What is the best fighting style???? [Archive] - MartialTalk.Com

AdrenalineJunky

12-18-2005, 05:15 PM

Hey everyone,

Well I was wondering, what the best type of fighting, as far as martial arts goes. I'm a begginer so can someone please tell me. Thanks all:)

Uh-oh. The one you can afford and enjoy. In a fight, cell-phone-911-fu-kwon-jutsu is the best MA. ;) What's available where you are?

Grenadier

12-18-2005, 05:32 PM

Assuming we're talking about an established style of martial arts, whether it's old or new, there really isn't a "best" fighting style. A lot of what may be better for you depends on how you are built, what your preferences are, etc. It may help if you give us a bit of background on yourself.

For example, if you're a 7' tall lanky fellow with stiff joints, having you do Jiu-Jitsu might not be the optimal choice.

If you have horrible leg flexibility, then something like Tae Kwon Do might not be good for you at all.

When it comes down to it, you really need to take a look at what's in your area. Pay close attention to the classes, and the instructors. Are they making the learning material reasonable? Are they patient? Do they take the time to help out each person as each one needs it?

Look at the students. Are they well-disciplined? Are they of strong character in addition to being good martial artists? Or are they nothing more than undisciplined thugs?

Good martial arts taught by good instructors is always going to be good martial arts, regardless of the style, and that's what you should look for when you begin your search.

arnisador

12-18-2005, 05:32 PM

It depends on many, many things...are we talking against weapons, with weapons, against groups, ...? What are your attributes? Beyond that, how you train makes the most difference.

tshadowchaser

12-18-2005, 06:03 PM

The one you can do best and helps you survive

TheBattousai

12-18-2005, 08:43 PM

As everyone has been saying, mainly choosing one that works best for you is all you can really do. You could venture towards throwing arts, striking arts (hands and feet), joint locks, weapons, and just any combination of the two or three or whatever. I suggest finding materials on the ones that interest you (books, videos, pics, etc.) and practice them to see which you like better.

Clint Strickland

12-19-2005, 12:09 PM

Well my attributes are..... Strong legs. Strong arms. Pre- flexible. What should I study??

Eric Daniel

12-19-2005, 12:12 PM

Hey everyone,

Well I was wondering, what the best type of fighting, as far as martial arts goes. I'm a begginer so can someone please tell me. Thanks all:)
There is no best fighting system out there. All of them have something different to share with you and help you improve yourself as a martial artsit.

mrhnau

12-19-2005, 12:26 PM

I second alot of the opinions stated here. Alot of things need to be considered.

How close is the school? willing to drive 1 hour one way for lessons 5 days a week?
How expensive is the school? Want to pay $25/month to learn boxing or would $100+/month for some excellant kung-fu be ok?
Willing to cross-train?
Looking for competition, or just knowledge?
Want to spar or just practice?
Wanting something more aggressive or more passive? external vs internal? More muscle or technique oriented?
How much time do you want to dedicate? If school teaches only 2 days a week, that ok?

Navarre

12-19-2005, 12:30 PM

Clint, if you could answer Mrhnau's questions for us we might be able to offer some suggestions. There's a lot to choose from overall but it will be limited by what's available to you.

arnisador

12-19-2005, 12:38 PM

Well my attributes are..... Strong legs. Strong arms. Pre- flexible. What should I study??

What's available where you are? If you want to take advantage of that strength, maybe grappling or (kick)boxing or mixed martial arts (MMA). But, what you've written rules out none of the arts, to my mind.

Toasty

12-19-2005, 02:54 PM

It depends on many, many things...are we talking against weapons, with weapons, against groups, ...? What are your attributes? Beyond that, how you train makes the most difference.

Againt Groups?
What style/system would that be?

arnisador

12-19-2005, 03:35 PM

No style is going to be really effective in that case, but if that's the person's concern, I'd recommend Aikido over BJJ, for example.

Sayoc Kali practices fighting groups-against-groups.

Flying Crane

12-19-2005, 03:41 PM

If there was a single, objective "best" style, then it would be the only style and we would all be doing it and no other.

There is no best style, only the style that is best for you, or that you like the best, or works the best for you, or even may not be the best for you but is the best one available in your area and you are able to get it to work well enough.

You could get as many different answers as there are people on the forum. Check out what is available near you, try some classes, and go with what you like the most.

still learning

12-19-2005, 10:48 PM

Hello, For a beginner you will find "JUDO" is a good place to start learning the martial arts. One needs to know how to fall first.

