite different than the Goju-ryu or Isshin-ryu version,
But listen to the breathing.

Should be interesting, training with Mr Liu and Kimo Wall
Sensei of Kodokan Goju-ryu Matayoshi Kobudo .

More info and video can be seen at
http://www.kimowall.netfirms.com/liutourposter.htm

This version of sanchin, is actually much more fluid than
Those mentioned above and closer to the Uechi-ryu version
In this regard.
See:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XeHbH8x_Zfo
for Kanei Uechi Uechi ryu version

see:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IKvHB6hB5pY&feature=related
for Tatsuo Shimabuku Isshin-ryu version

see:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7nhPx3qurM8
for Goju-ryu version with testing.

Also see
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yla9j0AangU
for related 5 ancestor fist

this is only a sample , Sanchin is a very widely
practiced form in southern Chinese systems,
as well as Okinawan karate, I think where
you teach it depends on your understanding
of what is essential. IMO in karate we
learn what is essential first, and then
take years to perfect it. There is nothing
In karate that is simple or easy, so you
start with what is the most important,
Hence in My Dojo Sanchin.
Romney^..^