Not sport judo, but actully judo classes. You will find this art saying it is defense......buy it is actully very offense and anyone can learn the throws. My son is taking sport judo for high school and it does go with the Kempo training he is also doing now for 8 years. (the throws can be done hard or soft or mean)

Read the book "Verbal Judo". Many people die every year because of their EGO"S and Pride. Best to always avoid. Awareness is one of the most important things to learn in life. Than one learns it is not neccessary to use any fighting arts.

The martial arts builds confidence in one self ,if one needs to protect himself or others.

Check out any JUDO schools and you may find it worth trying.......just my thoughts on this...........................Aloha

mantis

12-19-2005, 11:00 PM

Hey everyone,

Well I was wondering, what the best type of fighting, as far as martial arts goes. I'm a begginer so can someone please tell me. Thanks all:)
i think my style is the best
a lot would agree with me

thank you very much

note: jk

Cujo

12-20-2005, 12:19 AM

Hi. I would first ask yourself why you want to study the martial arts? Is it for competition, for health and fitness, or self defense, or a mix of all of the above? You will find that many schools will have a particular focus on one of the areas listed above and you should choose a school that will most closely match your own goals.

Pax
Cujo

Clint Strickland

12-20-2005, 03:44 PM

arnisador

12-20-2005, 03:54 PM

It's probably best if you list what's nearby.

Ceicei

12-20-2005, 03:55 PM

Let me restate my question. What is youre favorite type of fighting style, so I can look into it and see if I'm interested in it. Well the nearest class is about 14 min away, but its round 250 dollars a month. I'm not going to go there for the simple fact that it cost way to much. I'm looking for something to push me to the upmost limit, and to tech me both at the same time. If I was to find a class pretty close to me and the lessons were only 2 a week, I would still love to join, knoweledge has no sceduale. Well if anyone has any suggestion to what style I should do please inform me, you will be much appreciated by me. Thanks all.

You are asking a very tough question. I would suggest that you go into different schools and try out a class or two. Most will allow you to try, either for free or at a minimal cost. Some will allow you to sit in to watch. That would be the only way you can check out to see what catches your interest. Pay attention to how instructors teach. It might be a marvelous style, but the quality of the instructor(s) will make/break the experience for you.

What sort of martial arts schools are available near you? If you could let us know what is there in your area, then we could give you some of our own reasons/opinions why we like these styles. Be aware, however, that our reasons may differ from yours as each of us are on our own journey.

- Ceicei

Clint Strickland

12-20-2005, 06:11 PM

You are asking a very tough question. I would suggest that you go into different schools and try out a class or two. Most will allow you to try, either for free or at a minimal cost. Some will allow you to sit in to watch. That would be the only way you can check out to see what catches your interest. Pay attention to how instructors teach. It might be a marvelous style, but the quality of the instructor(s) will make/break the experience for you.

What sort of martial arts schools are available near you? If you could let us know what is there in your area, then we could give you some of our own reasons/opinions why we like these styles. Be aware, however, that our reasons may differ from yours as each of us are on our own journey.

- Ceicei

The only one is Karate, but I personaly like JU-JItzu the brazilian kind.

DeLamar.J

12-23-2005, 12:13 AM

Ok, I normally will not answer a question like this but Im going to go ahead and do it. I think that the best style out there is Chinese Shuai Chiao. I realize that there really is no BEST style, but if I had to give an answer, that would be my opinion.

green meanie

12-23-2005, 07:19 AM

Flatlander

12-23-2005, 12:15 PM

Clint, I have a couple of thoughts for you here.

As it seems that you are uncertain about with which art you want to apply your efforts, I encourage you to stay away from any contracts that schools might offer. It seems to me that you aren't really in a position to make a long term commitment. In fact, I echo what's been said already - check out a few different schools and see what feels best.

Also, you mention that you like Brazilian Jiu Jutsu. Why is that? What do you know of BJJ? What about this art appeals to you? Either way, if you really feel a predilection for this art, then by all means, go and check it out!

The most important point here is that it doesn't really matter what art you study. What matters is that you learn it from a qualified instructor that will commit themselves to your training and improvement, and that you commit yourself equally. If this happens, you will find success and experience the development of your skills and abilities.

Keep us updated as to your decisions and progress, Clint. The journey that you take here may help others who are on the same path, later on.

Flatlander

12-23-2005, 12:18 PM

My favourite style? Modern Arnis.

DeLamar.J

12-23-2005, 02:06 PM

Why? (If you don't mind my asking that is.) :)This is just my opinion because of what I have seen, ok?

The reason why I feel that shuai Chiao is best, is because I have seen some students of this art beat other students of so many other arts that I cannot even remember the number. And I must stress, the teacher, Grand Master Gene Chicoine. Anyone who is awarded a black belt under this man has earned that right by any standard. IMO he is the best in the WORLD. His dojo has had an open challenge policy for over 20 years and no one has ever defeated him. He was Grand Master Tung Sheng Chang's top student, who was china's last undefeated champion in no holds barred fighting.
This is just my personal opinion.

green meanie

12-23-2005, 09:55 PM

This is just my opinion because of what I have seen, ok?

The reason why I feel that shuai Chiao is best, is because I have seen some students of this art beat other students of so many other arts that I cannot even remember the number. And I must stress, the teacher, Grand Master Gene Chicoine. Anyone who is awarded a black belt under this man has earned that right by any standard. IMO he is the best in the WORLD. His dojo has had an open challenge policy for over 20 years and no one has ever defeated him. He was Grand Master Tung Sheng Chang's top student, who was china's last undefeated champion in no holds barred fighting.
This is just my personal opinion.

Ok. I was just curious. Thanks for the info. :)
Where is his school located? It sounds like something definately worth checking out.

Fluffy

12-28-2005, 09:54 PM

IMNSHO

There is no best MA. And if anyone tells you there is they are being less than truthfull. I'm a TKD guy, and if you were to call me up I'd sell you on taking it, I will not do that here. Let me make a suggestion, there is a book that I have read called "Living the Martial Way" by; Maj. Forrest E. Morgan USAF Ret. He covers this exact subject in the first few chapters of that masterpiece of a book. I'll go ahead and post a link to the book. I'll also PM you with this post.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0942637763/qid=1135820815/sr=8-1/ref=pd_bbs_1/103-4732254-6447032?n=507846&s=books&v=glance

If you have any questions PM or Email me. Good luck

Master Fluffy

DeLamar.J

01-08-2006, 07:01 PM

Ok. I was just curious. Thanks for the info. :)
Where is his school located? It sounds like something definately worth checking out.Akron ohio. I am trying to get in as we speak.

The MMA kid!

01-08-2006, 07:25 PM

here is The MMA kid!'s 2 cents.

just because there isnt a "best" martial art, doesnt mean that some arts are simply obsolete, i believe TKD is obsolete in street fighting/cage fighting.

here is my list

One on one, hand to hand combat- Brazilian Jiu jitsu+striking skills

multiple opponents- Aikido or Run-fu

best stand-up/ no grapple one on one- Muay thai

beauty- Wushu?

relaxation- Tai chi

green meanie

01-08-2006, 08:02 PM

Akron ohio. I am trying to get in as we speak.

Excellent. Keep me posted if you don't mind. I'd be very interested in hearing how it goes.

evenflow1121

01-09-2006, 12:16 AM

That question is right up there with the meaning of life. There are different styles and I would say that all legitimate styles are good, and the answer to your question usually lies with the particular teacher (how realistic their approach to a real life scenario is) and not the style per se.

Kenpojujitsu3

01-10-2006, 07:22 PM

The best style is the one that benefits YOUR life through it's study and appplication.

Corporal Hicks

01-11-2006, 09:02 AM

here is The MMA kid!'s 2 cents.

just because there isnt a "best" martial art, doesnt mean that some arts are simply obsolete, i believe TKD is obsolete in street fighting/cage fighting.

Im not starting another thread here, but just remember that Tae Kwon Do does actually have other applications other than kicking! such as elbow strikes, punching combinations etc etc.
A kick used correctly in a street fight can and will be devistating if applied correctly. If your in a street fight and you say use a kick to the lower knee with a turning (roundhouse) kick and apply it correctly along with maintaining other factors I would say that chances are more than likely your opponents knee will give way.
Im not having a go! I just believe its not as obsolete as some people would choose to believe, but hey, its a matter of opinion and we are all entitiled to that.
If I had to choose a favorite style, I would say, Jeet Kune Do, the only problem being that its not a style its a system. I agree with the other guys here, its what works for you that counts and not what anybody may say work or not!
Good luck with finding a school! Regards

kingkong89

07-30-2006, 07:33 PM

There is no fighting style that is the best. it is all in how the karatika {student] uses the fighting style, someone could think that their opponotes stylie is undergraded than his so h they think nothing of it, it is all in how well you aply your tech.